Yeah, I'm with Bazal on this.
All they have shown me this season is that Gabriel and Roach are good bowlers - all cricket fans already knew that. Roach was known well before his last tour of Aus years ago; and Gabriel starred vs Pakistan before touring England this time last year. I thought Gabriuel was a fine bowler BEFORE he toured NZ before Christmas last year.
Holder can get wickets when conditions suit swing against Asian batsmen - not really a surprise.
K Braithwaite is good - cricket fans already knew that.
And the rest of the WI top order is still rubbish.
http://www.espncricinfo.com/westindies/content/player/252932.html
Kieron Powell is barely an FC batsmen. Shai Hope's brother has been dropped. Roston Chase has gone from mid 40's average to mid 30's and still sliding.
Holder continually holds the batting order together from 7 now instead of 8.
Dowrich: their keeper:
http://www.espncricinfo.com/westindies/content/player/431905.html
Has fought hard this home season, but their top order is still crap.
It is utter rubbish.
http://www.espncricinfo.com/westindies/content/player/670025.html
Look at Hetmeyer - how is he a test quality batsman right now?
They scrap for runs between Holder and Dowrich and the tail to give Gabriel and Roach something to bowl at. That may work against SL and Bangladesh, but it will not work when the real acid test of seam competent sides tour. And if WI make it a spin track, my money is still on England, SA, NZ, Aus and Pak to take them out.
Roach and Gabriel are more than useful, - underrated even. Gabriel gives his all to be continually in excess of 140 km/h. Guys like that deserve cricket fans respect. Dowrich and Holder have fight and determination. But that top order besides Braithwaite is utter garbage still.
Besides Braithwaite, I have 0 respect for the WI batting line up. I respect Dowrich, Holder, Gabriel and Roach, but that batting line up is not really test standard as yet. I had very high hopes for Roston Chase - I am very disapointed that he has not kicked on.