What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Judiciary News

Buggee

Juniors
Messages
63
John Sutton is free to play.
Eddy Pettybourne will be free to play with an early guilty plea.
Luke Burgess is free to play, although he wont be with his injury.
Issac Luke facing 1 match ban for contrary conduct on Referee Jason Robinson in 31st minute.

All news came from rugby league week twitter.
 

Buggee

Juniors
Messages
63
apparently it was an alleged push on jason robinson, has anybody seen it? i would watch over it myself but i deleted it off IQ..
 

muzby

Village Idiot
Staff member
Messages
45,726
i would have thought sutton was gone for sure.. that was a pretty ordinary tackle..
 
Messages
14,937
John Sutton is free to play.
Eddy Pettybourne will be free to play with an early guilty plea.
Luke Burgess is free to play, although he wont be with his injury.
Issac Luke facing 1 match ban for contrary conduct on Referee Jason Robinson in 31st minute.

All news came from rugby league week twitter.

Top news on Sutto and Eddy/
 

gypsy

Bench
Messages
4,248
I don't understand why people have got it in for Isaac Luke, he only has to sneeze and he gets a few weeks.
 

cleary89

Coach
Messages
16,456
Yeh just saw it. Had to watch the 31st minute 3 times to actually see it. But ran into him on purpose, completely unnecessary. Agree with Dean, lucky to only be getting 1 week.
 

Buggee

Juniors
Messages
63
Can't blame Issac - I'd have done exactly the same thing. Robinson's a f**kwhit.

haha i hate robinson... all souths fans do. but thats just dealt a major blow to our first game of the year. No Issac, possibly no Inglis. two of our best players
 

SaraSassypants

Juniors
Messages
1,447
Good news on all but Luke. Lucky it's only a week. Then again if he was Thurston we wouldn't even be discussing it.
 
Messages
14,937
Luke pushes luck as ref contact attracts charge

Glenn Jackson

February 21, 2012


art-353-B22-20Isaac-20Luke-20ld-20thin-200x0.jpg
Issac Luke is again in hot water. Photo: Getty Images

ISSAC LUKE'S attempts at behavioural reform may have lasted a matter of minutes. In his comeback match from a suspension for a leg twist in the Four Nations tournament, Luke again found himself in hot water with officialdom, this time for allegedly pushing a referee.
Luke was yesterday handed with a contrary conduct charge, following an incident involving referee Jason Robinson during Saturday night's Charity Shield, and faces being suspended for the Rabbitohs' round-one clash with Sydney Roosters. The Rabbitohs will decide today whether to contest the charge - which arose from a 31st-minute incident in the defeat at the hands of the Dragons.
Brisbane prop Petero Civoniceva is the only other player facing a suspension out of the final round of trial matches, having been given a grade-three high tackle charge after a hit on Melbourne's Ryan Hinchcliffe.
Advertisement: Story continues below
While Civoniceva was placed on report, Souths officials did not see the Luke charge coming, only learning their player was being scrutinised after the meeting of match reviewers yesterday. It was alleged that Luke pushed Robinson. Any contact with a referee, whether deliberate or accidental, is heavily scrutinised by the match review committee, and after a lengthy meeting yesterday the panel decided that the contact was worthy of a charge.
Luke, who started the match on the interchange bench, had only just taken the field in his comeback match from a charge dating back to November.
Which means Luke's discipline will again be questioned, at a time the club needs its best players on the park. The charge is another pre-season blow for the Rabbitohs, who were reeling with the news prop Luke Burgess suffered a broken foot at ANZ Stadium, and will be sidelined for about three months. Star centre Greg Inglis suffered an ankle injury in the All Stars clash.
The match review committee yesterday studied footage of the Luke incident and handed the hooker a grade-one contrary conduct charge. The New Zealand international faces a one-match suspension whether he pleads guilty or not.
Even though three other Souths players were placed on report on Saturday night, Luke - who was not reported on the night - was the only Rabbitoh to face suspension.
Second-rower Eddy Pettybourne will escape suspension despite being charged with a grade-one high tackle on St George Illawarra's Chase Stanley.
''We haven't even seen the video,'' chief executive Shane Richardson said. ''I'll wait till tomorrow before I make a comment. I watched the game three times and I didn't notice it.''
Should Luke be suspended, the Rabbitohs will no doubt be aggrieved that Luke had found himself in trouble just moments after taking the field in his return match. Luke had previously promised to work on his tackling technique after a controversial Four Nations tournament. He was formally cautioned after a cannonball tackle on Australian prop David Shillington, and then suspended for his leg twist on Chase.
Luke's comments after his ban further raised eyebrows.
Civoniceva, meanwhile, faces a ban of one or two matches after a tackle on Hinchcliffe which upset Melbourne officials in Hobart. The Broncos must now decide whether to plead guilty, which will hand the veteran front-rower a one-match suspension, or fight the charge.



Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/...acts-charge-20120220-1tjoz.html#ixzz1mwzTbbR6
 
Messages
4,980
I haven't seen this incident specifically, but surely handling the ref is either unintentional ( ie 0 weeks) or intentional. If seemed intentional, the player should get a minimum of 5 weeks. And in this case because it's Luke, he should get an extra 2 weeks because he's a grub
 

Zigwaa

Bench
Messages
2,744
Geez that was a dumb thing to do. He really needs to pull his head, how many times has been said though.
 
Top