What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

09 :: R5 Sun :: Sea Eagles 23 Tigers 10 @ Brookvale

Round 5 :: Sea Eagles or Tigers?

  • Draw after Golden Point

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    32
  • Poll closed .

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,994


Gates open 12:30pm

man-main.jpg

MANLY WARRINGAH SEA EAGLES
1. Brett Stewart
2. Michael Robertson 3. Jamie Lyon 4. Steve Matai 5. Michael Bani
6. Chris Bailey 7. Matt Orford (c)
8. Brent Kite 9. Matt Ballin 10. Josh Perry
11. Anthony Watmough 12. Glenn Hall
13. Glenn Stewart​

Interchange: 14. Heath L’Estrange 15. Jason King 16. Adam Cuthbertson 17. George Rose
Reserves: 18. Shane Rodney​


wes-alt.jpg

WESTS TIGERS
1. Rhys Hanbury
2. Taniela Tuaki 3. Dean Collis 4. Chris Lawrence 5. Beau Ryan
6. John Morris 7. Benji Marshall
8. Bryce Gibbs 9. Robbie Farah (c) 10. Keith Galloway
11. Gareth Ellis 12. Chris Heighington
13. Todd Payten​

Interchange: 14. Corey Payne 15. Danny Galea 16. Dene Halatau 17. Shannon McDonnell​


ref-pink.jpg

Referees
Shayne Hayne & Tony De Las Heras
Sideline Officials: Daniel Eastwood & Steve Chiddy
Video Referee: Paul Simpkins​


Toyota Cup
Manly Warringah v Wests Tigers
Brookvale Oval, Sunday 12:45pm​

QLD Cup
Sunshine Coast (MAN) v Souths Logan (CAN)
Stockland Park, Saturday 2:05pm​

NSW Cup
Balmain Ryde-Eastwood (WST) v Windsor (PEN)
Leichhardt Oval, Saturday 3:00pm​

Western Suburbs (WST) v Shellharbour City (STG)
Campbelltown Stadium, Saturday 3:00pm​

r5-manwest.jpg

 
Last edited:

Dutchy

Immortal
Messages
33,887
NRL = Manly by 42
QLD Cup = Sea Eagles by 16
20s = Manly by 18
 
Last edited:

Tommax25

Bench
Messages
2,959
Ok 0-4 and I'm still not panicking. Stewart is back this week, maybe tony williams which means bye bye nueman and the team will be better for it. But if manly lose to the tigers, who I tipped for the spoon, at home for 5 losses in a row in defence of their premiership then I think I may start panicking.
 

perverse

Referee
Messages
26,707
i can't see manly beating the maitland pumpkin pickers at the moment. they are dreadful. i sure hope for their seasons sake that stewart has an absolutely, unbelievably, completely geniusedly amazing impact on their team... otherwise they could be in for a long year.
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,284
Yeah.. If they don't win this game with Stewart back, they are in deep sh*t for the year. A must win game imo if they want to make the top 8. There is plenty of time left sure, but with Stewart back they will have no more excuses for their poor performances..
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,994
SEA EAGLES 1. Brett Stewart 2. Michael Robertson 3. Jamie Lyon 4. Steve Matai 5. Michael Bani 6. Chris Bailey 7. Matt Orford (c) 8. Brent Kite 9. Matt Ballin 10. Josh Perry 11. Anthony Watmough 12. Glenn Hall 13. Glenn Stewart
Interchange: 14. Heath L’Estrange 15. Jason King 16. Adam Cuthbertson 17. George Rose; Reserves: 18. Shane Rodney

TIGERS 1. Rhys Hanbury 2. Taniela Tuaki 3. Dean Collis 4. Chris Lawrence 5. Beau Ryan 6. John Morris 7. Benji Marshall 8. Bryce Gibbs 9. Robbie Farah (c) 10. Keith Galloway 11. Gareth Ellis 12. Chris Heighington 13. Todd Payten
Interchange: 14. Corey Payne 15. Danny Galea 16. Dene Halatau 17. Shannon McDonnell

Referees Shayne Hayne & Tony De Las Heras Sideline Daniel Eastwood & Steve Chiddy Video Paul Simpkins


From the teams thread:
http://forums.leagueunlimited.com/showthread.php?p=5535944
 

Dutchy

Immortal
Messages
33,887
Chances of Lyon and Matai actually playing. Minimal.

Welcome back to First Grade Neumann.
 

Downie

Guest Moderator
Messages
1,038
Chances of Lyon and Matai actually playing. Minimal.

Welcome back to First Grade Neumann.

Maybe Williams and Williams in the centres, if both Matai and Lyon don't play? Rodney would even be a better shout than Neumann atm.
 

hybrid_tiger

Coach
Messages
11,684
We will play you guys back into form, without a doubt. Put your house on it. We are f**king pathetic and there is no accountability from Sheens or anyone at the club. How no questions are asked about his decisions and team selection is f**king mystifying. He must have all the journos in his back pocket.

