Rothfield rates Mortimer the 39th....

[Newie is God's Country]

Mortimer may be 39th now but he will be much higher up the list in a couple of years. For now IMO Hayne and Burgess are simply the two most exciting talents in the game. Burgess is going to be THE forward of his era.

 

[Parra Steve]

25, Brett Stewart
24. Ben Hannett
23. Ben Creagh
22. Jared Waerea Hargreaves
21. Cooper Cronk
20. Brett Morris
19. Brett Kimorley
18. Josh Morris
17. Feleti Mateo
16. Sam Burgess
15. Benji Marshall
14. Kurt Gidley
13. Darren Lockyer
12. Robbie Farah
11. Nathan Hindmarsh
10. Fui Fui Moi Moi
9. Michael Jennings
8. Paul Gallen
7. Scott Prince
6. Anthony Watmough
5. Cameron Smith
4. Jonathan Thurston
3. Jarryd Hayne
2. Billy Slater
1. Greg Inglis

http://blogs.news.com.au/dailyteleg...h/comments/buzzs_top_50_nrl_players_part_two/

Here's the rest, How Jared Hargreaves got into number 22 after playing just 6 nrl games is beyond me.

 

[Fathead]

greatest player in todays game in todays edition of the daily telegraph 1/3/2010. I rate the kid and think he is a fantastic player but is everyone getting way ahead of themselves here. The way things are going he will be getting a $500k contract to go with hayne

agreed !!

 

[yy_cheng]

Tally

4 Melb
4 Parra

3 Manly
3 Dogs

2 Saints
2 Tiges

Souths
Knights
Broncs
Penrith
Sharks
Titans
Cowboys

 

[Twizzle]

surprised to see Feleti rated so high

he's never even played any rep footy to my knowledge, other than for Tonga

 

[Ron Jeremy]

but what about the ''equally as talented as Hayne' Inu? lol oh yeah, he needs Tahu to make him rated lol

 

[Twizzle]

you really need to get a new act RJ

this one is getting boring

 

[Voodoo Rock]

that list needs more scotty mahon

 

[84 Baby]

but what about the ''equally as talented as Hayne' Inu? lol oh yeah, he needs Tahu to make him rated lol

because Rothfield has come up with the definitive list of the best players :roll:

 

[Stagger eel]

you really need to get a new act RJ

this one is getting boring

2 penis's walk into a bar, and the barman says...

 

[Qld Shark]

2 penis's walk into a bar, and the barman says...

Sorry we don't serve Eels fans in here!

Couldn't help myself ....I'll leave now:sarcasm:

 

[mickdo]

Sorry we don't serve Eels fans in here!

Couldn't help myself ....I'll leave now:sarcasm:

So the first penis says "that's ok, we're Sharks fans" ;-)

 

[Qld Shark]

So the first penis says "that's ok, we're Sharks fans" ;-)

Haha touche'

 

[johnkolc]

Tally

4 Melb
4 Parra

3 Manly
3 Dogs

2 Saints
2 Tiges

Souths
Knights
Broncs
Penrith
Sharks
Titans
Cowboys

I actually had the tally as:

5 - Parramatta, Melbourne, Canterbury
4 - Souths, St George
3 - Brisbane, Canberra, Manly, Penrith, Wests
2 - Cronulla, Gold Coast, NZ, Newcastle, Nth Qld, Boosters

Either way I'm sure we could all knock one up with pretty much the list of all players that played in and/or were ruled out of the All Stars game. Surely that did most of his hard work for him.

Wonder where he ranks Kevvy Kingston these days?

 

[mickdo]

I actually had the tally as

Yours is the top 50 tally, yy had the top 25 tally

 

[yy_cheng]

I actually had the tally as:

5 - Parramatta, Melbourne, Canterbury
4 - Souths, St George
3 - Brisbane, Canberra, Manly, Penrith, Wests
2 - Cronulla, Gold Coast, NZ, Newcastle, Nth Qld, Boosters

Either way I'm sure we could all knock one up with pretty much the list of all players that played in and/or were ruled out of the All Stars game. Surely that did most of his hard work for him.

Wonder where he ranks Kevvy Kingston these days?

I don't understand.
Then you have

15+
8+
15+
12
= 40 players ????

I was tallying the number of players in the top 25 for each team.

 

[lingard]

Mortimer may be 39th now but he will be much higher up the list in a couple of years. For now IMO Hayne and Burgess are simply the two most exciting talents in the game. Burgess is going to be THE forward of his era.

I think he will be too. But it is far too early for anyone to make that prediction. I agree with you, though. he looks to have the potential to be as good as Arthur Beetson. If we are right, we`ll both be geniuses!
P.S. I`m not as confident about Mortimer. I don`t think he is going to scale the heights that many are predicting. If I`m wrong, I guess I`ll have to go back to being an idiot again. Oh well.

 

[yy_cheng]

I think he will be too. But it is far too early for anyone to make that prediction. I agree with you, though. he looks to have the potential to be as good as Arthur Beetson. If we are right, we`ll both be geniuses!
P.S. I`m not as confident about Mortimer. I don`t think he is going to scale the heights that many are predicting. If I`m wrong, I guess I`ll have to go back to being an idiot again. Oh well.

Not in the short term. I think FUI will still be on top as Fui is starting to throw Sterling passes.

Watch for Fui's chip and chase.