Anyone know what happened to Witt?

[Ron Jeremy]

Clearly Thorman is the better player, hopefully Smith acknowledges this & uses him more.

 

[1eyedeel]

I think it was Parraren who mentioned last week that a good half is always going forward, keeping the opposition in two minds as to whether they will run or pass. I think Thorman did that last night and his game was infinitely better for it.

 

[Utey]

He is sometimes selfish kicking for himself 40m out from his own line. He needs to develop his kicking game 100%. His kicks are usually caught on the full and we suffered in field positioon where we found ourselves defending our own half quite a lot.

 

[ParraMatt]

No way is Thorman better then Witt. Because Thorman has one good game we state he is a better player then witt, Get stuffed. Witt had a good game against roosters, Can I now say that Witt is better then Thorman, And don't say "well thorman didn't play against roosters" because Witt didn't play against melbourne. Witt is a step above Thorman. Thorman does alot of silly shit.

 

[Utey]

So does Witt mate. Cant you see Witt is young his got a lto to think about if he is anywhere near to cutting it close to leading up to the finals next year. I think thorman is an average player but he created a lot but also caused us to be on the backfoot. If dykes comes back the whole team will be reshuffled.

 

[Dani]

i was wondering the same thing. he was down here. i was looking forward to seeing him play. oh well next time maybe

 

[The Colonel]

IMO they both need a lot of work, especially when kicking to put pressure on - however the longer term option seems to be Witt. Given that Saturday is the final day that Parramatta can take up Thorman's option than he had to be given a go. Would have preferred to see both and still think Witt has more options. Thorman played well on the back of some good go-forward similar to that which Witt was given against the Roosters. When he doesn't get the go-forward - ie last week he will struggle.

 

[Parraren]

I think we need both Witt & Thorman next year. If they are both battling for the number 7 it will bring the best out of each of them I think. Also, if Morris is injured we will need a back-up 5/8 and either Thorman or Witt could fill this role if need be.

Depth is very important as we all know given the amount of injuries we've had over the past 2 years.