Bazal
Post Whore
- Messages
- 110,182
Pitch was fine, batting was absolutely shite
Correct.
People are so used to flat dead tracks in the modern era that the minute there's a degree or two of seam movement it's an outrage.
Pitch was fine, batting was absolutely shite
Was a 250 pitch and that's ok sometimes. Sure the balance was tipped towards the bowlers but not to the degree that people are carrying on about.Correct.
People are so used to flat dead tracks in the modern era that the minute there's a degree or two of seam movement it's an outrage.
There have been no accusations of cheating or pitch doctoring, though.The whole of the Australian cricketing world has criticised the Melbourne pitch.
But “racism”.
There have been no accusations of cheating or pitch doctoring, though.
It's the same as when one of our athletes is caught using PEDs, it's always "a mistake" or "a headache tablet".
And 36 wickets in 2 days and zero half centuries is not fine.
This reads like you looked at the score and watched none of the gameThere have been no accusations of cheating or pitch doctoring, though.
It's the same as when one of our athletes is caught using PEDs, it's always "a mistake" or "a headache tablet".
And 36 wickets in 2 days and zero half centuries is not fine.
There have been no accusations of cheating or pitch doctoring, though.
It's the same as when one of our athletes is caught using PEDs, it's always "a mistake" or "a headache tablet".
And 36 wickets in 2 days and zero half centuries is not fine.

He added: “Our responsibility is to provide a pitch with good balance between bat and ball. We just weren’t able to do that.”
Has anyone interviewed Khawaja about the deck day 1 ?![]()
If they want tests to last longer than 2-3 days, pick batsmen who can last more than 5-10 minutes.
no shit
so why did you leave 11mm of grass on the pitch, which is double the normal preparation ?
dumb
They explained that.
This is the biggest storm in a teacup since we handed out year long bans for something Indian, Pakistani, English and South African blokes got a match off for. If even two or three blokes had some bits and some technique, we'd be watching the third innings today with about 500 total on the board across the first two.
We will obviously disagree on that but I noticed you said "if", and that would be a huge if. The fact is it didn't happen and 4 innings averaged 122 and by their own admission, the groundsman said the pitch was not up to it.
12 run pitch is not what we should be playing test matches on. A sorting pitch is generally around 250 runs, which I like much more than 500 run pitches.
There are quiet a lot of media, and ex players, all havng a whinge about a test being finished by 5.30 on day 2, and I've not seen anyone blame the batsmen.
It was a pitch that seamed a bit. How many batsmen would you say got out to genuinely unplayable balls?
Well then we're never going to even come close cos I can think of maybe 2 or 3 that were due to the pitch IMO....I would say about 60% to 70% were due to the pitch. What is also important to note is how many plays and misses ?
For example, I saw comments on Oozie's dismissal. The ball got big on him very quickly, as he went from a pull shot to having to play a hook shot and took his eyes off the ball as it reared on him, then he had to play a hurried hook shot that went in the air. I dont believe that was his intention as the ball approached him, and he's usually pretty good on the pull shot. I put that down to the pitch, yet some said it was just a poor shot.
I get what you are saying with the media but if you recall, I posted a comment early on day 1 on the pitch and the length of the grass, with a link to AI, that said it was double what it should be so I formed that opinion about 2 days before the media outrage was posted, so in this case I was just using them as back up.
Easy when it suits your argument, I guess.
There is an article I posted earlier in the thread where Toddy has suggested CA get a say in pitch preparation. I’ll find it and link it here for you.Wonder if this becomes the tipping point to where CA has input on pitch preparation.
Or is CA facing another year of huge financial losses and Greenberg is looking for someone to throw under the bus. After they lost a boatload of money last year through the BGT I would think another poor year could see ol’ Todd back up the job centre.
