What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

AFL 2004 - Round 17

CyberKev

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
2,323
ST KILDA v ESSENDON
Friday, 7:40pm (EST), Telstra Dome

ST KILDA
B: Baker, S.Fisher, Voss
HB: Jones, Ferguson, Goddard
C: Black, Hayes, X.Clarke
HF: Guerra, Riewoldt, Montagna
F: Milne, Gehrig, Dal Santo
FOLL: Knobel, Harvey, Ball
I/C: Thompson, R.Clarke, Blake, Peckett
EMG: Brooks, Stone, Murray
IN: X Clarke, R Clarke, Gehrig
OUT: Hamill (hip), Gram (hamstring), Powell (ankle)
NEW: R.Clarke (18, St Marys NT)

ESSENDON
B: McVeigh, Fletcher, Welsh
HB: Richards, Solomon, Bolton
C: Stanton, Misiti, Peverill
HF: Murphy, McPhee, Hird
F: Hille, Lloyd, Lovett-Murray
FOLL: Allan, J.Johnson, M.Johnson
I/C: Ramanauskas, Bradley, Haynes, Bullen
EMG: Alvey, Mercuri, Winderlich
IN: Hird
OUT: Dyson



KANGAROOS v HAWTHORN
Saturday, 2:10pm (EST), MCG

KANGAROOS
B: Makepeace, Watt, M.Stevens
HB: Archer, Brown, Colbert
C: A.Stevens, Wells, Simpson
HF: B.Harvey, Petrie, Motlop
F: Co.Jones Rocca, Hale
FOLL: Porter, Harris, Grant
I/C: King, Sinclair, S.Harvey, Firrito
EMG: Baird, S.Clayton, Watson
IN: Hale
OUT: Rawlings (suspended)

HAWTHORN
B: Barlow, Hay, Graham
HB: Beaumont, Croad, Smith
C: Clarke, Mitchell, Greene
HF: Lekkas, Thompson, Ladson
F: Brown, Holland, Hodge
FOLL: Everitt, Ries, Ball
I/C: Williams, Bateman, Lonie, Kane
EMG: Picioane, Barker, Cox
IN: Holland, Ladson, Lonie
OUT: Campbell, Osborne, Sewell


FREMANTLE v SYDNEY
Saturday, 2:10pm (WST), Subiaco Oval

FREMANTLE
B: Woods, Haddrill, Hayden
HB: Parker, Polak, Thornton
C: Walker, Bell, McManus
HF: Browne, Pavlich, Schammer
F: Farmer, Simmonds, Medhurst
FOLL: J.Longmuir, Hasleby, Headland
I/C: Sandilands, Cook, Murphy, Siegert
EMG: Smith, Grover, T.Longmuir
IN: None
OUT: None

SYDNEY
B: Crouch, Schauble, C.Bolton
HB: Barry, Goodes, Kennelly
C: Maxfield, Williams, Mathews
HF: O'Keefe, Hall, Ablett
F: Bevan, O'Loughlin, Nicks
FOLL: Ball, Kirk, J.Bolton
I/C: Buchanan, Doyle, Fosdike, Schneider
EMG: Dempster, James, McVeigh
IN: Williams
OUT: McVeigh


BRISBANE LIONS v ADELAIDE
Saturday, 7:10pm (EST), Gabba

BRISBANE LIONS
B: Johnson, Michael, C.Scott
HB: Copeland, Leppitsch, Lappin
C: Notting, Hadley, Akermanis
HF: Caracella, Bradshaw, McGrath
F: Hart, Lynch, Voss
FOLL: Charman, Black, Power
I/C: McRae, McLaren, Macdonald, Pike
EMG: Adcock, Rischitelli, White
IN: None
OUT: None

