What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

3-2-1 vs Warriors

Inferno

Coach
Messages
18,488
Why is it if Beau scott plays well he doesn't rank well because he doesn't get much game time, but if he playes poorly he gets rated as sh*t? Show some consistancy please, he was fine last night.
 

blacktip-reefy

Immortal
Messages
34,076
Inferno said:
Why is it if Beau scott plays well he doesn't rank well because he doesn't get much game time, but if he playes poorly he gets rated as sh*t? Show some consistancy please, he was fine last night.

Actually his first 3 attempts at tackles nearly all resulted in tries. Saved his own asss twice & kearney another.
Dreadful.
 

emetic

Juniors
Messages
274
3. Bird
2. Bailey
1. Simmo/kingston

good to see simmo directing the defence from behind ... he seems to be getting much more involved
 

blacktip-reefy

Immortal
Messages
34,076
chili pepper said:
mmmm the Wok mentioned today that Kimmorley was terrific last night and that his kicking was great.
Well he gave him far too much credit & the warriors too much credit.
They were completely dis-interested i nbeing there.
 

sharkmachine07

Juniors
Messages
798
3 bird playin good footy and i think is looking for a new contract
2 albet good speed read the defence well / kingston play really well all season
1 gallen good strong runs

noddy playin better but needs to play deeper still
villa didn't play that good
 

Gummy_shark

Juniors
Messages
68
3 Bird..playing his best footy
2 Simmons cleaned up in defence and solid all over the park
1 Dougie...defensive machine last nite
 

byrne_rovelli_fan82

First Grade
Messages
7,477
I find, whenever I watc the Sharks...Kimmorley especially. Whenever he passes long (which is the suseptiable ones to be intercepted) I tend to hold my breath. Anyone else?
 

Surely

Post Whore
Messages
107,200
blacktip-reefy said:
Bailey
Dougie
Kearney

Inverse
Kimmorley
scott
simmons

I'm going to ask a couple of questions here, because i like to ask them of the man who will tell you black is white.

If simmons or scott had let the try in that bailey did, what would be your response.

why do you rate douglas ahead of bird, gallen and williams, when last night we had 3 back rowers doing the work our props should have.
 

White Poiner

Coach
Messages
11,331
Card Shark said:
Haven't seen the full game but Bird seemed to go good by popular opinion.
He is only 22 or 23, most forget that!

Does not matter if the is 16.. He has had enough sh*t games to last a players whole career.
 

blacktip-reefy

Immortal
Messages
34,076
1. Baileys reads save our asses every games. Sure he misses the odd crucial one like hedid last week, coming in to assist kearney on a bigger man. His 20 or so weekly tackles are solid & he glues that side of the field together. A lot of Bails work is the stuff not a lot of people don't notice. Even off the ball stuff like getting under players skins.
If somebodey like scott, who has a solid tackling technique & is a big unit misses, then it is a read error generally. & his reads have been awful of late & that is why he being made look, well, stupid. But I actually think hes a handy player & dont want him to get the punt. & I dont want him to get gifted 60 games of first grade on the back of poor form.

Dougies tackling last night was first class. Driving tackles, hurting tackles & lots of them. Gallens were good too, so was Birds, generally.
Williams defense is excellent too, but he he is not troubling the defense with his attack. Dougie is, thats why he gets the points for mine.
Bird is finally improving but what odds would you get gallen & Bird error counts? no errors would be very long odds.
 

PHaTMaN

Juniors
Messages
2,411
3 - Bird
2 - Gallen
1 - Simmo

Noddy would have gotten a point if it weren't for the two intercepts. I thought he was good except for those.
 

carcharias

Immortal
Messages
43,118
3-Bird . Dunno if he was better or it's just that he played good for him.
2- Williams . Solid
1- Bailey . Apart from the dropped ball over the line I thought he did well again.

They looked like they were cruising for much of the game.
If it weren't for that one Sione fella the Warriors would have never even looked like scoring .
umm
well Noddy helped that as well.
 

Latest posts

Top