Pearl Jam vs Guns N Roses

[Anonymous]

Pearl Jam

First release: 1991 (Ten)
Genre: Alternative Rock

Key CD:

Ten

Key Songs:
- Even Flow
- Alive
- Daughter

Guns N Roses

First release: 1987 (Appetite For Destruction)
Genre: Hard Rock

Key CD:

Appetite For Destruction

Key Songs:
- Sweet Child O Mine
- Welcome to the Jungle
- November Rain

 

[ThrashViking]

Gunners by a looooooong way.

 

[brook]

Its a tough choice - both bands started so well to collapse in a heap.

But at least the gunners collapsed in style, Pearl Jam just keep releasing albums that sound identical every few years.

If they hadn't released anything after vitalogy they may have ended up with my vote...

 

[salivor]

I saw riot act selling for just $4 the other day, enough said :lol: .

 

[Anonymous]

Gunners collapsed? What about Chinese Democracy?

Either way... the Gunners got my vote. Far more talented and far more interesting band.

 

[SpaceMonkey]

I'd vote for a dead heat but as that isn't an option I'll have to abstain on this one. As others have said both bands started off with classics but fizzled out pretty quickly.

 

[Simo]

GNR by the biggest country mile there is!

 

[Trollhammaren]

Never got into the gunners really. I'll give Pearl Jam a pity vote.

 

[madunit]

Gunners get the nod for mine. Pearl Jam never really interested me.

 

[choc_soldier]

Oooh, another toughie.

Umm, Pearl Jam.

 

[greentooth]

I would have to go with Pearl jam, the gunners only had one good album, and thats the one in the picture above. Pearl jam still shreads live, go see em next time they tour here.

 

[Twizzle]

a much better match up than the others

Gunners for me

 

[MILLWALL]

gunners were good but i like pearl jam more cept for pearl jams new sutff its gone downhill plus i hate axl rose

 

[Weasels Ripped My Flesh]

agreed, Axl is a twit

 

[Ron Jeremy]

Gunners by a long way.

Ten was a great album, but as far as i'm concerned there later albums nevee done a single thing for me, where as Gunners as had Use your illusion 1 & 2 after Appetite.

TEN, one of the great albums, but Gunners where alot better IMO.

 

[les norton]

Im an eddie vedder girl from way back!

 

[Booyah]

Stupid Question.

Gunners as far as the eye can see.

That's not to say PJ weren't any good, just that they've got SFA on the Gunners.

 

[Once Dead]

GNFR! That's right - Pearl Jam are just a bunch of whiny wusses compared to the badasses of GNR

 

[Twizzle]

as they all get older they move that little bit closer to thte middle of the road

 

[Green Eye]

as they all get older they move that little bit closer to thte middle of the road

as we all get older...