2019 R13 Sun - Panthers 19-10 Roosters @ Panthers

[Meapro Ham]

It wasn't the tackle. It was the holding down afterwards when the opposition was in a scoring position. Obviously you aren't used to this but it happens every week to most sides.

You clearly don’t understand the rules around dominant tackles.

 

[Unscrupulous]

Are you actually suggesting it wasn't?

No. I am straight out TELLING you it wasn't.

As I said earlier, a linebreak does not grant you a fast play the ball. He was demolished in an overwhelmingly dominant tackle and was therefore entitled to slow things down.

 

[TheFrog]

No. I am straight out TELLING you it wasn't.

As I said earlier, a linebreak does not grant you a fast play the ball. He was demolished in an overwhelmingly dominant tackle and was therefore entitled to slow things down.

Get over it mate. You were the second best team.

 

[TheFrog]

You clearly don’t understand the rules around dominant tackles.

Winners are grinners, losers please themselves. We've been there enough times this year. Enjoy your slump.

 

[Unscrupulous]

Get over it mate. You were the second best team.

Haha well played. I'd play the 'we won so you're wrong' card too if I was shown up like that.

 

[snickers007]

No. I am straight out TELLING you it wasn't.

As I said earlier, a linebreak does not grant you a fast play the ball. He was demolished in an overwhelmingly dominant tackle and was therefore entitled to slow things down.

Can you point me towards this in the rule book? All I'm seeing is that no one shall delay the play the ball... No mention of dominant tackles...

 

[Dave's mate]

No. I am straight out TELLING you it wasn't.

As I said earlier, a linebreak does not grant you a fast play the ball. He was demolished in an overwhelmingly dominant tackle and was therefore entitled to slow things down.

Went far past the allowed time to hold him down. Eat a bag of dicks just this once...yku merkins are winning the comp

 

[Unscrupulous]

Winners are grinners, losers please themselves. We've been there enough times this year. Enjoy your slump.

Hahahaha you actually doubled down on it too.

 

[Blues Riff]

Teddy maintains his zero points scored against Penrith.

 

[Unscrupulous]

Can you point me towards this in the rule book? All I'm seeing is that no one shall delay the play the ball... No mention of dominant tackles...

Why does the referee call 'dominant' and 'surrender' then?

Must just be for the lols hey.

 

[Valheru]

Moylan, Johnson, Graham, Woods etc.. found ways to win

DCE, Tom Turbo, Walker etc... found ways to win

Roosters have been brave here, and other teams hit hard by injury struggled in some games too. But not three losses in a row struggled. Roosters have to find a way to win some when down on troops.

To be fair we have win a few games already with troops missing. It is all catching up to us a bit now with SOO added to the mix that is why it was so important to win all those early season games.

But yes they need to start winning again soon.

 

[Valheru]

Can you point me towards this in the rule book? All I'm seeing is that no one shall delay the play the ball... No mention of dominant tackles...

What they are saying is it should have been called a dominant tackle and thus he has more time to get up. If he did indeed call it a dominant tackle then he called the penalty too early.

Anyways, it is what it is and we move on.

 

[Fangs]

The mighty Panthers have defeated the Sydney City Roosters. No number of Uncle Nick's cheques and deplorable refereeing from Ben Cummins could stop us today.

Maloney playing his best football since early 2018. With Keary injured I think the NSW 6 is his. He is exactly what NSW were missing in the second half of Origin 1.

 

[Unscrupulous]

What they are saying is it should have been called a dominant tackle and thus he has more time to get up. If he did indeed call it a dominant tackle then he called the penalty too early.

Anyways, it is what it is and we move on.

He didn't call it a dominant tackle. To quote Cummins, "I know it looks strong but it isn't".

Lmfao.

 

[snickers007]

Why does the referee call 'dominant' and 'surrender' then?

Must just be for the lols hey.

The referee calls "surrender" it must be a rule.

Also:

The referee sin binned him, clearly an incorrect decision!


Make up your mind.

 

[ODC]

The spirit of lord Jesus Christ (Scott Sattler) has arisen

 

[Hutty1986]

Hopefully Maloney backs up today with a good game next week and gets the #6 spot back for NSW.

 

[Valheru]

He didn't call it a dominant tackle. To quote Cummins, "I know it looks strong but it isn't".

Lmfao.

Yeah I wasn't sure if he did call it and just called a penalty early or didn't call it at all

 

[Unscrupulous]

The referee calls "surrender" it must be a rule.

Also:

The referee sin binned him, clearly an incorrect decision!


Make up your mind.

What the actual chicken McShit are you on about?

If you didn't know that a Surrender tackle was a rule then you deadset need to give it up. Honestly.

 

[Valheru]

The mighty Panthers have defeated the Sydney City Roosters. No number of Uncle Nick's cheques and deplorable referring from Ben Cummins could stop us today.

Maloney playing his best football since early 2018. With Keary injured I think the NSW 6 is his. He is exactly what NSW were missing in the second half of Origin 1.

Yet another team overcomes our trillion dollar cap and paying off of the refs.

We really need to reconsider this arrangement, I don't feel we are getting value for money