0How many weeks in the Chin Bin?
Abdo apply the blow torch and send him to the EelsMakasini is a scary prospect.
Correct but it was shoulder to shoulderIf Cleary made direct contact to the head, shouldn’t the other player have gone off for a HIA?
I concur. You're not sooking mate, just like I'm not sooking in the WCC thread like that clown @some11 said. We're just 2 guys pointing out that Ash Klein is a stain on the game. He manages teams back into games, he makes up his own rules and just blatantly gets calls wrong on a consistent basis.Not sooking either. Was just bad both ways
Cleary cops 2 weeks.Makasini will cop a few weeks for making direct contact with Nathan Cleary's untucked, lunging shoulder, with his chin, no less. Poor Nathan, he even left the ground to try and avoid it.

Cleary cops 2 weeks.
![]()
Cleary cops high tackle charge
Panthers co-captain Nathan Cleary has been charged by the NRL Match Review Committee following Friday night’s trial match against the Wests Tigers at Leichhardt Oval.www.penrithpanthers.com.au
Cleary must have needed more force into the face to get away with it.
View attachment 109828
Of the 3 sides still able to topple the Tigers & win the pre season challenge ... Im not sure any of them will win their games let alone anything else
Initial contact was shoulder to shoulder.
Initial contact was shoulder to shoulder.
You can’t blame Nafe for the tackle. Just like you can’t blame him for his piss poor performances in Origin every year.Yes. Then it hit the bloke in the head
think that means grade one then if its shoulder first that bounces upYes. Then it hit the bloke in the head
Especially when the bloke didn't go off for a HIAthink that means grade one then if its shoulder first that bounces up
Cleary cops 2 weeks.
![]()
Cleary cops high tackle charge
Panthers co-captain Nathan Cleary has been charged by the NRL Match Review Committee following Friday night’s trial match against the Wests Tigers at Leichhardt Oval.www.penrithpanthers.com.au
Cleary must have needed more force into the face to get away with it.
View attachment 109828
That makes it the correct decision by the NRL.Harry Grant is still whinging about it.
