'14 // Women in League R10 // Sun // Raiders 20-26 Panthers // GIO

[bileduct]

Absolute BS. There was a period in the second half, starting with a penalty given to the Raiders from a tackle on Milford after he took a high ball, that saw the refs give the next three or four penalties/calls to Canberra and every one of them was incorrect.

Well, you're at least right about the first penalty there. Peter Wallace could clearly be heard being called offside at the kick and was the first player to touch Milford - but then gets penalised for holding on when he wasn't.

Right decision for the wrong reason.

 

[Spot On]

Well, you're at least right about the first penalty there. Peter Wallace could clearly be heard being called offside at the kick and was the first player to touch Milford - but then gets penalised for holding on when he wasn't.

Right decision for the wrong reason.

And the two after that as well as the feed going to Canberra after the Raiders player threw the ball into Mansoor (??) as he was being thrown into touch. It was never played at.

 

[bileduct]

And the two after that as well as the feed going to Canberra after the Raiders player threw the ball into Mansoor (??) as he was being thrown into touch. It was never played at.

Yeah, the scrum feed probably ended up going the wrong way, but are you referring to Shillington being elbowed in the face? Seems fair enough a penalty to me. I've seen Campese penalised twice this season for the exact same thing.

What was the other one?

 

[Paullyboy]

No, they were pretty bad, but equal opportunity. You just accept the call and move on. But Paullyboy decided crying non-stop was a more valid option.

At what point do you stop just accepting dud calls though? I get fired up during a match and say things I wouldn't normally say, but it's a build up over countless matches decided by horrendous officiating.

The raiders didn't deserve to win, however the panthers certainly didn't either.

 

[natheel]

Yeah, the scrum feed probably ended up going the wrong way, but are you referring to Shillington being elbowed in the face? Seems fair enough a penalty to me. I've seen Campese penalised twice this season for the exact same thing.

What was the other one?

It was a pretty soft elbow to the face. What Shillo did to segs face looked 100% times worse

 

[bileduct]

It was a pretty soft elbow to the face. What Shillo did to segs face looked 100% times worse

And Shillington wouldn't have done it had he not already been fouled, so what's your point?

 

[bileduct]

What was the other one?

The flop on Reece Robinson?

 

[billypilgrimnz]

And Shillington wouldn't have done it had he not already been fouled, so what's your point?

The point is all Panthers fans are glad he did it because it prevented a Raiders try.

 

[Spot On]

Yeah, the scrum feed probably ended up going the wrong way, but are you referring to Shillington being elbowed in the face? Seems fair enough a penalty to me. I've seen Campese penalised twice this season for the exact same thing.

What was the other one?

After watching Cam Smith elbow the Manly hooker across his nose and face three times UFC style last week in front of the ref and without a penalty or warning then I can't believe Seg was penalised for a forearm rub across Shillo's cheek.

Hey, I'm happy for it to be penalised IF it's going to be enforced EVERY f**kING TIME, EVERY GAME, EVERY WEEK. It won't though. Cam can do it when he pleases.

Can't recall what came after that???

 

[franklin2323]

Canberra had 43 tackles inside 20 to our 17. Won the penalties, had the most possession. So hardly refereeing that cost them.

As for the refs they were shit no doubt but missed plenty of stuff both ways.

That fight after we scored started from Soward getting worse treatment then Shillington did. Wasn't the only time & won't be the last this year 99% of the time it's let go.

Mansour knock on off his chest & making a tackle. Kite penalty for some crap...So went both ways but love a Stuart meltdown!

 

[natheel]

And Shillington wouldn't have done it had he not already been fouled, so what's your point?

Just saying he over reacted to what was a soft elbow

 

[umina panther]

Pillow is also a very lucky boy that Segeyaro wasn't in the mood to towel him up

 

[bileduct]

After watching Cam Smith elbow the Manly hooker across his nose and face three times UFC style last week in front of the ref and without a penalty or warning then I can't believe Seg was penalised for a forearm rub across Shillo's cheek.

And Campese has been penalised twice this year for simply putting his hand on an opposition player's face while on the ground.

Hey, I'm happy for it to be penalised IF it's going to be enforced EVERY f**kING TIME, EVERY GAME, EVERY WEEK. It won't though. Cam can do it when he pleases.

Some players are a protected species.

 

[Rhino_NQ]

Pillow is also a very lucky boy that Segeyaro wasn't in the mood to towel him up

that I would have loved to see

 

[Tipster]

Ricky's post match blow up another instant classic

 

[STORM.99/07]

After watching Cam Smith elbow the Manly hooker across his nose and face three times UFC style last week in front of the ref and without a penalty or warning then I can't believe Seg was penalised for a forearm rub across Shillo's cheek.

Hey, I'm happy for it to be penalised IF it's going to be enforced EVERY f**kING TIME, EVERY GAME, EVERY WEEK. It won't though. Cam can do it when he pleases.

Can't recall what came after that???

Cam never elbowed ballin in the face ,he was smacking at his arm to get him to let go of his jersey so he could get up to play the ball.

 

[GongPanther]

Hahaha this is the most blatant cheating I've ever seen.

This is a disgrace.

The refs have single handedly ruined yet another game

I have to agree with you.

If properly handled by these inept refs,Penrith would have won by 60.

 

[GongPanther]

Your mate GongPanther isnt any better
glass houses, pal.

One swallow a summer it does not make.

And besides,the whinge I put out was a contrasting and genuine one which I thought was a fair one and not a cry for the sake of whining.

There IS a difference in comparison to the likes of PaullyGirl who is obviously a serial moaner.

 

[Dutchy]

Cam never elbowed ballin in the face ,he was smacking at his arm to get him to let go of his jersey so he could get up to play the ball.

:lol: :lol: :lol:

Blind and delusional. Move Cam's ballsack from in front of your eyes mate.

 

[ek999]

Wrong thread.

Should contribute something so lol @ Sticky