2018 R18 Sun - Titans 12-20 Roosters @ Cbus Super

[TheFrog]

I would have preferred that to what we just saw. At least there's a logical argument for a penalty try.

For some reason they don't give penalty try for an offside close to the line. Often they don't even give a penalty.

 

[blaza88z]

Is that the worst decision of the year?

 

[Babyface O'reilly]

Really what if that was a Grand Final and these dumb farks award that as a try bunch of useless farks

I get where they’re coming from with the technical knock back but we’ve watched this game develop into calling every drop ball a knock on. So strange call

 

[The_Shield]

I am stunned that’s the worst decision of the year.

Storm no try against the Dragons was the worst decision of the year. But this one definitely the worst call from the bunker

 

[TheFrog]

Is that the worst decision of the year?

No that was allowing the Broncos to play in the premiership.

 

[blaza88z]

Storm no try against the Dragons was the worst decision of the year. But this one definitely the worst call from the bunker

You are on crack, that was the correct call

 

[Babyface O'reilly]

Storm no try against the Dragons was the worst decision of the year. But this one definitely the worst call from the bunker

What about the hand of god from DCE against Cows in semi?

 

[TheFrog]

Storm no try against the Dragons was the worst decision of the year. But this one definitely the worst call from the bunker

Bulldogs try in round 3 when Maloney was obstructed was pretty nasty.

 

[Uncle Kraka]

For some reason they don't give penalty try for an offside close to the line. Often they don't even give a penalty.

An offside player stripping the ball from someone who only has to fall over to score. If not a penalty try, would have to be a sin bin.

 

[Unscrupulous]

Agree. Should've been no try and sin binning.

 

[TheFrog]

An offside player stripping the ball from someone who only has to fall over to score. If not a penalty try, would have to be a sin bin.

You are allowed to strip one-on-one. So an offside player making a tackle is just as bad, and they don't give a penalty try for that. They only send him to the bin following a warning. Equally often they just let it go. I suggest you watch the final five minutes of Roosters v Tigers about a month ago.

 

[typicalfan]

Lots of bad calls but when you see the player pull the ball towards himself and then it hits the ground and they watch it several times...

 

[Leber]

Which to be fair was not as bad as the "no advantage" call that went against the Dragons versus us.

Shutup.

That goes against my narrative.

vote KTF

 

[Valheru]

Storm no try against the Dragons was the worst decision of the year. But this one definitely the worst call from the bunker

Why? Because it was against the storm.

We copped one on ANZAC day, clear as day knock on.

Swings and roundabouts

 

[Uncle Kraka]

You are allowed to strip one-on-one. So an offside player making a tackle is just as bad, and they don't give a penalty try for that. They only send him to the bin following a warning. Equally often they just let it go.

It’s an absolute gamble what the bunker does anyway so you almost have to be ready for anything. I expected it to be called a knock on and sin bin. Roosters probably would have scored against 11 men anyway.

 

[The_Shield]

You are on crack, that was the correct call

They pulled it back just to award the Storm a penalty. They claimed an incorrect ptb was the reason they couldn’t play on but there was absolutely nothing wrong with the ptb from Kasiano

 

[The_Shield]

Why? Because it was against the storm.

We copped one on ANZAC day, clear as day knock on.

Swings and roundabouts

No because they took a fair try away from a team that did absolutely nothing wrong. They took the try away to give a penalty from the play before

 

[2 weeks]

Fergo zero errors so far.
He's due.

 

[no name]

So the 4 penalties in two minutes is a binning again after two weeks ago the Storm gave away 4 penalties in two minutes and no binning?
Hooray for supporting a minnow team!

 

[SBD82]

No because they took a fair try away from a team that did absolutely nothing wrong. They took the try away to give a penalty from the play before

Fmd. Months ago, you've beaten us since, and it was the correct call.

Now you're complaining about it in a titans/roosters thread.

Seriously. Let it go.