ADELAIDE
B: Bassett, Rutten, Massie
HB: Shirley, McGregor, Reilly
C: Mattner, Ricciuto, Goodwin
HF: Johncock, Bock, Edwards
F: Jericho, Welsh, S.Stevens
FOLL: Clarke, Stenglein, McLeod
I/C: Watts, Skipworth, Gallagher, Biglands
EMG: Hudson, Perrie, Ladhams
IN: Massie, S.Stevens, Jericho
OUT: Doughty (eye), Torney (back), Hentschel (ankle)

WESTERN BULLDOGS v COLLINGWOOD
Saturday, 7:10pm (EST), Telstra Dome

WESTERN BULLDOGS
B: Boyd, Harris, Koops
HB: Smith, Grant, Gilbee
C: Power, West, McMahon
HF: R.Murphy, Rawlings, Eagleton
F: Bowden, Darcy, Cooney
FOLL: Street, Cross, Johnson
I/C: Hahn, Ray, Robbins, Skipper
EMG: Birss, Hargrave, Bandy
IN: Cooney
OUT: Harrison

COLLINGWOOD
B: Johnson, Prestigiacomo, Clement
HB: Cole, J.Cloke, Lonie
C: Woewodin, Buckley, King
HF: Lockyer, Fraser, Davis
F: Maxwell, Lokan, Holland
FOLL: McKee, Burns, Licuria
I/C: Rowe, O'Bree, R.Shaw, Walker
EMG: McGough, Williams, Crow
IN: King, J Cloke, Walker
OUT: Rocca (ankle), Wakelin (arm), Swan


PORT ADELAIDE v WEST COAST
Sunday, 12:40pm (CST), AAMI Stadium

PORT ADELAIDE
B: Wilson, Wakelin, Bishop
HB: Poulton, C.Cornes, Kingsley
C: Cassisi, James, K.Cornes
HF: Pickett, Tredrea, Dew
F: Schofield, Thurstans, S.Burgoyne
FOLL: Brogan, Carr, P.Burgoyne
I/C (from): Ebert, Hardwick, Lade, Mahoney, Pettigrew, Symes, White
IN: Bishop, Pettigrew, Symes
OUT: None

WEST COAST
B: Chick, Glass, Hunter
HB: Morrison, Lynch, Wirrpunda
C: Butler, Fletcher, Waters
HF: R.Jones, Staker, Adkins
F: Matera, Seaby, Sampi
FOLL: Cox, Judd, Kerr
I/C (from): Braun, Beeck, Banfield, Carroll, B.Jones, Green, Wooden
IN: Staker, Green, Carroll, Beeck, B.Jones
OUT: Hansen (hamstring), McDougall (shoulder)


GEELONG v CARLTON
Sunday, 2:10pm, Telstra Dome

GEELONG
B: Corey, Scarlett, Milburn
HB: Hunt, Harley, Sanderson
C: Wojcinski, Ling, D.Johnson
HF: Kingsley, Mooney, Bartel
F: S.Johnson, Graham, Gardiner
FOLL: King, Chapman, Ablett
I/C (from): Chambers, Spriggs, Koulouriotis, Haynes, Callan, Byrnes, Enright
IN: Mooney, Enright, Haynes, Spriggs, Koulouriotis
OUT: Riccardi (hamstring), Mackie

CARLTON
B: Houlihan, Thornton, Norman
HB: Lappin, Morrell, Teague
C: Prendergast, Johnson, Walker
HF: Camporeale, Whitnall, Koutoufides
F: Deluca, Fevola, Scotland
FOLL: French, McGrath, Stevens
I/C (from): Bannister, Clarke, Davies, Fisher, Harford, McCormick, Waite
IN: Clarke, Harford, Waite
OUT: None


RICHMOND v MELBOURNE
Sunday, 2:10pm (EST), MCG

RICHMOND
B: A.Kellaway, Jackson, Chaffey
HB: Newman, Zantuck, Fiora
C: Bowden, Dragicevic, Pettifer
HF: Tivendale, Richardson, Hartigan
F: Krakouer, Moore, Fleming
FOLL: Ottens, Johnson, Brown
I/C (from): Hyde, Tuck, Rodan, Blumfield, Houlihan, Hall, Roach
IN: Chaffey, Dragicevic, Houlihan
OUT: None

