What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

State of Origin 2025 (Mens Edition)

Parra Pride

Referee
Messages
20,715
It's been a rule for a while.. you used to be able to tackle the attacking player in the air when on the goal line but for some dumb reason they changed it...
It’s a hard one, it’s obvious to see how it’s not safe to tackle blokes in air but it’s now created these situations where blokes really can’t do anything when defending kicks like that. The To’o one on game one was absolute horseshit as was the one Lomax gave up against the Sharks.
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
16,816
They aren’t easy, but if you want to be an elite goal kicker you need to hit them. With Cleary in the side the moment he misses a second kick he should’ve been hooked.


I don't see why Latrell or Chrighton didn't Kick after he missed the second one actually either..
 

Parra Pride

Referee
Messages
20,715
I don't see why Latrell or Chrighton didn't Kick after he missed the second one actually either..
Would’ve gone for Cleary over either of those, but yeah they should’ve changed to any of them. Had the same issue in game one, stuck with Cleary too long. Lomax ended up missing when we swapped regardless, and it didn’t matter because we belted them but someone still should be making the call that the first choice is clearly off.
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
17,757
NSW scoring early and then got too cocky.

The penalty count was atrocious but NSW lost the plot as well.

Ill discipline was there

Hudson Young, Stefano, Max King ain't origin players.

Connor Watson was horrendous when he came on.

It also puts to bed Gus Gould theory that Cleary/Luai combo is superior at Origin.

3 wins from 7 at that level.

In a way NSW got what they deserved for there disgraceful handling of Moses last week.
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
16,816
Would’ve gone for Cleary over either of those, but yeah they should’ve changed to any of them. Had the same issue in game one, stuck with Cleary too long. Lomax ended up missing when we swapped regardless, and it didn’t matter because we belted them but someone still should be making the call that the first choice is clearly off.


Clearly was injured
 

Matty Bhoy

Juniors
Messages
2,286
We all know it sucks to be on the other side of Ashley Klein who is one of the biggest momentum refs I’ve ever seen. But that’s not why you lost.

The Blues were way too undisciplined. Luai must’ve given us five penalties alone. He’s more interested in trying to be a hard man than just playing footy.

Kurt Capewell was on another level, which is something I never thought I’d say.
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
17,757
We all know it sucks to be on the other side of Ashley Klein who is one of the biggest momentum refs I’ve ever seen. But that’s not why you lost.

The Blues were way too undisciplined. Luai must’ve given us five penalties alone. He’s more interested in trying to be a hard man than just playing footy.

Kurt Capewell was on another level, which is something I never thought I’d say.
Does Ponga stay at FB for QLD.

He was rubbish last night.

Andrew Johns though won't so a bad word about his precious Kalyn though on the commentary.
 

Matty Bhoy

Juniors
Messages
2,286
Does Ponga stay at FB for QLD.

He was rubbish last night.

Andrew Johns though won't so a bad word about his precious Kalyn though on the commentary.
Yeah I think he stays. Wasn’t great at all but the only other realistic option is Walsh. They’ll stick with KP.
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
16,816
We all know it sucks to be on the other side of Ashley Klein who is one of the biggest momentum refs I’ve ever seen. But that’s not why you lost.

The Blues were way too undisciplined. Luai must’ve given us five penalties alone. He’s more interested in trying to be a hard man than just playing footy.

Kurt Capewell was on another level, which is something I never thought I’d say.


That's BS...

There was 4 penalties in the first half that were rightfully so a penalty..

The Elbow / eye gouge / ruck kicking ball and obstruction every other penalty could have been let go as he did in the second half..

Klien was busting a nut to give a penalty away.. He tried when it was a clear knock on and had to be challenged. Then QLDs next set out of trouble he gave one for Hass laying down even though QLD didn't do the exact same thing..

Like I said in my rant I don't watch SOO for the ref to show us he is alive put the f**king whistle away unless th penalty is warranted.
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
16,816
Hammer to FB and Murray T back onto the wing? I'd be nervous about that as a NSW fan.

I'm a bit worried now. Cleary is pretty injured I reckon. Luai was awful. Moses won't be back.

Hammer is a winger. He is shit at fullback even for the Fins..

If Cleary is injured they bring in Katoa..

Probably should have picked him instead of Luai.
 

Matty Bhoy

Juniors
Messages
2,286
That's BS...

There was 4 penalties in the first half that were rightfully so a penalty..

The Elbow / eye gouge / ruck kicking ball and obstruction every other penalty could have been let go as he did in the second half..

Klien was busting a nut to give a penalty away.. He tried when it was a clear knock on and had to be challenged. Then QLDs next set out of trouble he gave one for Hass laying down even though QLD didn't do the exact same thing..

Like I said in my rant I don't watch SOO for the ref to show us he is alive put the f**king whistle away unless th penalty is warranted.
He did lay all over the ruck though. He was trying to slow down Qld’s quicker play the balls. Looked a clear penalty to me. Joey and Gus said what I was saying at halftime, NSW were poorly disciplined just like we were in Game one.
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
17,757
Ashleigh Klowns performance last night would of given the Gradshopper a Chubb.
Is it any coincidence the 1 big game in the last 5-6 years Klein didnt ref was the 2023 GF.

And its considered one of the best refereed games in the last 20 years.

The only reason Klein didnt ref that game was he had a howler in the semi final and basically had to be hooked for the prelim and GF.
 

Latest posts

Top