What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Peter V'landys - New NRL/ARLC Chairman

Iamback

Referee
Messages
22,380
So let the lunatics run the asylum.

The NRL will be a billion dollar business shortly with eyes on a global audience. Surely they should be able to control what the game looks like rather than having coaches dictate it. And if not, get someone in who can.

What sells better?

This product now?

Or one that is 50 penalties a game?

The world has that, It is called Rugby Union.
 

Jetka100

Juniors
Messages
284
I’m going to suggest something the purists will hate (and probably quite a few others)

Have the 4 conferences of the 5 teams as has been suggested before. Every team plays each other once and the teams in the conference twice (23 games in total, currently it is 24).

At the end of the season, will have the current minor premiership winners.

The top team of each conference will go into the finals top 8.

Teams 2 and 3 from each conference will play each other to determine the remaining 4 finals teams.

The ranking of the top 8 will be determined by how they ended on points at the end of the season and the finals would then be played as it is now.

There will be 13 finals matches and more teams will remain in contention until the end. Some will see it as rewarding mediocrity, I say it is more entertainment for the masses and will grow the fan base.
 
Messages
3,312
I’m going to suggest something the purists will hate (and probably quite a few others)

Have the 4 conferences of the 5 teams as has been suggested before. Every team plays each other once and the teams in the conference twice (23 games in total, currently it is 24).

At the end of the season, will have the current minor premiership winners.

All solid ideas....


The top team of each conference will go into the finals top 8.

Teams 2 and 3 from each conference will play each other to determine the remaining 4 finals teams.

The ranking of the top 8 will be determined by how they ended on points at the end of the season and the finals would then be played as it is now.

There will be 13 finals matches and more teams will remain in contention until the end. Some will see it as rewarding mediocrity, I say it is more entertainment for the masses and will grow the fan base.

......until you went and said this
 

Trifili13

Juniors
Messages
2,479
Potential problem with conferences is you will get arguments of some being stronger than others so you might have a 'group of death' as it is called in soccer given teams strengthen or become weaker over periods. We already have supporters saying their team is disadvantaged with the draw. Conferences would also mean certain conferences/teams might have greater travel commitments. Not sure if there is any such kickback or complaints in the USA with conferences in their sports.

If/when we go to 20 or more teams, then play each other once, maybe then a heritage or rivalry game (or whatever you want to call it) and magic round, which may then leave room for SOO to not impact the season. You simply reverse the fixtures in alternate years so over a 2 year period you play everyone home and away. This is just high level spitballing and haven't taken into account the impact to broadcast content and hence money received for the rights.
 

Valheru

Referee
Messages
21,195
What sells better?

This product now?

Or one that is 50 penalties a game?

The world has that, It is called Rugby Union.
Are set restarts penalties? If they are, our game is on par with union in terms of number of penalties

Roosters/Rabbits - 9-11
Broncos/Eels - 12-7

Drua/Brumbies - 10-9
Reds/waratahs - 10-9
 
Messages
3,615
Potential problem with conferences is you will get arguments of some being stronger than others so you might have a 'group of death' as it is called in soccer given teams strengthen or become weaker over periods. We already have supporters saying their team is disadvantaged with the draw. Conferences would also mean certain conferences/teams might have greater travel commitments. Not sure if there is any such kickback or complaints in the USA with conferences in their sports.

If/when we go to 20 or more teams, then play each other once, maybe then a heritage or rivalry game (or whatever you want to call it) and magic round, which may then leave room for SOO to not impact the season. You simply reverse the fixtures in alternate years so over a 2 year period you play everyone home and away. This is just high level spitballing and haven't taken into account the impact to broadcast content and hence money received for the rights.
make the conferences and pools a lottery each year and re-set them one season to the next before the draw.
 

Trifili13

Juniors
Messages
2,479
make the conferences and pools a lottery each year and re-set them one season to the next before the draw.
Not a fan and I know it would be bad luck, but you don't want some teams travelling all over the place and others not leaving their suburb to play games and this happening for multiple years based on numbers being pulled out of a hat or however they make the draw.

Given we can't change where the teams are located and some obviously have more travelling than others, if you can simply play everyone once plus add a couple of extra rounds to have sufficient tv content, and reverse the fixture the following year, you can't complain about uneven draws. Anyway, my 2 cents worth.
 

BuffaloRules

Coach
Messages
18,240
If you play every body once … there will likely be 3 or 4 other games to account for, say it’s 4 so 2 home 2 away … so we are only talking 2 additional games here that teams need to travel…let’s not make this issue bigger than it needs to be..,

I think it makes some sense to have these additional games against teams you have a rivalry with … and that is likely to be teams that are geographically close to you ..
 

Steel Saints

Juniors
Messages
1,522
make the conferences and pools a lottery each year and re-set them one season to the next before the draw.

When there is 20 teams, have 4 conferences of 5 teams each. The four teams that reach preliminary finals are seeded, one team per conference.

Then have a pot draw show where ex players draw out teams from bowls, and allocate or fill out the conferences. Do it each year.