Our bench is the worst I've ever seen in my life. We have oxygen thiefs like Gibbs and Halatau who have done NOTHING in three years still keep their spots every week, Collis who has done nothing for 18 months still keeps his spot, and Ryan who has been mediocre this year so far still keeps his spot.

On the bench we have a fullback/winger who would not get a game at any other club in the NRL and is only in the team because his father is the recruitment manager (I do feel sorry for him though as he will only play 5 minutes as Sheens loves playing with 15 or 16 players for 75 minutes of the match).

We also have a mediocre second rower who loves giving away penalties and who is played out of position at prop, and a "utility" who could not pass go in Monopoly and could have a five-man overlap and still murder it.

f**k this.
 

gong_eagle

First Grade
Messages
7,655
Sea Eagles v Wests Tigers Preview
Big League.
http://www.nrl.com/News/Latest/tabid/10244/default.aspx?id=54376


Brookvale Oval
Sunday 3pm
RAISE your hand if you predicted the reigning premiers would start the year with four straight losses before the start of season 2009. Now put your hand down, you pack of liars!
Unbelievably, Manly are the only side without a win after the first month of football and as such are rooted to the foot of the table.
Thankfully for the Sea Eagles’ fans they get a chance to break the duck at home this weekend with the return of the Brookvale try-scoring machine Brett Stewart in their match against the up-and-down Wests Tigers.
With some off field ructions of their own due to a boardroom battle and some serious defensive flaws, the Wests Tigers are ripe for the picking if the Sea Eagles can finally put their own problems behind them.
They come into the match following a disappointing loss to Penrith where they leaked three late tries to be thumped 42-22.
The result saw them fall to 12th on the ladder, although they still have two wins more than the Sea Eagles.
With Stewart back at fullback, Michael Robertson returns to the wing and David Williams is out of the side. Jamie Lyon is also slated to return from injury, which ushes Shane Neumann out of the team. Prop George Rose has been added to a five-man bench.
The Wests Tigers have named Rhys Hanbury at fullback to take over from the injured Tim Moltzen, with Shannon McDonnell taking Hanbury’s spot on the bench.
Rocky Trimarchi is out of the side with Corey Payne joining the squad.
Watch out Sea Eagles: The Wests Tigers will attack almost exclusively up the middle and to the left side. The Tigers have scored 20 tries this season, 10 on the left side of the field (seven on the left sideline, three on the left edge), nine up the middle and just one on the right side.
The biggest beneficiary has been left winger Taniela Tuiaki who leads the NRL with six tries. They will continue their focus left, considering the Sea Eagles have leaked 10 tries on this side of the field.
Watch out Wests Tigers: Brett Stewart returns to the Sea Eagles outfit with plenty to prove. The Manly custodian scores almost a try a match at Brookvale Oval and would love nothing more than to put some of the off-field dramas behind him with a mammoth performance.
In the regular season last year Stewart averaged 125 metres a match, had 14 line breaks, 10 line-break assists, nine try assists and 19 tries along with 81 tackle breaks. Don’t be surprised if he makes up for lost time with a match-turning display.
Where it will be won: Defence. Both sides have been terrible defensively so far this year and improvement is needed to win this game. Manly are now conceding 24.5 points a match – a huge difference from last season when they were only leaking 13.6 points a game.
The Wests Tigers house the absolute worst defence in the league at this point, leaking 33.5 points a game – more than 10 points worse a match than they conceded last season.
While having a good attack can sometimes negate poor defence, a good defensive team is usually going to come out on top against a good attacking side. The attitude to defence from both sides has been poor. Manly have missed an NRL-high 142 tackles in the first month and the Wests Tigers have missed 104 tackles thus far. Whoever pays some attention to the hard stuff… i.e. tackling, will come away with the competition points.
The History: Played 11; Sea Eagles 7, Wests Tigers 4. Manly have won six of the past eight between the two clubs, including the past four in a row. At Brookvale the ledger is 4-1 to the home side over the Tigers with the only win for the visitors being back in April 2003.
Conclusion: Just about everyone has been waiting for Manly to finally put it together and start winning. Surely this is the weekend that happens. They are once again back at home and have their attacking fullback back in the side, so excuses are now gone. They have had sufficient time to adjust to the two-referee system and their egos are surely back to normal after having been humiliated over the first month.
The Wests Tigers have been dismal defensively and unless they improve in that area they can expect another loss. However, they are dynamic in attack and have scored more points than any other side so they can certainly turn on the points if the Sea Eagles are still in a funk. They will also be buoyed by the knowledge another loss for the Sea Eagles could put a real nail in their premiership defence. Tip Manly here – but if they lose again feel free to run the red felt pen through them for the rest of the year.
Match officials: Referees – Shayne Hayne & Tony De Las Heras; Sideline Officials – Daniel Eastwood & Steve Chiddy; Video Ref – Paul Simpkins.
Televised: Channel 9 – Delayed 4pm; Fox Sports – Delayed 6pm.
* Statistics: NRL Stats.
 

Latest posts

Top