Who would win?

[eloquentEEL]

Ok, total fantasy world here, but a game I'd love to see some time between now and the beginning of next year is as follows:

Confirmed/Rumoured players leaving:
1. Hodgson
2. Moodie
3. Tonga
4. Richards
5. Prince
6. S.Witt
7. Green?
8. Heckenberg
9. Irvine?
10.Chan
11.Treacy?
12.Solomona?
13.Crouch

14.Dunley
15.Wheeler?
16.Boyd?
17.Cleal

? = rumoured
______________________________

vs.
______________________________
Confirmed/Rumoured new signings since mid-year + NRL debutants that have been re-signed:
1. McKinnon
2. Roberts**/Clarke**
3. Kativerata
4. Halliday
5. Grothe
6. Thorman
7. M.Witt *
8. Pearson
9. Webster*
10.Cannings
11.Muckert
12.Armit *
13.Muspratt

14.Tsoulos *
15.Stapleton
16.Moi Moi
17.Fitzgerald**/Nightingale

* NRL Debutant re-signed
** Rumoured


So who do you think would win?

 

[Freak]

Draw

 

[eloquentEEL]

Are you saying it would still be a draw after extra time?

 

[Ron Jeremy]

Players leaving would win very comfortably....32-14 after leading 18-8 at half time! 8)

 

[bartman]

But players leaving would look silly all wearing the different jerseys of their new clubs... or playing naked if they're retiring!

At least all our new signings would look the part of a team in our uniform...

 

[PARRA_FAN]

Ok, total fantasy world here, but a game I'd love to see some time between now and the beginning of next year is as follows:

Confirmed/Rumoured players leaving:
1. Hodgson
2. Moodie
3. Tonga
4. Richards
5. Prince
6. S.Witt
7. Green?
8. Heckenberg
9. Irvine?
10.Chan
11.Treacy?
12.Solomona?
13.Crouch

14.Dunley
15.Wheeler?
16.Boyd?
17.Cleal

? = rumoured
______________________________

vs.
______________________________
Confirmed/Rumoured new signings since mid-year + NRL debutants that have been re-signed:
1. McKinnon
2. Roberts**/Clarke**
3. Kativerata
4. Halliday
5. Grothe
6. Thorman
7. M.Witt *
8. Pearson
9. Webster*
10.Cannings
11.Muckert
12.Armit *
13.Muspratt

14.Tsoulos *
15.Stapleton
16.Moi Moi
17.Fitzgerald**/Nightingale

* NRL Debutant re-signed
** Rumoured


So who do you think would win?

Solomona is staying for another season

The leaving team is good one, especially Dunley and Steve Witt.