Of course the drawback is that it may prevent Souths playing against the Roosters twice, or similarly Broncos v Dolphins.
 

Jetka100

Juniors
Messages
284
Not a fan and I know it would be bad luck, but you don't want some teams travelling all over the place and others not leaving their suburb to play games and this happening for multiple years based on numbers being pulled out of a hat or however they make the draw.

Given we can't change where the teams are located and some obviously have more travelling than others, if you can simply play everyone once plus add a couple of extra rounds to have sufficient tv content, and reverse the fixture the following year, you can't complain about uneven draws. Anyway, my 2 cents worth.
I think, however, the idea of conferences is not that you only play teams in the conference all season, it is just who you play some extra games against. In a 20 team competition, at most it means you only play 4 teams twice. This already happens at the moment to some extent, with teams like Roosters always playing Souths twice, Broncos vs Cowboys and so on. The conference system just formalises it a bit more. I certainly wouldn’t favour two seperate conferences where teams only play within a conference until a Super Bowl style grand final. That would not work for the NRL.
 

Pippen94

First Grade
Messages
9,072
I would go to two conferences of ten teams (once chch are in) leading to to two finals systems with one grand final at Suncorp and one at Accor or Allianz and then the Super Bowl type game moving around

Play home and away tour conference plus a few from the other

Top five was the best finals concept ever used

NSW conference vs big city conference. Finals at SFS and lang park.
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
48,857

ARL Commission chair Peter V’landys has urged clubs to take more responsibility for their discipline amid revelations of a six-again scourge though the opening two rounds of the premiership.

This masthead can reveal that set restarts have nearly doubled in the opening two rounds this season in comparison to the corresponding period last year.

Referees have awarded 78 per cent more ‘six-agains’ (9.8 per game) this year than at the same time last season (5.5 per game) – an increase from 88 infringements last year to 157.

Last year’s end-of-season set restart average was 5.88 per game – showing a 67 per cent increase year-on-year.
V’landys insisted that the onus lay fell squarely on coaches and players to take care of their discipline after concerns were raised in the off-season over a return other of the wrestle.
“It’s a lack of discipline,” V’landys said.

“It is the coaches way of trying to slow the ruck down. No-one wants it to go back to the bad old days of the wrestle and that was unfortunately what was going to happen if we didn’t change it.”

V’landys was armed with statistics that showed the play the ball had been materially slowed down last season between the 40-metre lines.

It is understood senior referees had conceded they were more reluctant to blow penalties in that area of the field. As a result, the rules to allow referees to award six-agains in that area of the field.
V’landys message was simple.
“Be disciplined and do the right thing,” he said.

Statistics provided by Fox Sports Lab show total infringements (penalties and set restarts) have increased 20 per cent from 16.65 per game at the end of 2025 to nearly 20 (19.94) per match this season. Penalties have remained relatively steady at 10.8 per game last year to 10 this season.

The material increase in infringements has become a hot topic following the opening two rounds of the premiership, with numerous coaches and players voicing concerns.

The winless Titans were on the wrong end of an 8-4 set restart count as they struggled to contain the fast finishing Dolphins in Sunday night’s 18-14 loss to Redcliffe.

Four of those ‘six-agains’ came in a 14-minute blitz midway through the second half which helped the Dolphins gain momentum to overcome a 14-0 deficit.
There is no suggestion the set restarts weren’t warranted, but the increase has coaches concerned.

“(The referees are) officiating the game the way they (NRL) want it officiated,” Gold Coast coach Josh Hannay said.
The Titans were on the wrong end of the set restart count against the Dolphins. Picture: NRL

The Titans were on the wrong end of the set restart count against the Dolphins. Picture: NRL

“They’re all doing their job. We’ve got to play by the rules like everyone else.
“You adjust to how the game is being officiated and then it changes again and they’ll crack down on something else.
“You’ve constantly got to roll with punches with the game, where it’s at and how it’s trending. Those who adapt the quickest win.”

The struggling Cowboys conceded three set restarts in the opening three minutes of their 44-16 loss to Wests Tigers on Sunday.

North Queensland co-captain Tom Dearden said the players were confused.
“The most frustrating bit is when it happens you don’t know what it’s for,” he said.

“To start the game we had three (set restarts) back-to-back but we had no idea what for. It’s not like they’re calling six-again and telling us what it’s for. We just see the arm go up.

“Our job is to keep turning up but to start the game we had no clue what the six-agains were for. We made 12 or 14 tackles and had no idea what we were doing wrong.

“Once we got a break in play I spoke to the ref and he said it was a mix of everything. We were getting a lot wrong at the ruck and then inside the 10m.

“Our job is to clean that up, but in play it’s frustrating to not know what they’re for and how to fix it up.”

The Cowboys were their own worst enemy at Leichhardt Oval but coach Todd Payten called for referees to reconsider how often they awarded set restarts.

“It’s bringing fatigue into the game and the game’s fast enough,” he said.

“They’re more willing to blow those ruck infringements. I’d prefer if it’s not a full-blown penalty then don’t give the ruck infringement.

