What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Cherry Evans

ram raid

Bench
Messages
4,074
Is it possible everyone has overrated DCE and underrated Foran for years?

I'm going with this. Of course, it compliments my biases (hate manly / love parra) so it's hard to say in what ways heart and head are affecting my judgement.
 

nick87

Coach
Messages
12,612
Trent Barrett isn't impressing early doors as a coach
The team looks as if they have no idea what they are doing.
 

Rabbits20

Immortal
Messages
42,381
I feel for walker, he is having a crack but just isn't a 5/8.

DCE is a complete joke. Playing like a guy who has signed a 10 year $10million contract. Completely unbelievable from Manly, guy has zero motivation.

Well he went to Manly as he wanted to play 5/8 and he thought he was good enough.

I don't feel for him.

He is a centre. Obviously he's too stubborn to admit that and too full of himself.

Correct re DCE. DCE is just lazy.

I can't believe with 4-5mins left he didn't know it was the last. How amateurish. That from DCE was Newcastle type play:lol:

Anyway I am happy to see Moanly struggling.
 

Rabbits20

Immortal
Messages
42,381
That bloke who left my club was never any good anyway

At centre yes he was very good. He isn't a 5/8. Souths played him there a few times and he failed.

If Moanly persist with him there they will see eventually.

Manly seem to be having trouble out wide too. They are getting exposed.
 

Rabbits20

Immortal
Messages
42,381
Souths actually aren't missing Dylan.

Hunt has the goods it looks like and Goodwin has lifted. We've got Auva'a too.
 

blaza88z

Coach
Messages
15,225
They made a big mistake signing him for that long for that much money, his motivation right now will be at all time low and let's be honest.. he's always had a world class half outside of him
 

RufusRex

Post Whore
Messages
65,556
Barrett has the Hagan stare.

picture.php
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
24,331
Needs a competent 5/8 to help take the pressure off. Walker ain't it.

For 10 million DCE should be playing both spots.

Ever since he raped the titans emotionally as a negotiating tactic I have not liked this guy but I always thought he was a gun and Foran was slightly overrated.
 

Incorrect

Coach
Messages
13,210
Early days still, but I think Lyon to 6 and Walker to the centres needs to happen as a matter of urgency. Not only for Walker but perhaps also for Lyon, he ain't as quick as used to be and the tigers outside backs were continually getting on the outside of Manly's 3/4's on both sides of the field last night... Lyon has done a reasonable job at 6 in his stints there in the past. Better than Walker is managing at the moment anyway...

As I said, early days at this stage. After round 3 last year the Cows were winless and the Knights were top of the table! Things can change... Barrett needs to tweak a few things though, no doubt.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
73,752
Signs were there in Origin that he isn't the wonder kid most were claiming. Given how he shafted the Titans he is going to generate little sympathy and lots of mirth if he falls on his face with that massive pay packet in his back pocket. Always interesting when a quality half back pairing breaks up to see who was carrying who.
 
Messages
15,545
Early days still, but I think Lyon to 6 and Walker to the centres needs to happen as a matter of urgency. Not only for Walker but perhaps also for Lyon, he ain't as quick as used to be and the tigers outside backs were continually getting on the outside of Manly's 3/4's on both sides of the field last night... Lyon has done a reasonable job at 6 in his stints there in the past. Better than Walker is managing at the moment anyway...

As I said, early days at this stage. After round 3 last year the Cows were winless and the Knights were top of the table! Things can change... Barrett needs to tweak a few things though, no doubt.

I remember making the call early last year that Milford looked all at sea as a 5/8 and would be playing fullback before too long so yeah, things can definitely change...

However, Walker had a run of two or three games at 5/8 for Souths last year and looked to be utter balls. He's now had a full preseason training there with Manly and hasn't improved at all. I think it's safe to say that he's not a 5/8.

Will be interesting to see what happens. As mentioned, Lyon doesn't want to shift in. Could we potentially see Brett Stewart in the halves when he comes back? Walker goes ok at fullback but I really doubt this will happen either. The way things are looking at the moment, if Lyon won't shift then Walker could be coming off the bench in some sort of utility role or could even be playing NSW cup before too long.

If he doesn't work at 5/8 then he has nowhere else to play in that full strength back line. He is a poor fit for Manly at this stage.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
73,752
Can a top quality 7 cover for a avg 6? Cronk seems to have done it at Melbourne, he's had a number of pretty avg 6's alongside him over the years but has Smith who controls a lot of the game. Anyone else in recent times that has carried the team from 7 with little at 6?
 

Latest posts

Top