'13 | 1st SF | Fri | Sea Eagles 24-18 Sharks | Allianz

[SaraSassypants]

Just some simple mathmatics for you.

The Taufua try wasn't converted. 24-4 = 20. 20>18. Ergo, Manly still win.

Last year, take away the Foran try. 22-6 = 16. 16>12. Ergo, Manly still win.

So, no, neither year have they "won" due to knock ons. The winning margin has just been increased.

My bad I miss calculated that. I must've been using the same Mathamatics that Manly used where Matai scores, Manly win in Round 23 ;-)

Anyway hopefully a controversy free game next week

 

[Sea_Eagles_Rock]

sorry, but its hardly ever the 'could have' theory with me. i have the nuts to talk it up before the game, but you manly softies always have your say after the event. i'll be back at your forum after the bunnies show you what having depth in your top 25 is all about. just failing by 1 week to make the gf, you poor things.

Just curious. Do you have a 6 pocket theory?