What's new
By:
Advanced search…
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Round 8 vs The Silvertails (Manly)

BxTom

BxTom

Bench
Messages
2,577
This one has me worried. I am a Bathurst regular and it often goes poorly for us.
 
T

The Realist

Juniors
Messages
1,657
franklin2323 said:
Won't be 40 point win but our pack is too good. The defence up the middle is too good
Click to expand...

Don't be so sure. Tigers got carved primarily on the edges. Yes our Defence is far far better but it has vulnerabilities. Capewell has been dropping off tackles regularly and the Luai/Kikau edge at times gets cracked - though they are generally good. Martin when he comes on can also be a little loose.

Manly are on fire and this game will be our biggest test since the Storm. Other than them what we faced so far this year has been rubbish and against some of those rubbish teams we weren't so convincing.
 
franklin2323

franklin2323

Immortal
Messages
33,546
The Realist said:
Don't be so sure. Tigers got carved primarily on the edges. Yes our Defence is far far better but it has vulnerabilities. Capewell has been dropping off tackles regularly and the Luai/Kikau edge at times gets cracked - though they are generally good. Martin when he comes on can also be a little loose.

Manly are on fire and this game will be our biggest test since the Storm. Other than them what we faced so far this year has been rubbish and against some of those rubbish teams we weren't so convincing.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't call beating Warriors, GC and Tigers as much of on fire.

We have played last years premiers, PF side and another top 8 team and have conceded 6 points a game. Defence is our strength and Manly make too many mistakes to keep the pressure on for long periods
 
Fangs

Fangs

Coach
Messages
11,504
Can't win every game but think we are all good in this one. Got a decent turn around Thursday-Saturday.

I'll be interested to see how we handle Tom. He is close to the best player in the competition right now. Burton/Crichton will get challenged at some point.
 
Mr. Shaman

Mr. Shaman

First Grade
Messages
6,611
franklin2323 said:
I wouldn't call beating Warriors, GC and Tigers as much of on fire.

We have played last years premiers, PF side and another top 8 team and have conceded 6 points a game. Defence is our strength and Manly make too many mistakes to keep the pressure on for long periods
Click to expand...

Prior to the Warriors game v Storm 6/7 of our opponents had been in the Top 8, 3 wins is a good effort for a team as shit as ours. We are on fire, but got to keep in mind we’re shit.
 
age.s

age.s

First Grade
Messages
7,048
franklin2323 said:
I wouldn't call beating Warriors, GC and Tigers as much of on fire.

We have played last years premiers, PF side and another top 8 team and have conceded 6 points a game. Defence is our strength and Manly make too many mistakes to keep the pressure on for long periods
Click to expand...

They didn't just beat GC and Wests, they destroyed them in a way you'd expect from a very good team.

Like you I think we'll get home. Their defence won't get the kind of relief that naturally comes from putting 40 on. But this isn't the same team we played a month ago. Turbo alone gives us much more to worry about defensively and their general morale/attitude will be light years from what it was. Realist is right, this should be a real test.
 
franklin2323

franklin2323

Immortal
Messages
33,546
age.s said:
They didn't just beat GC and Wests, they destroyed them in a way you'd expect from a very good team.

Like you I think we'll get home. Their defence won't get the kind of relief that naturally comes from putting 40 on. But this isn't the same team we played a month ago. Turbo alone gives us much more to worry about defensively and their general morale/attitude will be light years from what it was. Realist is right, this should be a real test.
Click to expand...

They had 53% of the ball v GC and still missed 30 tackles. GC missed 23.
Again yesterday they had 14 errors to WT 9.

That is the difference between mid table and top teams right there. 1 or 2 individual performances can get you home against mid sides whereas v top you need to do everything right
 
franklin2323

franklin2323

Immortal
Messages
33,546
Mr. Shaman said:
Prior to the Warriors game v Storm 6/7 of our opponents had been in the Top 8, 3 wins is a good effort for a team as shit as ours. We are on fire, but got to keep in mind we’re shit.
Click to expand...

2 or 3 shit teams will make the 8. You guys are every chance of being one if Tom Turbo stays fit. Not sure if like GC or Newcastle you guys can compete with the top 5 of the comp.

Good test to see where you improved across the board. As for us a loss will come at some stage
 
Jane Murray

Jane Murray

Bench
Messages
2,837
RED-HOT PANTHERS WILL CAUSE HEADACHES FOR CLEARY

Young Panthers winger Brian To’o is set to steal the crown from Roger Tuivasa-Sheck as the NRL’s biggest metre-eater. While his insane form has helped Penrith win seven straight this season, it could also cause coach Ivan Cleary some headaches come State of Origin time.

