What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2026 rumoured and confirmed signings

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
14,584
Siale Faeamani who came thru our juniors and played in last years jersey Flegg grand final making his debut for Titans in tonight’s trial.
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
24,726
Cole would be the best option at 14 if he could gets some minutes at 9. Covers a lot of positions in the backline and defends well enough to cover hooker for limited minutes.

If it is a choice between him and Cogger, it would be Cole for me.

Think he was hard done by to not get that role last year tbh
 

Luke Bowden

First Grade
Messages
8,428
Cole would be the best option at 14 if he could gets some minutes at 9. Covers a lot of positions in the backline and defends well enough to cover hooker for limited minutes.

If it is a choice between him and Cogger, it would be Cole for me.
I agree, I think he’d make an excellent 14
 

Oldpanther86

Juniors
Messages
1,199
Cole would be the best option at 14 if he could gets some minutes at 9. Covers a lot of positions in the backline and defends well enough to cover hooker for limited minutes.

If it is a choice between him and Cogger, it would be Cole for me.

I argued for this last year but Ivan loves his washed up/never has been old half at 14.
 

Iamback

Referee
Messages
22,380
The last two premiership winners who werent named Penrith did it with a half on the bench. Both GF teams had halves on the bench this year.

Both sides used 17 though, that is the difference.

We lost Sorro early in the Preliminary final. Schneider got garbage time at the end.

Laurie playing allows Tago to get time in the pack. Garner should be on 50-60 mins at most.

It goes with the fading away late we had for most of the season
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
24,726
Both sides used 17 though, that is the difference.

We lost Sorro early in the Preliminary final. Schneider got garbage time at the end.

Laurie playing allows Tago to get time in the pack. Garner should be on 50-60 mins at most.

It goes with the fading away late we had for most of the season

So we shouldve carried a specialist full back to get Tago into the pack? Sure lets reshuffle the backline due to an injury in the backrow. We will chuck laurie on the wing where he sucks, paul in the centres where he got dropped from at the start of the year and tago in the pack where he hasnt played consistently since sg ball, Genius!



At the end of the day the last 10 years have seen coaches carrying halves on the bench having a lot of success.
 

Iamback

Referee
Messages
22,380
So we shouldve carried a specialist full back to get Tago into the pack? Sure lets reshuffle the backline due to an injury in the backrow. We will chuck laurie on the wing where he sucks, paul in the centres where he got dropped from at the start of the year and tago in the pack where he hasnt played consistently since sg ball, Genius!



At the end of the day the last 10 years have seen coaches carrying halves on the bench having a lot of success.

I am in the Cole should have been 14 camp. Laurie was the 18. He can play wing too at a push

The game has changed. 10 years hell even 5 years ago, Sorro isn't ruled out. He passed his HIA. That then gives us a fresh Garner to slot back into rotation

Schneider didn't get on in 2024.
21 and 22. Ivan ran with a proper utility.

2023 Cogger did play because to cover Luai. We still had Fish so could use Smith as a back row cover.

Storm used Wishart as the 14, He plays anywhere.

Broncos had Mam but Hunt is a 9 in that setup

We didn't use the 14 for 13 games last year. Had some pretty disappointing fade outs

You need a versatile bench that includes a role for the 14 if injuries don't hit
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
24,726
I am in the Cole should have been 14 camp. Laurie was the 18. He can play wing too at a push

The game has changed. 10 years hell even 5 years ago, Sorro isn't ruled out. He passed his HIA. That then gives us a fresh Garner to slot back into rotation

Schneider didn't get on in 2024.
21 and 22. Ivan ran with a proper utility.

2023 Cogger did play because to cover Luai. We still had Fish so could use Smith as a back row cover.

Storm used Wishart as the 14, He plays anywhere.

Broncos had Mam but Hunt is a 9 in that setup

We didn't use the 14 for 13 games last year. Had some pretty disappointing fade outs

You need a versatile bench that includes a role for the 14 if injuries don't hit


I agree with Cole, he was the best option. Wishart plays anywhere cause he never established himself as a starting half, ive said for a while most good utilities are just halves that never cracked it, like Cole looks like hes heading.

Im just pointing that the criticism Ivans for carrying a half at all is ridiculous, its very easy for me to make that look silly, its a general, lazy observation that isnt close to accurate. You have put some thought it into it and your argument seems to be he shouldve used a different half or used the minutes differently, not that he should never carry a half.
 

Iamback

Referee
Messages
22,380
I agree with Cole, he was the best option. Wishart plays anywhere cause he never established himself as a starting half, ive said for a while most good utilities are just halves that never cracked it, like Cole looks like hes heading.

Im just pointing that the criticism Ivans for carrying a half at all is ridiculous, its very easy for me to make that look silly, its a general, lazy observation that isnt close to accurate. You have put some thought it into it and your argument seems to be he shouldve used a different half or used the minutes differently, not that he should never carry a half.

It isn't ridiculous because with the games evolution. Guys like Crossland are perfect example of a half but he can do a job elsewhere in the pack.

If Ivan is going to carry a half. The half needs to be trusted at 13 and a prop in the 17 needs to be flexible to play on an edge.

Of find a makeshift half,
 
Top