What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Gallen's knee

Charlie124

First Grade
Messages
8,509
What I want to know is what was the go with Taylor feigning injury then getting up and charging onto the footy off the scrum??

Didn't think that was a real good look.

The commentators seemed to think he was having a dislocated finger put back in, i dont think he was feigning anything, if the trainer popped it back in quickly it wouldnt have bothered him to much.
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,170
Typical dog QLDer headbutting the great mans knee
almost injured him

Dave Taylor, merc, qlder, grub, merkin.
Paul Gallen, God.
 

Tommax25

Bench
Messages
2,959
Just read that if Gallen is unfit for the Storm game they might fight the charge so that he's suspended, but can't play anyway, and has a clean record. I don't like that, and I just realised I'm not sure what happens.

Like say T-Rex got injured for a month the same game he got his 7 week suspension. Would the ban start from the next week, despite T-Rex not being fit, or would it only start after the month? Who decides if he is fit? When does the suspension begin?
 

Spot On

Coach
Messages
13,910
Doesn't matter a flying f**k. Suspension starts straight away whether you have a broken leg, missing an eye or it's your birthday.
 

Charlie124

First Grade
Messages
8,509
What I want to know is what was the go with Taylor feigning injury then getting up and charging onto the footy off the scrum??

Didn't think that was a real good look.

The commentators seemed to think he was having a dislocated finger put back in, i dont think he was feigning anything, if the trainer popped it back in quickly it wouldnt have bothered him to much.

My apologies, BDR, you were right right about Taylor feining injury. Its $(c)uff$ new stupid LOL@Setplay. f**king ridiculous.

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...6350466197?from=igoogle+gadget+compact+bi_rss

A PHONE call from the NRL has forced Souths coach Michael Maguire to ditch a set play involving barnstorming forward Dave Taylor faking an injury.

The Rabbitohs were under investigation by the NRL yesterday after Kangaroo star Taylor feigned injury in a mischievous manoeuvre against the Sharks on Monday night.

Souths had a scrum feed in Cronulla's half when Taylor went down for "treatment" from the the club's head trainer on the short side.

The giant forward bounced to his feet the moment the ball was fed into the scrum and powered on to a pass from half-back Adam Reynolds.

It came as such a shock to referee Chris James that he had his back turned and got bowled over by Taylor.

The Sharks had numbered up on Taylor's side and managed to contain him. But the NRL's operations director Nathan McGuirk rang Souths CEO Shane Richardson to say it had breached the rules.

"Where we do have some concern is the involvement of a head medical trainer in any tactical on-field play," McGuirk said.

"Our operational rules do state that the head trainer is only to enter the field of play at a scrum for a player who is seriously injured. I am not saying at this stage that any rule has been breached but we will discuss the issue with the Rabbitohs."

The Rabbitohs are likely to escape a breach notice or fine but were warned not to do it again.

Maguire was happy to abide by the NRL ruling when contacted by The Daily Telegraph last night.

"It was just something different you come up with as a coach," he said. "I'm told I'm not allowed to do it again so it will go into the back pocket.

"The players talk about different things we can try as well.

"Hopefully we'll have a few other things to try in games coming up. At the end of the day we're just working hard as a group."

Sharks coach Shane Flanagan questioned whether the ploy was in the spirit of the game. "The trainer shouldn't have been on the field because Taylor obviously wasn't seriously hurt," Flanagan said.

"He jumped to his feet and went for it. Is it not in the spirit of the game? That's a 50-50 call. We'd marked up on him anyway but if they were to do it close to your line, that's when they could catch you out."

While the ploy has been banned, Maguire couldn't be happier with the Rabbitohs' improvement in recent week on the back of fullback Greg Inglis' sensational form.
 
Messages
13,584
What a cat manouvre.

Typical of Taylor and Souffs in general.

Put in your back pocket Maguire, with all of your love beads and double-enders.
 

eozsmiles

Bench
Messages
3,392
Just read that if Gallen is unfit for the Storm game they might fight the charge so that he's suspended, but can't play anyway, and has a clean record. I don't like that, and I just realised I'm not sure what happens.

Like say T-Rex got injured for a month the same game he got his 7 week suspension. Would the ban start from the next week, despite T-Rex not being fit, or would it only start after the month? Who decides if he is fit? When does the suspension begin?

Been going on forever. Jason Smith rocked up to the judiciary with a cast on his arm once.

Can't see Gallen being found guilty. They'll bring out 50 similar incidents so far this season and say he was just trying to get up.
 

STORM.99/07

Bench
Messages
2,857
typical nsw judiciary.grub gallon knees a player in the head and of course he`ll get cleared cos they need him to play in soo,then to come out with questioning Madge about taylor`s manoeuvre is just crazy.
 

Bretto

Bench
Messages
2,792
I seem to remember a similar thing happening this time last year against Taylor??

What was the outcome of that again? *trollface*
 

Hutty1986

Immortal
Messages
34,034
typical nsw judiciary.grub gallon knees a player in the head and of course he`ll get cleared cos they need him to play in soo,then to come out with questioning Madge about taylor`s manoeuvre is just crazy.

Both your post and user name is hilarious
 

gUt

Coach
Messages
16,935
What I want to know is what was the go with Taylor feigning injury then getting up and charging onto the footy off the scrum??

Didn't think that was a real good look.

It's not his go.
 

Mr Fourex

Bench
Messages
4,916
I believe after the judiciary cleared Gallen of the kneeing incident they asked him for his autograph.....

Gallengrubreturns.jpg
 
Top