Tuivasa-Sheck averaged 215 running metres per game in 2015 — the most on record since Fox Sports Lab started collecting such statistics. However, 22-year-old Panthers winger Brian To’o is currently averaging 232 running metres per game and if he can keep up the same mammoth efforts we’ve seen every round so far this season, he’ll no doubt surpass Tuivasa-Sheck’s record.

To’o shone in Penrith’s win last week, finishing with 246 run metres. He then stunned the league world by going to another level on Thursday night, racking up an astonishing career-high 290 metres against the Knights.

Last week Panthers coach Ivan Cleary threw his support behind the workhorse winger for a State of Origin debut.

Now Cleary has conceded his team is going to look very different come Origin time given just how in-form his star players are. Nathan Cleary, Isaah Yeo and Kurt Capewell all played Origin last season, while Jarome Luai and Stephen Crichton were also included in NSW’s extended squad. But Origin was at the end of last season so it didn’t have any impact on Penrith’s premiership campaign.

This year, Origin returns to mid-season and will see heavyweights like the Storm, Roosters and the Panthers lose their best players.

Incumbent halfback Cleary will once again wear the Blues’ No.7 jersey, while his Panthers halves partner Luai should come into serious contention for an Origin debut. Isaah Yeo should hold his spot in the NSW squad and Stephen Crichton and Brian To’o will be pushing for debuts also. Meanwhile, utility Kurt Capewell will be called up to play for Queensland after emerging as a Maroons hero after last year’s series.

“We’ve got a few things to deal with this year that we didn’t have to last year,” Cleary said.

“Origin will look different for us, but at the moment we’re going along pretty well, so (I’m) happy.”



800649_640x360_large_20210422224730.jpg
 
mxlegend99

mxlegend99

Referee
Messages
23,052
Jane Murray said:
RED-HOT PANTHERS WILL CAUSE HEADACHES FOR CLEARY

Young Panthers winger Brian To’o is set to steal the crown from Roger Tuivasa-Sheck as the NRL’s biggest metre-eater. While his insane form has helped Penrith win seven straight this season, it could also cause coach Ivan Cleary some headaches come State of Origin time.

Tuivasa-Sheck averaged 215 running metres per game in 2015 — the most on record since Fox Sports Lab started collecting such statistics. However, 22-year-old Panthers winger Brian To’o is currently averaging 232 running metres per game and if he can keep up the same mammoth efforts we’ve seen every round so far this season, he’ll no doubt surpass Tuivasa-Sheck’s record.

To’o shone in Penrith’s win last week, finishing with 246 run metres. He then stunned the league world by going to another level on Thursday night, racking up an astonishing career-high 290 metres against the Knights.

Last week Panthers coach Ivan Cleary threw his support behind the workhorse winger for a State of Origin debut.

Now Cleary has conceded his team is going to look very different come Origin time given just how in-form his star players are. Nathan Cleary, Isaah Yeo and Kurt Capewell all played Origin last season, while Jarome Luai and Stephen Crichton were also included in NSW’s extended squad. But Origin was at the end of last season so it didn’t have any impact on Penrith’s premiership campaign.

This year, Origin returns to mid-season and will see heavyweights like the Storm, Roosters and the Panthers lose their best players.

Incumbent halfback Cleary will once again wear the Blues’ No.7 jersey, while his Panthers halves partner Luai should come into serious contention for an Origin debut. Isaah Yeo should hold his spot in the NSW squad and Stephen Crichton and Brian To’o will be pushing for debuts also. Meanwhile, utility Kurt Capewell will be called up to play for Queensland after emerging as a Maroons hero after last year’s series.

“We’ve got a few things to deal with this year that we didn’t have to last year,” Cleary said.

“Origin will look different for us, but at the moment we’re going along pretty well, so (I’m) happy.”



800649_640x360_large_20210422224730.jpg
Click to expand...
Assuming everyone makes it:

1. Edwards
2. Rennings
3. Naden / salmon
4. Momirovski
5. Staines
6. May
7. Burton
8. Jfh
9. Api
10. Leota
11. Martin
12. Kikau
13. Kenny

14. Leniu
15. Eisenhuth
16. Hopgood
17. Sorensen

Salmon if missing out on starting side might drop back to bench to have a utility. I mean its unlikely we will have that many reps but if we did we still have a solid team.

We face Tigers before Origin 1 and that side is probably good enough to match them at their best currently. Although it wouldn't have much cohesion and that would be the area it suffers in. But id back us as 50/50 in that game.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Top