What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

1st Test: Australia v India @ Optus Stadium, PERTH Nov 22-26, 2024

BunniesMan

Immortal
Messages
33,710
Not much to replace the incumbent failures with.

You look at some of the shield line ups and there isn't much depth to any of these top orders. Blokes making careers as first class batsmen despite averaging 30 odd. It is rare to find anyone at 40 let alone 50. I remember a time we could have fielded not one but two top 6 lineups with blokes averaging 50.

What has happened to batting in this country?
 

Chins get the wins

First Grade
Messages
8,279
Not much to replace the incumbent failures with.

You look at some of the shield line ups and there isn't much depth to any of these top orders. Blokes making careers as first class batsmen despite averaging 30 odd. It is rare to find anyone at 40 let alone 50. I remember a time we could have fielded not one but two top 6 lineups with blokes averaging 50.

What has happened to batting in this country?
20/20 happened.


Unfortunately 50 over cricket needs to die to give space for real cricket (tests) and that crap Indians like.
 

AlwaysGreen

Post Whore
Messages
50,130
20/20 happened.


Unfortunately 50 over cricket needs to die to give space for real cricket (tests) and that crap Indians like.
True. However India are hooked on t20 yet have improved in test cricket.

Australia are actually in a worse boat than the likes of the West Indies, New Zealand, South Africa. We haven't had a test regular give up test cricket to join the t20 circuit like they have Which makes our bare cupboard even worse.
 

This Year?

Immortal
Messages
35,498
Congrats to India. Hard to split Bumrah or Jaiswal for MOM. Until we find a way to see off Bumrah/Siraj's 1st spells and limit our wickets in the 1st 20 overs we are going to struggle. With the ball we must not be giving up so many extras and be more aggressive with our field placement.
Looking forward to seeing if we are up for the challenge in Adelaide.
 

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
102,900
True. However India are hooked on t20 yet have improved in test cricket.

Australia are actually in a worse boat than the likes of the West Indies, New Zealand, South Africa. We haven't had a test regular give up test cricket to join the t20 circuit like they have Which makes our bare cupboard even worse.

T20 has driven a huge rise in professionalism in Indian cricket. It's a much different equation.

That said blaming T20 for where we are is a cop out. Its one of a lot of issues, but the worst is that CA ae a bunch of ARU level fart sniffers driving the game down the toilet for their own gain
 
Messages
11,643
Rise of T20 definitely can't be held to blame for all of it. Add in the amount of useless white ball series' we play at the expenses of Test matches.

Whittling down test series' against NZ and Sri Lanka away down to two tests, seemingly because they're less commercially attractive.

The complete lack of tour matches we play these days. We played six tour matches on the Ashes tour in 2001. How many last year? None.

The reduced match experience the top guys and the ones in the wings get all adds up. It's an absolute myth that they play more cricket than ever. Go see how many FC and List A matches players back in the 70s/80s/90s would rack up and compare it to now, yet we've got batsmen now being rested when they're available for Shield matches.
 

Latest posts

Top