Raider_69 comes off the bench and make immediate impact, brushing past Jed P) on his way to the try line
---------------------------------
State of Foreigners
With the 2005 NRL season well under way, the much anticipated representative season is just around the corner. But with the representative season comes fierce debate. And there is one issue that continues to rage throughout rugby league communities: should we allow foreigners to take part in the pinnacle of the representative season State Of Origin?
This debate was brought about by two young stars and their individual decisions in regard to State Of Origin. On one side, we have young Bulldogs star, Sonny Bill Williams who has stayed true to his heritage and has elected to play for his Kiwis and by-pass the opportunity to represent NSW in State Of Origin. Then on the other side, we have talented young Broncos star Karmichael Hunt, who has turned his back on his New Zealand background for a shot at donning the maroon of Queensland.
These choices have sparked fierce debate amongst experts and die hard fans alike, with the question Should foreigners be able to participate in State Of Origin? still an unanswered one.
Those who are of the belief that they should be eligible for State of Origin will argue that the exclusion of foreigners weakens the all important international game, as players like Karmichael Hunt elect to by-pass their country of origin in order to play in the spectacle that is State Of Origin.
They would ask why players like Karmichael Hunt should have to turn their backs on their country, just for a chance to play in undisputed pinnacle of Rugby League? Why should foreigners be penalised by not being eligible for such an occasion in their sport?
It could also be argued that the addition of such superstars from across the Tasman would only add to the spectacle. I mean, sure, what would be better to see than Adrian Morley running off a short ball from Trent Barrett and offloading to a rampaging Anthony Minichello? And it would be a sight to behold seeing Karmichael Hunt stepping past a couple and linking up with Billy Slater to score a typical Queensland try. Surely there are no losers in this situation, right?
Well in a perfect world this would be true. Unfortunately, this far from a perfect world and there are losers, tradition for one. State of Origin isnt about the individuals involved, its about the pride of two league mad States going toe to toe for bragging rights.
Its this idea that has seen some of the more memorable things ever witnessed in rugby league: Billy Moore screaming QUEENSLANDER as he walked down the tunnel; the famous Queensland miracle try; or what about big Mal Meninga going toe to toe with Blues' centre Mark McGaw? This is not to mention The Chief Harragon and Mark Spud Carroll, bitter club rivals, joining forces to lead a NSW pack against the might of the Queensland juggernaut.
You see, State of Origin is not about pitting the best of best against each other. No, its much more than that. Its the might and power of the NSW Blues doing battle against the passion and never say die attitude of the Maroons. The concept is bigger than the individual. Tinkering with that would conflict the very reason for creating the concept.
Another loser in this would be the hard working Queenslanders and New South Welshmen who may lose their spot, or never even get a shot at this great honour, because their spot is being filled by a foreign player. Has anyone thought of this poor bloke when suggesting this be allowed?
State Of Origin is about the traditional, passionate fight, an epic battle between Queensland and New South Wales. Its a simple concept, and one that has worked for 20 odd years. Theres an old saying that is relevant to this debate, and that is if it aint broke, dont fix it. And as far as I can see the State of Origin concept isnt broken.
I hoped that by the end of this piece you wouldnt need to ask for my answer to the question: Should foreigners be able to participate in State Of Origin? But just in case you are unsure, the answer is simple. "No." Im a passionate Blues supporter and to me it betrays the concept of State Of Origin. Allow this and you might as well call it something else, because it wont be State Of Origin, not to me anyway.
--------------------
Word count: 740 including title