What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2025 FW2 SF Sat - Canberra 12-32 Cronulla @ GIO

Who wins?


  • Total voters
    48
  • Poll closed .

Chimp

Bench
Messages
3,237
Sharks haven't looked back since McInness got injured. Look better in fact.
This also coincided with our coach doing the thing we’d all be crying out for, 4 forwards on the bench and dumping the bullshit Atkinson at 14 tactic, that saw him getting 5 token minutes as a middle every game,
Since we moved to a big bopper bench rotation, we’ve kicked the front door down once Sifa, Hazleton, BHU etc have come on.
Oh, and Billy Burns has gone beast mode.
 

Rudy

Juniors
Messages
1,558
Oh well. The good news for Canberra is that they do have a lot of very good players, and now they have some recent finals experience, even though the experience was negative. Maybe next year is the year for them.
 

mave

Coach
Messages
14,715
Oh well. The good news for Canberra is that they do have a lot of very good players, and now they have some recent finals experience, even though the experience was negative. Maybe next year is the year for them.

It's going to take them a generation to get over blowing that game against the Broncs.

Shame.
 

JamesRustle

First Grade
Messages
9,470
This also coincided with our coach doing the thing we’d all be crying out for, 4 forwards on the bench and dumping the bullshit Atkinson at 14 tactic, that saw him getting 5 token minutes as a middle every game,
Since we moved to a big bopper bench rotation, we’ve kicked the front door down once Sifa, Hazleton, BHU etc have come on.
Oh, and Billy Burns has gone beast mode.
Sifa looks immense with bigger minutes!

Burns having a break out year.

Just don't go getting DA injured in the next 1-2 weeks.
 

Woody90

Bench
Messages
4,168
I really think a lot of the Raiders issues last night came down to coaching.

Stick is obviously a good motivator and has a good ability to create a siege mentality to get his side up, but tactically there were some horrible decisions last night:

- Trying to win by playing a grinding style of footy despite them being successful this year by attacking.
- Again too many hit ups in the oppositions end. There have always been some questions regarding the Sharks resilience and yet they play a style that makes it easy on them.
- Not replacing Strange with another half to take some pressure off Fogarty. They wouldn’t have won the MP this year without Fogarty, but now he’s probably going to be ripped from pillar to post for not being able to control and win the game all himself.

Stuart has been coaching for so many years now and still seems to have a special ability to sabotage his team when it counts.
 

This Year?

Immortal
Messages
41,179
I feel for the Raiders. 4 weeks ago they're lifting the JJ and Ricky gives a speech about the job not being done.
Today they wake up probably still in shock over how such a great season has gone down the drain.

Although I don't like the Sharks I'm happy for Nicho who cops it deluxe (myself included) whenever he makes an error, but so far this finals he's been outstanding. Congrats to the Sharks who have just made the PF in consecutive seasons.
 

Black Panther

Juniors
Messages
2,400
Cracker of a game by the Sharks. They certainly proved me wrong, I had Canberra winning easily at home. Losing Strange was a massive out, but even with him I think the Sharks still would’ve won with that effort.
 
Messages
17,358
Raiders tactics lately has been very suspicious. The forward's get gassed out about the 60th minutes mark. Cause of it

That's because Ricky Stuart over uses his starters and often underuses his bench players. He started doing that at the Roosters in 2002 and little has changed.
 

Front-rower2

Juniors
Messages
151
This thread is disappointing as f**k. All the fake humility from the Sharks fans? Skeepe being courteous and logical? The weird f**king troll conversing with himself?

0 out of 10. Rip into each other you merkins.
It’s a disgrace. Not the LU I’ve grown up with over the last 20 years.
 
Top