Best and Worst for 05

[pennywisealfie]

Best: Brad Thorn
Worst: anyone newcastle bought

 

[Kris_man]

best: Andrew Johns :arrow: Newcastle (retaining a player is just as hard as getting one from another club nowadays)

worst: Jason Smith :arrow: Canberra (too old. if the Raiders were after a half with first grade experience, then there were plenty on the market better and much younger than this bloke, who's a back-rower more than he is a half anyway)

 

[Chippo Raiders]

Best- equal Kirk Reynoldson to Knights and Wiki to Warriors...

Worst-Tahu to Eels as a centre, Hodges to Brisbane

 

[Anonymous]

Hodges will carve up next year.........

 

[The Grouch]

Hodges will carve up next year.........

Yeah for the Clydesdales

 

[Anonymous]

Let's wait and see Grouch. A lot of people expected Clinton Toopi to play good this year.......

 

[The Grouch]

Let's wait and see Grouch. A lot of people expected Clinton Toopi to play good this year.......

You got me there, I thought he was the best centre running around in 03 :lol:

 

[Kris_man]

You got me there, I thought he was the best centre running around in 03

he was.

 

[Special K]

no he wasn't. Vagana had been the best in 02 and 03. Toopi and Lyon had nothing on Nige

 

[thuganomics]

Best - Im sorry Raiders fans I just think Monaghan will go well next year
Worst - Timana Tahu

 

[Kris_man]

no he wasn't. Vagana had been the best in 02 and 03. Toopi and Lyon had nothing on Nige

Jamie Lyon - a lazy fat bum. the next Owen Craigie. Vagana was great, no doubt, but i think Toopi was something special too.

 

[MILLWALL]

best : The Howell Bros

worst : thurston

 

[damo72]

Best - Manly - Michael Witt
Worst - Warriors - Todd Byrne

 

[Iafeta]

I tended to agree with your worst Damo, up until I watched the Reggies GF. Todd Byrne gave Clint Greenshields a couple of metres, from 35 metres out, turned, and chased him down in a classic try saving tackle. Greenshields is no slouch, he's played first grade from the back. Showed to me that maybe Sattler-Gate was one of those embarrassing moments you'd just love to forget.

Best: Steve Price
Best Bargain Buys: Fein, Marcus Perenara, Metisuela to the Storm - this bloke has the tools, Keiran Kerr - he absolutely annihilated the Warriors at Christchurch
Worst: Matt Jobson

 

[Greenblooded]

I thought Toopi was awesome in 2003. In 2004 he was horrible.

 

[SOULS 04]

Best - Im sorry Raiders fans I just think Monaghan will go well next year

not if he plays like he has been for the second half of this season

i reckon we're better off with frawley

 

[Stomp]

Frawley - Sucks that the Broncos lost him - he was a good player too! Meh - they can't keep everyone I guess.

Stomp

 

[thuganomics]

Best - Im sorry Raiders fans I just think Monaghan will go well next year

not if he plays like he has been for the second half of this season

i reckon we're better off with frawley

For Raiders fans sake I hope so Too. I just didn't think the Raiders really used him to their advantage in the 2nd half of the season.
I think Finch and Firman could really put those crossfield bombs up too him next year and he can grab alot of tries for them.

 

[Mayor_Quimby]

Best: Michael Witt
Worst: Grant Wooden/Matt Reick/Justin Hodges/Shannon Hegarty/Luke Dorn

 

[Raider_69]

Best - Im sorry Raiders fans I just think Monaghan will go well next year

not if he plays like he has been for the second half of this season

i reckon we're better off with frawley

For Raiders fans sake I hope so Too. I just didn't think the Raiders really used him to their advantage in the 2nd half of the season.
I think Finch and Firman could really put those crossfield bombs up too him next year and he can grab alot of tries for them.

not much you can do with a bloke who dosnt want to be there and a set of halves that couldnt organise a root in a brothel, Monnas was nothing short of disgraceful apon his return from a mid season injury... sometimes i questioned if he even tried :evil: