What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2025 WTC FINAL: Aust v SA @ Lords, June 11-15

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
106,048
Bit of a shame the selectors didn't have the balls to stick with Smiffy.

Bit of a shame they didn't start bringing an opener or two though 3 years ago. Since Little Davey retired we've tried the world's best middle order bat, given a debutante middle order bat a couple of sacrificial Tests against Bumrah, tried an actual opener who is too young to grow pubes yet, and now looking at trying a tinny middle order bat whose eyes are too close together. It's a bit of a joke tbh.

For all the uselessness of guys like Hilditch and Hohns and other selectors back in the day, they generally found a way to give players some exposure and get them more ready to spot in down the track. They even worked with players to change their role at state level if they thought there was another avenue for them.
 

Chins

Juniors
Messages
1,557
Bit of a shame they didn't start bringing an opener or two though 3 years ago. Since Little Davey retired we've tried the world's best middle order bat, given a debutante middle order bat a couple of sacrificial Tests against Bumrah, tried an actual opener who is too young to grow pubes yet, and now looking at trying a tinny middle order bat whose eyes are too close together. It's a bit of a joke tbh.

For all the uselessness of guys like Hilditch and Hohns and other selectors back in the day, they generally found a way to give players some exposure and get them more ready to spot in down the track. They even worked with players to change their role at state level if they thought there was another avenue for them.
Well yeah if he had an opening option but we haven't really. Renshaw is the only guy with any sort of ability really
 

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
106,048
Well yeah if he had an opening option but we haven't really. Renshaw is the only guy with any sort of ability really

Yeah but if they saw McSweeney as an actual option, get him in there in the middle earlier rather than Darsh and have him open for SA. For eg. Or get Mad Marn back in Shield while he's batting shit and have him open.
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
16,540
I'm all about Smith back to 3.

The 3 has a phallic nature to it in Australian cricket. A revered position. You give it to your best batsman. It never should have been given to Marnus when we had Steve Smith in the team. The rest of the order can figure itself out.
 

TheParraboy

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
70,400
Marnus looking likely as opener...

Khawaja backs Labuschagne to come good as Australia's Test opener​

Australia's selectors will likely opt for Labuschagne's experience over dropping him in favour of 19-year-old Sam Konstas

Opening the batting may not be Marnus Labuschagne's preferred option, but Usman Khawaja has said that sometimes players need to take a role that is best for the team rather than the individual and backed him to make a success of it should that be the selectors' call at Lord's.

Labuschagne is firming as the likely option to walk out alongside Khawaja in the World Test Championship final as Australia juggle their batting order. When it was suggested last year that Labuschagne could be an option at the top of the order after David Warner's retirement, Khawaja said he had "opening-itis" and on Monday joked again that he wasn't really over it.

However, it appears the selectors will opt for Labuschagne's experience and Test record - which includes 11 centuries - over dropping him in favour of 19-year-old Sam Konstas, who was handed a debut against India when Australia wanted someone to take the game on. Should that transpire, it shapes as a key moment as Labuschagne fights to secure his Test spot with the selectors keen to settle down an opening combination ahead of the Ashes later this year.

"You don't always get to choose in Australia. You've got six of the best batsmen in the country," Khawaja said while promoting Prime Video who will broadcast the final in Australia. "Like I've said in the past, there are plenty of times where I prefer to bat in other positions. But beggars can't be choosers. You just have to be humble that you're playing for Australia."

1749533825147.png



Labuschagne has previously opened 15 times in first-class cricket although only once since 2016, but as a regular No.3 knows there is a chance he could be in for the second ball of an innings.

"You take what you get and you make the best out of it. At the end of the day, it's a team game," said Khawaja, who moved permanently into the opening role in early 2022 after returning to the side with twin hundreds against England at No. 5. "The best place for me to bat for the team is to open. So I'm very happy to open and do my role for the team. I'm sure if it's the same for Marnus, I'm 100%. I know he'll take that role.

"[When] you bat three, I think the opening is an easier transition. The only time it's hard is when you bat second. You have to run off and change [into] your pads. Usually when I was at three, I just put my feet up. You don't get to do that anymore. That's the biggest difference. But Marnus is a terrific player. If he gets an opportunity, I'm sure he'll be fine."


 
Top