3-2-1 Player Votes v. Tigers

[legend]

Kahler certainly had a dog but he gets pummelled at the advantage line all the time. He's simply not big enough to be a yardage man in the NRL. he's probably 10kg's too light at the moment.

3 - Carney
2 - Schif
1 - Croker

 

[thickos]

Yeah I thought Kahler got smashed up a bit again, as usual. I wasn't that impressed but maybe I'm too eager to find the bad spots in his game...

3 - Schifcofske. Glad he played the way he did but it just makes it harder to say goodbye.

2 - Weyman. 6 games in a row now - WOOT!

1 - Croker. Big effort in what has been a tough couple of weeks for the old bugger.

 

[Chachi]

2. Schif - outstanding player, hated his decision to attempt the penalty shot though.
1. Tilse - excellent workrate. 33 tackles, over 100 metres and a couple of offloads - just gets better every week in FG IMO.
1. Kahler - nice game too, although I still worry every time he takes a hitup!
1. Tongue - freak. Over 40 odd tackles again.
1. Croker - just hold onto the ball and keep it going son!

 

[waltzing Meninga]

Our best player was Shif, but I don't think he should be elligable for a "fans" award at the end of the season considering the way he has treated the fans and the club. Played unreal though.

3 - Croker - can someone tell him that he is NOT to offload the ball under any circumstances!!! He has a ripper of a game every time he just puts his head down and runs the ball. still one of the finest defenders in the NRL

2 - Smith - did some ordinary things but we wouldn't have won without him.

1 - Weyman - Why the f**k does he not start the game??? we always seem to be down by 10 or 12 points before he comes on and makes an impact!

 

[sanjane]

3- Schif
2- Smith
1- Toots

I thought Withers had a great game. he dropped some ball but looked dangerous, made a couple of line breaks and made some try-saving tackles. Carney was good off the bench, as were Kahler and Weyman. Hodgson was OK as well.

I thought Graham was great, looked for the ball and looked threatening. And Tongue- great as usual, in everything, and unluckly not to get a try.

 

[Timbo]

3-Schif. Still a bastard but great game.
2-Smith. I'm starting to wonder with our talent drain, and performances like that, if a third year isn't warranted?
1-Carney. Really starting to step up.

 

[Poida_Raider]

3 - Schifcofske
2 - Kahler
1 - Thommo

 

[whatwhat]

3. Schif
2. Croker
1. Kahler

 

[dubby]

Kahler gets hammered but I still rate him higher than Rothery or Martin.
Kahler seems more effective in attack and in defence is more mobile and fitter IMO.

If Mick Weyman stays fit *touches alot of wood* he will be our next Aust.rep.
This guy is an absolute legend in the making.

 

[woodgers]

Can't really vote this week. Listened to the 1st half on the old walkman but watched the 2nd half at home. I don't like to vote unless I have seen the whole thing. Schif was outstanding in the 2nd half though.

It was interesting to see Schif line up a conversion from half way, is he preparing for Union already? Next week, FG in the first 5 minutes!