As much as everyone would enjoy the lols if Souffs lose, they deserve to be in a prelim more that the Raiders.
Any team that gets thumped 40 zip at home in the rain doesnt deserve to be playing finals. More proof we need a top 5.
Firstly, I'm not disputing the fact that Souths have been more consistent this season. No dispute whatsoever.
I do disagree though that we don't deserve to be here.
No matter what happens, whether we lose this week or make it to the GF (highly unlikely), everyone is going to think of this run as a fluke like the Tigers of '05 or the Eels of '09.
The simple fact is that we have a very young roster and especially young halves who are now learning to take control of a team without our best player in Campese. Things have finally started to click in terms of our execution but also our attitude. If we had just fluked 5 games in a row, I would have agreed with you. But look at the way we have put some teams to the sword this year, specifically Melbourne and the Bulldogs. Then against the Warriors and Sharks, we were in positions where in years gone by, we would have given up and lost both games. But we have mentally turned the corner and this young team is now responding to what Furner is preaching.
Again, not disputing that Souths deserve to be there. I just disagree that we don't deserve to be there because if you look at our season as a whole, we are a much better footy team than we were at the midpoint of the year, and it's not because of luck, it's because of experience, attitude and execution.