2025 R13 Sat - Gold Coast 16-28 Melbourne @ Cbus

[Tom155]

Also shocking nobody kasey badger f**king up matches with her horrible decisions time and time again

 

[Generalzod]

View attachment 102648

Lol no. There's a reason they have those white lines on the field. Front foot clearly in front of the kickers.

Sure it is..

 

[Quicksilver]

It was obviously for Papenhuyzen, who played them like a fiddle. Bunker get played by defenders being impeded regularly. Paps had all the time in the world to stand on the other side of him.

Not only that, but pap had hold of the man playing the ball.

 

[no name]

Papz is on 13+

 

[speedster]

View attachment 102648

Lol no. There's a reason they have those white lines on the field. Front foot clearly in front of the kickers.

Those white lines are to measure 10m and 20m in from the sideline for the restart options. They are not aligned as far as north-south is concerned. And AKP is behind the top of the line nearest him while Foran is before the beginning of the line ahead of him for the loosest reference if we were to use them which we shouldn't.

 

[dogslife]

View attachment 102648

Lol no. There's a reason they have those white lines on the field. Front foot clearly in front of the kickers.

Melbourne game day threads are the f**king best!

 

[Mr. Shaman]

I thought the white lines were for Munster

 

[Bazal]

Papz speaks far too well for a man who looks like he lives in a government flat in Revesby

 

[speedster]

I thought the white lines were for Munster

Before and after the game.

 

[Apey]

I've always wondered why a Knights fan simps for the Storm.

I now think it's because you have undiagnosed sight defects and actually aren't aware of who you're looking at

A simple "I was wrong" would suffice.

 

[Bazal]

A simple "I was wrong" would suffice.

He's onside in the snip lol

 

[Generalzod]

A simple "I was wrong" would suffice.

We know you are wrong the screen shot proves it…

 

[no name]

View attachment 102648

Lol no. There's a reason they have those white lines on the field. Front foot clearly in front of the kickers.

That screen shot isn’t painting the picture you think it is.

 

[Apey]

Those white lines are to measure 10m and 20m in from the sideline for the restart options. They are not aligned as far as north-south is concerned. And AKP is behind the top of the line nearest him while Foran is before the beginning of the line ahead of him for the loosest reference if we were to use them which we shouldn't.

Yes, they are for 10m and 20m in from the sideline. The rest is incorrect. They do line-up north-south. That's why they're placed staggered like that and not just on the same line.

 

[Warrimoo3]

NAS was clearly offside when he chased Hughes’ kick with 26 min to go in the 2nd half. A good metre. That was the one where Melbourne challenged the NAS knock on and the bunker upheld the challenge. The bunker did not check whether The chaser (NAS) was onside. They only looked at the challenge. It resulted in 6 points to the Storm. Badger should be sacked for not following protocol by

 

[speedster]

Yes, they are for 10m and 20m in from the sideline. The rest is incorrect. They do line-up north-south. That's why they're placed staggered like that and not just on the same line.

But they're staggered, as you say yourself. So, they can't possibly be a north-south reference.

Not for the fully able-visioned anyway.

 

[Apey]

NAS was clearly offside when he chased Hughes’ kick with 26 min to go in the 2nd half. A good metre. That was the one where Melbourne challenged the NAS knock on and the bunker upheld the challenge. The bunker did not check whether The chaser (NAS) was onside. They only looked at the challenge. It resulted in 6 points to the Storm. Badger should be sacked for not following protocol by

Just had a look. Nah. Ball has already left Hughes foot and NAS's foot only needs to be behind the ball kicking foot anyway.

 

[no name]

NAS was clearly offside when he chased Hughes’ kick with 26 min to go in the 2nd half. A good metre. That was the one where Melbourne challenged the NAS knock on and the bunker upheld the challenge. The bunker did not check whether The chaser (NAS) was onside. They only looked at the challenge. It resulted in 6 points to the Storm. Badger should be sacked for not following protocol by

She was taking ages to make a decision a while back and was criticised for it.
She seems keen to make a decision quick now, correct or not.

 

[speedster]

There's no clear, definitive indicator for the correct centimetre required to make that call.

The correct call should be that it's line ball and therefore too close to make a call of offside.

It shits me when they miss howlers and then act like they have superman-like laser vision on other calls that are bee's dicks one way or the other.

Make the obvious calls and stop trying to suddenly be super-f**king-man!

 

[no name]

Just had a look. Nah. Ball has already left Hughes foot and NAS's foot only needs to be behind the ball kicking foot anyway.
View attachment 102651

NAS is pretty much the same distance back from the kicker than AKP was. Both behind.