What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2025 GF | PREMIERS - Brisbane 26-22 Melbourne @ Accor

Who wins the 2025 Grand Final?


  • Total voters
    36
  • Poll closed .

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
108,145
Jamie Buhrer is an origin rep. You can't tell me that if that tackle wasn't made by Walsh, it wouldn't have been a sin bin.

I've said in this thread that I think it was a shoulder charge and should have been binned. But when Klein Kampf ruled it wasn't, he basically couldn't be binned.

Loiero left the ground to hit a taller bloke high with his shoulder and no effort to wrap.

I'm saying they aren't the same tackle at all. Loiero could have been sent off in a regular season game and few would blink.
 

Someguy

First Grade
Messages
7,772
Sour grapes from me but a no try penalty for high contact instead of 7 tackle set after tui was hit around the jaw is the correct decision and likely ends in a different overall result

Edit: bunker is meant to make correct calls according to rules in a try scoring situation, if it was general play it’s not on report so no intervention
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
29,815
No I reckon it's even better than that

I reckon that Craig has got so overconfident that he's doing this to himself. Look at him being happy to keep washed Munster, apparently let Pezet go, and trying desperately to turn bums like Howarth and Anderson into those old Stomr specials (which were actually players with some talent but attitude issues like Cheyse Blair and Curtis Scott)
Tbh I think they should have turfed Munster a while ago but I always get the vibe that there's an arrogance in the Storm team that they know they can get back here so its not as a big deal to lose some. Or I'm just talking total shit. But i tipped Broncos purely on the fact I thought they'd want it more and they did, by a long way.
 

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
108,145
Sour grapes from me but a no try penalty for high contact instead of 7 tackle set after tui was hit around the jaw is the correct decision and likely ends in a different overall result

My man, for a Storm fan you go ok...and I think in a week or so you will realise that this post actually acknowledges it wasn't a penalty.

Because foul play preventing a try doesn't result in no try, penalty.

It was nothing.
 

firechild

First Grade
Messages
8,106
I've said in this thread that I think it was a shoulder charge and should have been binned. But when Klein Kampf ruled it wasn't, he basically couldn't be binned.

Loiero left the ground to hit a taller bloke high with his shoulder and no effort to wrap.

I'm saying they aren't the same tackle at all. Loiero could have been sent off in a regular season game and few would blink.
That's totally fair and sin bin or send off, nobody will care when it happens with 3 minutes to go. Fundamentally I don't think we disagree. Walsh should have been off for 10 minutes.
 

Saxon

Bench
Messages
3,699
My man, for a Storm fan you go ok...and I think in a week or so you will realise that this post actually acknowledges it wasn't a penalty.

Because foul play preventing a try doesn't result in no try, penalty.

It was nothing.
Can you imagine the outcome if it was Walsh though?
 

Munky

Coach
Messages
14,155
Tbh I think they should have turfed Munster a while ago but I always get the vibe that there's an arrogance in the Storm team that they know they can get back here so its not as a big deal to lose some. Or I'm just talking total shit. But i tipped Broncos purely on the fact I thought they'd want it more and they did, by a long way.

Outside of Paps the Storm were Cam Newton in the super bowl. Just watched the ball on the ground multiple times.

It's a shame Paps lost his top end speed. He goes the distance on the line breaks with his 2020 speed.

The Storm played like they'll be back next week.
 
Top