2025 Match Review & Judiciary charges

[League Unlimited News]

 

[I Bleed Maroon]

No surprise. Was the best choice to make. We will miss him but he could probably do with a couple of weeks off.

 

[yobbo84]

Does anyone actually believe suspensions serve as any form deterrent for accidental high tackles, hip drops, etc?

Do people think the week off would make Carrigan go "hmm, if we make the GF, maybe I won't rush out as hard".

Please.

He 100% deserved a suspension under the system we've got, but I don't like the system we've got.

 

[Desert Qlder]

The NRL are definitely in legal preservation mode with their methods of acting on 'illegal' play.

It seems primarily aimed for future defenses.

 

[Chins]

Does anyone actually believe suspensions serve as any form deterrent for accidental high tackles, hip drops, etc?

Do people think the week off would make Carrigan go "hmm, if we make the GF, maybe I won't rush out as hard".

Please.

He 100% deserved a suspension under the system we've got, but I don't like the system we've got.

Accidents in tackling being punished more than a headbutts, where the only thing the player is doing to trying to assault someone is wild.

Where is the logic in that?


*For consistencies sake I'm glad Walsh got what pretty much everyone has for the last few years but how about we sort this shit?

 

[Maximus]

Accidents in tackling being punished more than a headbutts, where the only thing the player is doing to trying to assault someone is wild.

Where is the logic in that?


*For consistencies sake I'm glad Walsh got what pretty much everyone has for the last few years but how about we sort this shit?

Presumably it started with a protected species getting a fine, now it's a bit hard to punish any player adequately for the same thing.

 

[Trifili13]

Presumably it started with a protected species getting a fine, now it's a bit hard to punish any player adequately for the same thing.

The NRL should rule a line under this and say any future headbutts are a send off and will get a suspension. They might occur in the heat of the moment but are not accidents unlike the rubbish suspensions for accidental slaps across the head or so called hip drops.

 

[League Unlimited News]

https://leagueunlimited.com//news/43111-nrl-match-review-and-judiciary-charges-2025-fw2-nrlw-fw1/

Saturday​

Canberra v Cronulla​

Toby Rudolf (Sharks)​

Grade 1 High Tackle - Careless on Tapine Joseph (22nd minute)
Base penalty: $1,500
1st Offence
-- Early Plea: $1,000
-- Guilty at Panel: $1,500
PLEA: Monday 12pm

Billy Burns (Sharks)​

Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Stuart Jed (43rd minute)
Base penalty: $1,500
1st Offence
-- Early Plea: $1,000
-- Guilty at Panel: $1,500
PLEA: Monday 12pm

Zac Hosking (Raiders)​

Grade 1 High Tackle - Careless on Bralley Blayke (59th minute)
Base penalty: $1,500
2nd Offence
-- Early Plea: $1,800
-- Guilty at Panel: $2,500
PLEA: Monday 12pm

 

[League Unlimited News]

Sunday​

Canterbury v Penrith​

Kurt Mann (Bulldogs)​

Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Nathan Cleary (33rd minute)
Base penalty: $1,500
2nd Offence
-- Early Plea: $1,800
-- Guilty at Panel: $2,500
PLEA: Monday 12pm

Nathan Cleary (Panthers)​

Grade 1 High Tackle - Careless on Connor Tracey (52nd minute)
Base penalty: $1,500
1st Offence
-- Early Plea: $1,000
-- Guilty at Panel: $1,500
PLEA: Monday 12pm

Brad Schneider (Panthers)​

Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Sitili Tupouniua (67th minute)
Base penalty: $1,500
1st Offence
-- Early Plea: $1,000
-- Guilty at Panel: $1,500
PLEA: Monday 12pm

​

 

[Vic Mackey]

Sunday​

Canterbury v Penrith​

​

Brad Schneider (Panthers)​

Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Sitili Tupouniua (67th minute)
Base penalty: $1,500
1st Offence
-- Early Plea: $1,000
-- Guilty at Panel: $1,500
PLEA: Monday 12pm

​

Penrith should fight it and hope it gets upgraded so he misses a game

 

[soc123_au]

Schneider on Sitili was grade 3 at least. MRC hates us

 

[age.s]

Brad Schneider (Panthers)
Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Sitili Tupouniua (67th minute)
Base penalty: $1,500
1st Offence
-- Early Plea: $1,000
-- Guilty at Panel: $1,500
PLEA: Monday 12pm

f**king hell what a joke. This system is f**ked.

 

[yobbo84]

Logged on to make the same joke already made 3 times before me. My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined.

 

[mxlegend99]

Logged on to make the same joke already made 3 times before me. My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined.

Schneider only getting a fine ruined my day too. f**k the NRL.

 

[soc123_au]

Logged on to make the same joke already made 3 times before me. My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined.

The fact that it was a beeline for everyone to get in on the joke makes it even more bizarre that Ivan picks him. Only explanation is the Silver Fox is just waving his big old slug at everyone and no one has worked out yet that it's the ultimate flex, even more than just running with 16.

 

[League Unlimited News]

https://leagueunlimited.com/news/43133-nrl-match-review-and-judiciary-charges-2025-fw3-nrlw-fw2/

Melbourne v Cronulla​

Trent Loiero (Storm)​

Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Nicho Hynes (11th minute)
Base penalty: $1,500
1st Offence
-- Early Plea: $1,000
-- Guilty at Panel: $1,500
PLEA: 12pm Monday

 

[League Unlimited News]

Sunday​

Brisbane v Penrith​

Xavier Willison (Broncos)​

Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Luke Garner (26th minute)
Base penalty: $1,500
1st Offence
-- Early Plea: $1,000
-- Guilty at Panel: $1,500
PLEA: Monday 12pm

Liam Martin (Panthers)​

Grade 1 Contrary Conduct on Ezra Mam (55th minute)
Base penalty: $1,500
1st Offence
-- Early Plea: $1,000
-- Guilty at Panel: $1,500
PLEA: Monday 12pm

 

[no name]

If Willison’s was in round 5 what would he get?
It would have sucked for him if he missed the GF, but that was an awful tackle and shit like that needs to be rubbed out.

 

[lockyno1]

If Willison’s was in round 5 what would he get?
It would have sucked for him if he missed the GF, but that was an awful tackle and shit like that needs to be rubbed out.

waa as soft as butter I did laugh how the big galah got up after having a fake like a soccer player. If you are that injured get off the field

 

[Chins]

That tackle on Garner is the worst of it's kind I've seen in years. Very lucky he hit him from directly behind.