Gobsmacked
First Grade
- Messages
- 5,931
I'm glad someone didThe rest of us understood it bruh.
I'm glad someone didThe rest of us understood it bruh.
makes complete sense he even broke down club comparisons. raiders were fading as a squad when it took over. lauries, sticky, clydes were back end of career. mal was late 30's trying to refreshen a team and made some ruthless calls to let mates go/leave and not re-sign them.I'm glad someone did






i knows right but gobthroat struggles to tie his shoes. not surprising cob.The rest of us understood it bruh.
Yeah..nah.makes complete sense he even broke down club comparisons. raiders were fading as a squad when it took over. lauries, sticky, clydes were back end of career. mal was late 30's trying to refreshen a team and made some ruthless calls to let mates go/leave and not re-sign them.
he put up winning percentage stats. 53% in his first tilt in an era dominated by broncos is pretty good. and he is right its that last season that stunk.
here is brad arthurs first full 5 seasons coaching (i didnt count his 6 game foray in 2012)
View attachment 109051
now mal's 5 seasons
View attachment 109053
ciraldos first 3 seasons
View attachment 109054
websters first 3 seasons
View attachment 109055
mcguires first 5 seasons are very good (minus 2016) and he won a prem
View attachment 109056
now look at mcguires last 5 (full) seasons are average and he won a prem.
View attachment 109058
so is Mal REALLY that bad a club coach? @Red&BlackBear is right. Stats dont back that narrative out.
he also never said mal made those origin players, he said he got them up for the games. this is after losses in 03-05 with a lucky draw in 02. he also said those players werent known stars when mal took over. qld in 2006 had a real whats up team. mogg, bell plus the champions now were only 2/3 years into their careers. hindsight is what makes it look like a killer side, at the time they were rank outsiders.
you question his man-management skills. rep teams are all about management (as opposed to coaching).
i knows right but gobthroat struggles to tie his shoes. not surprising cob.
what knots? you get stats and blatantly ignore them. you get context and blatantly ignore it. lol its funny and it's making ya look even more moronic. poor trolleyboy gobthroat, cant take a clue. not very smart is ya.Yeah..nah.
As much as I enjoy watching you boys twist yourselves into knots.
Mal saw no success at the Raiders.
The players Mal had the privilege of coaching at QLD were once in a generation superstars that Mal had very little hand creating.
He is the coach of Perth, as much as any other coach in the NRL. If he wishes to outsource any of those responsibilities, that's on him as coach, as it is with every other coach.
He hasn't coached in decades and decades ago had no success.
Have you ever considered having your own opinion?
helps when people actually lived through it. you can tells who wasnt watching footy back then.Some ppl are happy to have a surface level opinion I guess. Others like to analyse deeper.
Such dedication to trash talk lolwhat knots? you get stats and blatantly ignore them. you get context and blatantly ignore it. lol its funny and it's making ya look even more moronic. poor trolleyboy gobthroat, cant take a clue. not very smart is ya.
whats your issue with facts? do they interfere with ya shit takes lol. every time ya challenged the one poster in the know with the bears stuff he keeps crushing ya and making ya look stupid. it's hilarious.
poor gobthroat, just cant take a hint,
![]()
helps when people actually lived through it. you can tells who wasnt watching footy back then.
its clear that gobthroat is just jealous, he wishes he was involved in the game but he is too busy buying sticks with his trolley boy wage.
well the more clueless stupid shit with no truths that you post, the more i'll highlight it.Such dedication to trash talk lol
Love it, keep em coming.
Mine is a deep opinion based on a broad overview.Some ppl are happy to have a surface level opinion I guess. Others like to analyse deeper.
absolute rubbish post with 0 facts. broad overview lolMine is a deep opinion based on a broad overview.
Mal was in charge of an established NRL franchise for years that was meh..for years, final year was less than Meh..
That was 2 decades ago. The game is a far tougher beast today than it was then and the task is twice as great.
That in mind, it could be argued that he has no real record at all , not in the modern game, the speed, the professionalism, the rule changes.. the tackling technique alone has evolved incredibly.
And
Rep coaches coaching NRL have a poor record and vis versa. Actually, the better you are at one usually points to being even worse at the other, I'm sure there will be outliers.
I would have preferred a coach with hands on experience in the modern game with some record of success doing it. I thought Arthur would have been better suited, he has coached a team to a GF, he has overseen to development of players from rookie to modern stars .
He's one example, I'm sure there's others.
I hope I'm wrong, I hope Perth get up.
But if you look at this with both eyes, objectively, it paints are far different picture than the one the Bears faithful are preaching.
His resume isn't 20 years old , I thought I made the importance of that clear.absolute rubbish post with 0 facts. broad overview lol
you boast arthur as an example yet quickly brushed away his own record when provided with the like for like stats with no thought that he was up and down lol.
again for fair comparison cause ya turned blind eye.
here is brad arthurs first full 5 seasons coaching (i didnt count his 6 game foray in 2012)
![]()
now mal's 5 seasons
![]()
no stats back ya up, no context gives your rubbish opinion substance lol
again ya brush aside the facts that mal coaches a raiders side that was in transitional change lol
gobthroat the trolley boy thinking he knows alot but evident he knows nothing.
ya keeping getting owned trolleyboy gobthroat.
youre a 32 year old trolley boy.His resume isn't 20 years old , I thought I made the importance of that clear.
Trolleyboy gobthroat?
Still better than " sirPies&beers".. what on earth were you thinking?
Your insults are getting kinda desperate.youre a 32 year old trolley boy.
you gob things down ya throat with no shame.
so now ya want to highlight context in ya post while clearly brushing context aside in others posters posts? lol
sure, ok. whatever ya think trolleyboy gobthroat.
dont need toYour insults are getting kinda desperate.
Got anything else?
Knowing that you go to the effort to manually type trolleyboy gobthroat each time is hilarious.dont need to
youve proven what a hack you are by again side stepping something.
i can just repeat the below lol
so now ya want to highlight context in ya post while clearly brushing context aside in others posters posts? lol
sure, ok. whatever ya think trolleyboy gobthroat.
knowing ya still side stepping thisKnowing that you go to the effort to manually type trolleyboy gobthroat each time is hilarious.
Get a life.
He also has Jesse Colqhuoun on that list.
I said in this very thread ages ago that JC isn't leaving the Sharks, and he isn't.
Have a look at that Telegraph list of players and notice that JC's name isn't on it, for very good reason, they all know where he is continuing his career.
R and B would surely know that Colqhoun has rejected Perths offer. Its pretty well known now in the Cronulla circles.
jesse extends for sharkies for 4 years.I also wrote at the end of my wish list post
I’d be surprised if even half those players are nabbed, there will be more English contingent coming which I didn’t list.
It’s a personal wish list, nothing more. Jess would be a good get but if it isn’t to be, it isn’t to be.
Still going, what a loser.knowing ya still side stepping this
so now ya want to highlight context in ya post while clearly brushing context aside in others posters posts? lol
sure, ok. whatever ya think trolleyboy gobthroat.
is hilarious.
get an education trollyboy gobthroat lol
poor gobthroat,Still going, what a loser.
