What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumoured/Confirmed Signings and More Crap XVII

Status
Not open for further replies.

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
95,031
Was Anderson responsible for 2010 as well? Why didn't his master coaching work then? All 3P's fault?

Why was no other club interested in him?

You're happy to throw everyone under the bus but make endless excuses for Daniel Anderson.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
156,425
DA is this forums sacred cow, I think tactically he is a very good coach.

Casper was spot on, his rope a dope on Bennett in 09 was pure genius.

His man management and recruitment left a lot to be desired IMO, and the reason he is no longer coaching.
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
79,164
It's stupid to judge a coach in his first season at a club, at least on team results. Even the second season is tainted by a mostly inherited team. Early in his tenure at a club it's best to judge a coach on off field factors, which the fans generally aren't privy to.

pretty sure coaches aren't on the field anyway - most of em are a bit older

#justSayin
 

oldmancraigy

Coach
Messages
12,069
DA is this forums sacred cow, I think tactically he is a very good coach.

Casper was spot on, his rope a dope on Bennett in 09 was pure genius.

His man management and recruitment left a lot to be desired IMO, and the reason he is no longer coaching.

I agree with this sentiment.

I just don't know if it is true? They wept and tore their clothing when he left England. And they wept and tore their clothing when he got the sack here (the players that is). I don't think his 2010 performances were aided by being under pressure from the backroom all year, and the 2 overpriced players he punted stirred up trouble.

I can see how one could spin it nicely for him, but personally I agree exactly with what you say. Super tactician, crap manager.
 

TheRam

Coach
Messages
13,911
Well if Trent Merrin is not wrapped up by Saints by the October deadline, then I think we would have rocks in our head if we don't go after him real hard. He would be one of the best signings this club has ever done. This is exactly the type of player we are totally lacking and desperately need.

He is the best offloading young backrower in the comp and we just don't have anyone at the club right now that can give us second faze ball which is a huge reason we become one dimensional a lot of the time.

If Watmough gets $600 000 and we can't offer Merrin that sort of money, then the coach has no idea. Merrin at the top of his game, Watmough is the shadow man of his former self.

http://www.news.com.au/sport/nrl/st...d-out-of-dragons/story-fndv36r0-1227060580715
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
35,514
I'm hearing you Ram but I can't see Merrin leaving. If we wanted controlled aggression we should have gone after Ashton Sims before he committed to the UK Super League.
 

Joely01

Bench
Messages
4,553
DA is this forums sacred cow, I think tactically he is a very good coach.

Casper was spot on, his rope a dope on Bennett in 09 was pure genius.

His man management and recruitment left a lot to be desired IMO, and the reason he is no longer coaching.

I think this man management thing is a total myth, Most players weren't happy he was sacked.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
79,465
Heard a merkin on Sky News say last night that Watmough has played his last game for Manly (predicting that without Watmough they are no chance). Looking at their side in the middle they look very thin.

8. Jason King
9. Jayden Hodges
10. Brenton Lawrence
11. Tom Symonds
12. Justin Horo
13. Dunamis Lui

Interchange

14. Jesse Sene-Lefao
15. Cheyse Blair
16. James Hasson
17. Josh Starling

Same merkin said that there are at least 6 manly players (including Watmough) that have not spoken to DCE for 6 months.
 

oldmancraigy

Coach
Messages
12,069
That is because they play on the other side of the field Gronk...

Pack is thin against the big Bulldogs. They need Horo and Symonds to have the games of their lives
 
Messages
13,894
Heard a merkin on Sky News say last night that Watmough has played his last game for Manly (predicting that without Watmough they are no chance). Looking at their side in the middle they look very thin.

8. Jason King
9. Jayden Hodges
10. Brenton Lawrence
11. Tom Symonds
12. Justin Horo
13. Dunamis Lui

Interchange

14. Jesse Sene-Lefao
15. Cheyse Blair
16. James Hasson
17. Josh Starling

Same merkin said that there are at least 6 manly players (including Watmough) that have not spoken to DCE for 6 months.
Where do they get this shit from, i have seen Watmough and DCE speak during a game, once at a scrum and another time Watmough was giving it to him for missing a simple one on one tackle that lead to try.
 

84 Baby

Immortal
Messages
31,074
2009 Round 26 Win Jubilee Oval
Dragons 37 Eels 0
The following week Win Jubilee Oval Qualifying Final
Eels 25 Dragons 12
Sure DA can't coach...... :lol::lol:
It was all Jarryd Hayne's doing.... :lol::lol:
Wayne Bennett being his opposition :lol:

Honestly can't believe people think we intentionally went out to lose that game, when we weren't even guaranteed to be playing St George first week of final even if we lost (Bulldogs only had to not lose their game) and if we had won, we would have finished 7th but at the time of playing our round 26 game we were still a chance of finishing as high as 5th (under old finals format which meant a potentially 'safer' first week of finals).

It wasn't a coaching masterclass, it was pure coincidence
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
95,031
Don't forget the Bulldogs offered big money to Mortimer so we wouldn't be able to afford to keep Keating. :roll:

How f**ken dumb are some merkins?
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
79,465
jarryd hayne ‏@jarrydhayne_1 17m Cya Sydney
2708.png
LA bound! Going to learn from the best!!

Sounds like a KRudd junket.
 

Joshuatheeel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
20,792
Honestly can't believe people think we intentionally went out to lose that game, when we weren't even guaranteed to be playing St George first week of final even if we lost (Bulldogs only had to not lose their game) and if we had won, we would have finished 7th but at the time of playing our round 26 game we were still a chance of finishing as high as 5th (under old finals format which meant a potentially 'safer' first week of finals).

It wasn't a coaching masterclass, it was pure coincidence

There was an article about it a long time ago - they didn't tank it but Anderson didn't bother putting any game plans in place for the game knowing he had to play them the week after and winning the game wouldn't achieve anything for us.

Notice the following week in the semis how the defence on the edges changed in particular Reddys/Grothe side, grothe came in and reddy took the winger, it helped stopped the dragons main set play quite a few times. Don't tell me Anderson just thought of this the week after round 26.
 

84 Baby

Immortal
Messages
31,074
There was an article about it a long time ago - they didn't tank it but Anderson didn't bother putting any game plans in place for the game knowing he had to play them the week after and winning the game wouldn't achieve anything for us.

Notice the following week in the semis how the defence on the edges changed in particular Reddys/Grothe side, grothe came in and reddy took the winger, it helped stopped the dragons main set play quite a few times. Don't tell me Anderson just thought of this the week after round 26.

I think the article is a myth. I remember a lot of people speculating it was the case, but I never read quote from Ando. And I question how much game planning you are going to do in round 26 anyway. Plus as I said the results of 4 other games that round, all occurring after our game, had a direct result on where we finished, so any plan on playing St George in finals was too reliant on luck to be a real plan.

Any improvement in Reddy & Grothe was probably because rather than watch Dragons' attack on video, they experienced it firsthand the week before.

The extent I think to which it was likely tanked was individual players not focused on the game (long winning streak, already made finals and all that) and no game plan was likely just 2nd half when we already down something like 3 or 4 tries. I believe the turnaround was because it was finals so players were more focused (forwards were faster at beginning of game), we had seen their game style the week before, and Dragons were probably a little lulled after winning, but I doubt extremely so that it was any great plan by Anderson.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Top