Dirty Reds
Skeptic Ghost
Word count: 713
Comments: Hmmm
nicely written piece about admiring someone who is very special in your life, but it kind of draws a very long bow on its link to rugby league. It only loses marks because it isnt really a rugby league piece; otherwise a strong effort.
Score: 72
Chriswalkerbush
Word count: 749
Comments: Read the whole thing with a smile on my face. A bit brash, certainly uncouth at times, but a nice bit of comedy and true in every sense of the word
especially the Dragons getting kicked out of last years finals.
Score: 92
Andy
Word count: 741
Comments: Injuries
the bane of every team. Some good points raised, although you never really came to a solid conclusion.
Score: 82
PJ Marshal
Word count: 722
Comments: Dont get me wrong, I dislike Gus Gould as much as the next Friday Night Football viewer. But this article is fairly scathing and not particularly constructive and as a result, I think it loses a lot of its effectiveness.
Score: 81
Mr Charisma
Word Count: 739
Comments: A completely surreal article, at times I had little idea what was going on but I loved it anyway. The Roosters fan day is a queer event? Anyway, there were a few spelling and grammatical errors which eroded your score a little bit, but otherwise it was thoroughly enjoyable.
Score: 86
Dirty Red total: 413
Lions
PK
Word count: 746
Comments: Very well written, unique, and though it ended kind of abruptly, you did well given the confines of the word limit. A very entertaining telling of the Mark Geyer story.
Score: 90
Parra_panther
Word count: 750
Comments: Started off very strongly with the sickeningly sarcastic satire of the Roosters place in the NRL. Kind of dropped off a bit after that; still funny though, and I liked the idea of a Brian Smith motivational speech. Since most newspaper articles trail off at the end though, Ill give you the benefit of the doubt on this one overall a good piece of comedy.
Score: 88
Roosterboy60
Word count: 731
Comments: A few minor grammar issues to iron out; otherwise fairly well written. Will rugby league still be around in a hundred years? I have no doubt about it, but I imagine itll be hugely different to the game we watch now.
Score: 82
Everlovin Antichrist
Word count: 748
Comments: A good summary of the situation, strong writing. The Gold Coast definitely seems the best option for expansion for both the NRL and the AFL; lets just hope we get there first.
Score: 87
Mr Rock
Word count: 750
Comments: I definitely do remember the first time I ran out onto the field in the Under 7s
absolute horror best describes it
. Anyway, I digress: a very entertaining article about an often overlooked area of the wonderful sport.
Score: 86
Lions total: 433
Game result:
Lions 433 defeat Dirty Reds 413
Man of the Match: chriswalkerbush