Anything official on Goodwin and Ale yet?

[Tokyo_Raider]

This is such a chicken and egg argument - Carney has not displayed any organisational skills so is not put in a position to display them so has not displayed any organisational skills.

Carney had heaps of opportunity in reserves to show his wares and obviously just didn't produce what the coach is looking for.

 

[Raider Azz]

carney has had plenty of oppurtunity to display his organisation skills, both in first grade and reggies - he just looks much much better when he runs the ball.

 

[Bay56]

This is such a chicken and egg argument - Carney has not displayed any organisational skills so is not put in a position to display them so has not displayed any organisational skills.

Carney had heaps of opportunity in reserves to show his wares and obviously just didn't produce what the coach is looking for.

You could be correct .... but I'd go with the fact that he could have all the skills in the game and he still would not drop Smith or Withers.

I would ask who has played the better football in the past 7 weeks, Carney or Withers. If you answered Withers go to the back of the class ... if you answered Carney can you also explain why Carney started on the bench and was taken off late in the game against the Tigs.

 

[gph]

You could be correct .... but I'd go with the fact that he could have all the skills in the game and he still would not drop Smith or Withers.

Of course, that's a theory you might have