“But we’ve opened it up, this is the game and we’ve got to move forward and find a way to handle ourselves better.”


Watch Pvl will have the refs instructed to go easy now
 
Last edited:
Messages
3,615

Peter V’landys delivers blunt message to concerned clubs amid increased ‘six-again’ calls​

Players and coaches have bemoaned an increase in ‘six-again’ set restarts in 2026 – and the proof is in the numbers. It’s prompted Peter V’landys to deliver a simple message to clubs.

3 min read
March 16, 2026 - 4:00PM
News Sport Network

78af9ad8fef317dbb1e2d6ee892c08b278386822.avif

NRL: North Queensland Cowboys coach Todd Payten spoke to the media after the Cowboys round 2 loss to the Wests Tigers.
ARL Commission chair Peter V’landys has urged clubs to take more responsibility for their discipline amid revelations of a six-again scourge though the opening two rounds of the premiership.
This masthead can reveal that set restarts have nearly doubled in the opening two rounds this season in comparison to the corresponding period last year.
Referees have awarded 78 per cent more ‘six-agains’ (9.8 per game) this year than at the same time last season (5.5 per game) – an increase from 88 infringements last year to 157.
Last year’s end-of-season set restart average was 5.88 per game – showing a 67 per cent increase year-on-year.
V’landys insisted that the onus lay fell squarely on coaches and players to take care of their discipline after concerns were raised in the off-season over a return other of the wrestle.
“It’s a lack of discipline,” V’landys said.
A common sight this season. Picture: NRL Photos

A common sight this season. Picture: NRL Photos
“It is the coaches way of trying to slow the ruck down. No-one wants it to go back to the bad old days of the wrestle and that was unfortunately what was going to happen if we didn’t change it.”
V’landys was armed with statistics that showed the play the ball had been materially slowed down last season between the 40-metre lines.
It is understood senior referees had conceded they were more reluctant to blow penalties in that area of the field. As a result, the rules to allow referees to award six-agains in that area of the field.
V’landys message was simple.
“Be disciplined and do the right thing,” he said.
Peter V'landys wants clubs to take more responsibility for their discipline. Picture: Ryan Osland

Peter V'landys wants clubs to take more responsibility for their discipline. Picture: Ryan Osland
Statistics provided by Fox Sports Lab show total infringements (penalties and set restarts) have increased 20 per cent from 16.65 per game at the end of 2025 to nearly 20 (19.94) per match this season. Penalties have remained relatively steady at 10.8 per game last year to 10 this season.
The material increase in infringements has become a hot topic following the opening two rounds of the premiership, with numerous coaches and players voicing concerns.
The winless Titans were on the wrong end of an 8-4 set restart count as they struggled to contain the fast finishing Dolphins in Sunday night’s 18-14 loss to Redcliffe.
Four of those ‘six-agains’ came in a 14-minute blitz midway through the second half which helped the Dolphins gain momentum to overcome a 14-0 deficit.
There is no suggestion the set restarts weren’t warranted, but the increase has coaches concerned.
“(The referees are) officiating the game the way they (NRL) want it officiated,” Gold Coast coach Josh Hannay said.
The Titans were on the wrong end of the set restart count against the Dolphins. Picture: NRL

The Titans were on the wrong end of the set restart count against the Dolphins. Picture: NRL
“They’re all doing their job. We’ve got to play by the rules like everyone else.
“You adjust to how the game is being officiated and then it changes again and they’ll crack down on something else.
“You’ve constantly got to roll with punches with the game, where it’s at and how it’s trending. Those who adapt the quickest win.”
The struggling Cowboys conceded three set restarts in the opening three minutes of their 44-16 loss to Wests Tigers on Sunday.
North Queensland co-captain Tom Dearden said the players were confused.
“The most frustrating bit is when it happens you don’t know what it’s for,” he said.
The Cowboys suffered an early sin bin against the Tigers with Kai O'Donnell sent. Picture: NRL Photos

The Cowboys suffered an early sin bin against the Tigers with Kai O'Donnell sent. Picture: NRL Photos
“To start the game we had three (set restarts) back-to-back but we had no idea what for. It’s not like they’re calling six-again and telling us what it’s for. We just see the arm go up.
“Our job is to keep turning up but to start the game we had no clue what the six-agains were for. We made 12 or 14 tackles and had no idea what we were doing wrong.
“Once we got a break in play I spoke to the ref and he said it was a mix of everything. We were getting a lot wrong at the ruck and then inside the 10m.
“Our job is to clean that up, but in play it’s frustrating to not know what they’re for and how to fix it up.”
The Cowboys were their own worst enemy at Leichhardt Oval but coach Todd Payten called for referees to reconsider how often they awarded set restarts.
“It’s bringing fatigue into the game and the game’s fast enough,” he said.
“They’re more willing to blow those ruck infringements. I’d prefer if it’s not a full-blown penalty then don’t give the ruck infringement.
“But we’ve opened it up, this is the game and we’ve got to move forward and find a way to handle ourselves better.”
 

Latest posts

Top