MELBOURNE
B: Wheatley, Nicholson, Brown
HB: Broadbridge, Bizzell, Whelan
C: Walsh, Read, Yze
HF: Robertson, Miller, Green
F: Vardy, Neitz, Holland
FOLL: White, Bruce, Heffernan
I/C (from): Johnstone, McLean, Rigoni, Ward, Bell, Williams, Jolly
IN: Bizzell, Jolly, Bell, Williams, Ward
OUT: Rivers (general soreness), Davey (hamstring)


St Kilda (36)
Kangaroos (46)
Fremantle (12)
Brisbane (60)
Collingwood (22)
Port Adelaide (50)
Geelong (30)
Melbourne (37)


Seventeen weeks into the season and I'm still desperately seeking a perfect 8...

Don't fancy my chances, in all honesty, although with Hawthorn, Richmond and the Bulldogs running around its nice to be guaranteed at least 3 for the round.

You can really make it a certain 4, given that embattled Adelaide have drawn the short straw of playing Brisbane in Brisbane.

Port will murderise West Coast and Geelong will roll over Carlton with relative ease, which only leaves 2 games of genuine interest for the whole round.

In normal circumstances you'd expect St Kilda to thrash an Essendon side like this one, but the Bombers will be ultra desperate and many holes have been found in the Saint veneer of late. At the end of the day, however, St Kilda has the greater talent and Essendon has struggled to merely man them up in recent times. Add to this the harsh reality that Hird can't be close to fit and the Saints are rarely beaten at the Dome and the key pointers lead to the Moorabbin faithful hanging on to top spot (at least for another week).

Freo and Sydney should be the tightest clash of the round, as is also the most difficult to pick. Freo are a side that you can never pick with any confidence and the Swans continue to underwhelm with their inate averageness. I suspect both sides are bound for lower eight spots, but Freo can least afford to lose here. As such, it has to come down to the old favourite 'home ground' backstop, and that's precisely how I'm tipping here.


CyberKev[/b]
 

Beaussie

First Grade
Messages
6,021
St Kilda v Essendon
Kangaroos v Hawthorn
Fremantle v Sydney
Brisbane v Adelaide
Western Bulldogs v Collingwood
Port Adelaide v West Coast
Geelong v Carlton
Richmond v Melbourne
 

Cricketer

Juniors
Messages
139
Saints
Roos
Freo
Brizroy
Dogs
Port
Cats (By a whisker)
Demons

Go Tigers though. I was going to pick the Bombers but the Perth factor may play a part - I cant see Hird playing but you never know. The others seem clear cut, I would have picked the Hawks but Schwabby is seeing out the year so thats no good and the Roos are fighting for a place in the 8. Freo should beat Sydney but you never know. I wouldn't be surprised if the Cats and Blues play out a very very close match - I'll be watching that with interest on Fox Footy Active on Sunday.
 

JTR

Juniors
Messages
984
St Kilda v Essendon
===================
Kangaroos v Hawthorn
Fremantle v Sydney
Brisbane v Adelaide
Western Bulldogs v Collingwood
Port Adelaide v West Coast
Geelong v Carlton
Richmond v Melbourne
 

oxenham

Juniors
Messages
628
St Kilda V Essendon- St Kilda by 35 8)
Kangaroos V Hawthorn- Kangaroos by 71
Brisbane V Adelaide- Brisbane by 39
Western Bulldogs V Collingwood- Western Bulldogs by 10
Port Adelaide V West Coast- Port Adelaide by 20
Geelong V Carlton- Geelong by 8
Richmond V Melbourne- Melbourne by 103
 
Top