Seasons most underated/overated

[roostergirl]

Willow how can say that the Aus selectors prefer Craig Wing?? Joey then Sherwin then Wing would be there choices.

 

[MistyBee9-11]

Well, considering where they were at the start of the year, what they expected to do, and what they ended up doing - here's my thoughts.

OVERRATED:
Brian Smith
Preston Campbell
Bred Drew
George Piggins

UNDERRATED
Stacey Jones
Craig Fitzgibbon
Brad Fittler
Ricky Stuart

 

[Willow]

OK RG, I take it back, Craig Wing is the best... way up there with Justin Hodges.
I think Hodges rates Hodges very highly.

 

[roostergirl]

Willow, don't patronise me.....we all know how much you hate the Roosters and how hard it would be for you to say something nice about any aspect of the club, team whatever

 

[Willow]

I dont hate the Roosters. They're sort of middly in my ratings. There are a number of clubs which are ahead in that regard... Sharks, Broncos, Storm, Bulldogs, Souths.. Idon't think I have enough room for Easts.

 

[imported_Pugs]

Overrated : Pat Richards & Eric Growth Jnr. Where are they now ??? Neville nobodies

Underrated: Brett Kimmorely, Craig Fitzgibbon

 

[MistyBee9-11]

Can't do much to enhance your reputation when you are injured, Pugs.

Richards will be back next year, bigger and better than ever. Grothe? I dunno....

 

[imported_JoeD]

Pugs, how can 2 guys who play for australia be underrated?

 

[Willow]

Perhaps they are overated moreso because they were selected to play for Australia.
Current example: B Tate.

 

[imported_Roopy4246]

I have been a great critic of Tate's from his first game, but Bronco convinced me in the chatroom the other day that I am being a bit unfair. All he said was 'he's young, he can learn' and I have to agree with that. He seems to have lots of natural ability but he is tackle shy and is often out of position. He might be a great player some day, but at the moment he doesn't deserve to be in the Aussie side.

 

[imported_MrAngryOne]

Over-rated - Braith Anasta, he is a good player but Sherwin carried him.
Every single back


Under-rated - the Roosters pack
All forwards - back are NOTHING without them.