What's new
By:
Advanced search…
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Ben Smith, Nathan Hindmarsh, Luke Burt - Retire now!

H

High Flyers

Juniors
Messages
153
Nathan Hindmarsh is old, slow and offers nothing in attack. Every move he makes is easily read by the opposition defense. He said that he knew at the end of last year he didn’t want to play anymore... Well why didn’t he retire then!

Luke Burt is old, slow and weak. He has no confidence and gets monstered in EVERY tackle. Every time he is tackled it reminds me of the Tallis/Hodgson tackle in Origin.

Ben Smith offers nothing in attack and has committed more handling errors than anyone else in Parramatta history! First game of footy back in 2012, first touch of the ball... Drops it!

Its obvious that we have carried these players for too many years. I can’t remember the last time that any of the above three won Parra a game. Time to drop these guys and plan for the future; I would rather have Matt Ryan playing 80mins than Ben Smith!
 
D

DeanPay98

Juniors
Messages
1,116
Hindmarsh made 45 tackles. Strong again in defence. His attack is down, but he still saves us points.
 
boxhead

boxhead

First Grade
Messages
5,958
High Flyers said:
Nathan Hindmarsh is old, slow and offers nothing in attack. Every move he makes is easily read by the opposition defense. He said that he knew at the end of last year he didn’t want to play anymore... Well why didn’t he retire then!

Luke Burt is old, slow and weak. He has no confidence and gets monstered in EVERY tackle. Every time he is tackled it reminds me of the Tallis/Hodgson tackle in Origin.

Ben Smith offers nothing in attack and has committed more handling errors than anyone else in Parramatta history! First game of footy back in 2012, first touch of the ball... Drops it!

Its obvious that we have carried these players for too many years. I can’t remember the last time that any of the above three won Parra a game. Time to drop these guys and plan for the future; I would rather have Matt Ryan playing 80mins than Ben Smith!
Click to expand...

25_5d2be9d36ae110cde103685d32f19284.jpg
 
The Phelan Folly

The Phelan Folly

Juniors
Messages
2,376
High Flyers said:
Nathan Hindmarsh is old, slow and offers nothing in attack. Every move he makes is easily read by the opposition defense. He said that he knew at the end of last year he didn’t want to play anymore... Well why didn’t he retire then!

Luke Burt is old, slow and weak. He has no confidence and gets monstered in EVERY tackle. Every time he is tackled it reminds me of the Tallis/Hodgson tackle in Origin.

Ben Smith offers nothing in attack and has committed more handling errors than anyone else in Parramatta history! First game of footy back in 2012, first touch of the ball... Drops it!

Its obvious that we have carried these players for too many years. I can’t remember the last time that any of the above three won Parra a game. Time to drop these guys and plan for the future; I would rather have Matt Ryan playing 80mins than Ben Smith!
Click to expand...

Go and look in the mirror.
And repeat these words -

"i am a f**kwit".
 
H

High Flyers

Juniors
Messages
153
The Phelan Folly said:
Go and look in the mirror.
And repeat these words -

"i am a f**kwit".
Click to expand...

Lol.. wow internet hero!

I stand by all my comments!

Catching the last pass is a wingers job, tackling is a back rowers job! They didnt win the game or create the points. Roberts, Morgan, Hayne, Fui Fui, Ryan, all made the three I mentioned look good.

If we relied only on Hindmarsh, Smith and Burt we wold have lost by 50!

Im happy for the win, I still stand by my point... F**kwit!
 
hindy111

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
62,867
Burt did score 2 tries and kicked some good goals.But he dropped 2 bombs-He was thrown into touch and he gets thrown around like a ragdoll every tackle.
Ben smith played well IMO
Hindys should run wide-He looked good the times he did-In the middle he just gets monstered
 
Barry O'Speedwagon

Barry O'Speedwagon

Coach
Messages
19,354
High Flyers said:
Lol.. wow internet hero!

I stand by all my comments!

Catching the last pass is a wingers job, tackling is a back rowers job! They didnt win the game or create the points. Roberts, Morgan, Hayne, Fui Fui, Ryan, all made the three I mentioned look good.

If we relied only on Hindmarsh, Smith and Burt we wold have lost by 50!

Im happy for the win, I still stand by my point... F**kwit!
Click to expand...

We haven't exactly got a bunch of superstars playing for Wenty....they aren't keeping a budding superstar out of the team. If we relied on those three (or any three) only we'd lose by 300 because there'd be some pretty big gaps in the defensive line.
 
The Phelan Folly

The Phelan Folly

Juniors
Messages
2,376
High Flyers said:
Lol.. wow internet hero!

I stand by all my comments!

Catching the last pass is a wingers job, tackling is a back rowers job! They didnt win the game or create the points. Roberts, Morgan, Hayne, Fui Fui, Ryan, all made the three I mentioned look good.

If we relied only on Hindmarsh, Smith and Burt we wold have lost by 50!

Im happy for the win, I still stand by my point... F**kwit!
Click to expand...

Im sorry, but i do spend time looking at f**kwits, wondering if theve actually ever been told that they are, in fact, a f**kwit. And then i wonder, if someone took the time to say - "look, im sorry, but youre just a f**kwit" if theyd realise that they are a f**kwit, and maybe think before they were a f**kwit?

Youve been told.
 
Last edited:
hineyrulz

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
153,228
High Flyers said:
Lol.. wow internet hero!

I stand by all my comments!

Catching the last pass is a wingers job, tackling is a back rowers job! They didnt win the game or create the points. Roberts, Morgan, Hayne, Fui Fui, Ryan, all made the three I mentioned look good.

If we relied only on Hindmarsh, Smith and Burt we wold have lost by 50!

Im happy for the win, I still stand by my point... F**kwit!
Click to expand...
You must of missed Hindy's pass to Morgan??? Benny Smith defended strong and pulled of a try saver near the end. Burt i sort of agree with but he still scored a couple of tries and kicked 3 from the touch line.
 
Djay

Djay

Juniors
Messages
1,827
High Flyers said:
Nathan Hindmarsh is old, slow and offers nothing in attack. Every move he makes is easily read by the opposition defense. He said that he knew at the end of last year he didn’t want to play anymore... Well why didn’t he retire then!

Luke Burt is old, slow and weak. He has no confidence and gets monstered in EVERY tackle. Every time he is tackled it reminds me of the Tallis/Hodgson tackle in Origin.

Ben Smith offers nothing in attack and has committed more handling errors than anyone else in Parramatta history! First game of footy back in 2012, first touch of the ball... Drops it!

Its obvious that we have carried these players for too many years. I can’t remember the last time that any of the above three won Parra a game. Time to drop these guys and plan for the future; I would rather have Matt Ryan playing 80mins than Ben Smith!
Click to expand...

I agree with everything you've said.

Hindmarsh has gone one year too long and is a horrible leader, he doesn't talk, doesn't get in the refs ear like other captains do (e.g Smith, Ennis, Gallen etc) and is starting to make poor decisions like passing when he should hold it or holding it when he should pass it.

Burt played ok tonight but under the high ball his woeful and gets dominated in every single hit up he makes. Atleast he can kick I guess. ;-)

Ben Smith is average, not a bad defender but doesn't offer much in attack. he has been out for a while though so I'll give him that.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Top