Worst Signing in recent history?

[Lynch]

Joe Williams Halfback for numerous clubs was signed by the Dogs to fill the void in the creative playmaking position.
Although some initial sparks at the Rabbitohs in his career he consistintly failed to make the starting squad throughout his career.
Also being notoriusly inconsistent why did Folkes and GM think he could lead your team off the bottom of the ladder?
Also leaking players of the quality of Kane Cleal (now heading to the rabbits are only hurting ur side).
Kane played some quality football for u guys..
anyway rate the decision to sign Williams, could he ever fill the void at Halfback?

 

[dogz08]

Probably our worse signing ever..

 

[thehattrickrabbit]

Probably our worse signing ever..

Craig Trindall ?

 

[Capt. Awesome Sauce]

Probably our worse signing ever..

Brett Kimmorley....




ENJOY!

 

[Dave Q]

Brett Kimmorley....




ENJOY!

lol

 

[Bulldog Force]

Worst Signing? Ben Chicorollski.

 

[dogz08]

Brett Kimmorley....




ENJOY!

We will

 

[Bulldog Force]

Kimmorley is playing better football now because he doesn't have to worry about trying to impress for origin anymore. It's been proven that when long-term rep players retire from rep footy, their club game improves. The likes of Brad Fittler, Gordon Tallis and Tonie Carroll are fine examples.

 

[Hanscholo]

Brett Kimmorley....




ENJOY!

Was actually in here looking for this...

 

[Big Pete]

I'd say you're right in regards to Fittler but your use of Tallis and Carroll are way off the mark.

Tallis didn't have the best 04 from memory. Some fine performances here and there but hardly the player he was pre-neck injury.

While Carroll's best year was in 06/07 when he was a feature for Queensland.

Webcke on the other hand is a perfect substitute. When he announced his retirement from represenative football in 2005 he lifted his game enormously and the Broncos would win games off of the back of his efforts. As soon as he'd leave the field, the Broncos would clock off.

 

[Hanscholo]

Kimmorley is playing better football now because he doesn't have to worry about trying to impress for origin anymore. It's been proven that when long-term rep players retire from rep footy, their club game improves. The likes of Brad Fittler, Gordon Tallis and Tonie Carroll are fine examples.

Id argue that is wrong. Kimmorely played his best football when he was competing against johns for the NSW 7. Ever since then he has fallen away.

 

[murraymob]

worst signings recently for penrith would be a tie between ritchie williams and brendon worth

 

[Lynch]

worst signings recently for penrith would be a tie between ritchie williams and brendon worth

And the fact that there is a mass exodus leaving the club...:lol:
Although im glad Lewis stayed coz that would of disrupted souths rebuilding phase (at 5/8 and #7) and im not even sure ur former fullback will even make the starting team...:roll:
#1-merrit
#2-talanoa
#3-Simpson
#4-Colin/Gordon
#5-Colin

 

[murraymob]

wesser would not have made first grade next year lachlan coote has him covered both in speed and ability but good luck to him he could be a good signing for the bunnies