What's new
By:
Advanced search…
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Best Fullback = Ratings?

  • Thread starter Deleted member 10972
  • Start date
Ghoulies

Ghoulies

Bench
Messages
3,948
Anthony Minichello
Attacking - 8
Tackling - 9
Positional Play - 9
Catching - 10
Support Play - 9
Playmaking - 7
Total = 52

Clinton Schifcofske
Attacking - 8
Tackling - 9
Positional Play - 9
Catching - 9
Support Play - 7
Playmaking - 7
Total = 49

David Peachey
Attacking - 8
Tackling - 6
Positional Play - 8.5
Catching - 8.5
Support Play - 7
Playmaking - 8.5
Total = 46.5

Brett Hodgson
Attacking - 8.5
Tackling - 6
Positional Play - 9
Catching - 9
Support Play - 9
Playmaking - 8.5
Total = 50

Matt Bowen
Attacking - 9.5
Tackling - 6
Positional Play - 7.5
Catching - 7.5
Support Play - 7.5
Playmaking - 9
Total = 47

Billy Slater
Attacking - 10
Tackling - 6
Positional Play - 7
Catching - 7.5
Support Play - 10
Playmaking - 6.5
Total = 47
 
D

Deleted member 10972

Guest
So far mine would be:

Darren Lockyer

Attacking - 9
Tackling - 8
Positional Play - 9
Catching - 10
Support Play - 8.5
Playmaking - 10
Total = 54.5

Tim Brasher

Attacking - 10
Tackling - 8
Positional Play - 10
Catching - 10
Support Play - 9.5
Playmaking - 7
Total = 54.5

Anthony Minichiello

Attacking - 10
Tackling - 8.5
Positional Play - 8.5
Catching - 10
Support Play - 10
Playmaking - 7
Total = 54

Gary Belcher

Attacking - 8.5
Tackling - 9
Positional Play - 9
Catching - 10
Support Play - 9
Playmaking - 8.5
Total = 54

Brett Mullins

Attacking - 10
Tackling - 7.5
Positional Play - 9.5
Catching - 10
Support Play - 9.5
Playmaking - 7
Total = 53.5

Matthew Ridge

Attacking - 7.5
Tackling - 10
Positional Play - 10
Catching - 10
Support Play - 9
Playmaking - 7
Total = 53.5

Luke Phillips

Attacking - 7
Tackling - 9
Positional Play - 9.5
Catching - 10
Support Play - 9
Playmaking - 9
Total = 53.5

Ben Hornby

Attacking - 8.5
Tackling - 8
Positional Play - 8.5
Catching - 9
Support Play - 9
Playmaking - 10
Total = 53

Brett Hodgson

Attacking - 9
Tackling - 7
Positional Play - 9.5
Catching - 10
Support Play - 10
Playmaking - 8.5
Total = 53

Clinton Schifcofske

Attacking - 8.5
Tackling - 8
Positional Play - 10
Catching - 9
Support Play - 9
Playmaking - 8
Total = 52.5

Robbie Ross

 Attacking - 7.5
Tackling - 7.5
Positional Play - 9.5
Catching - 10
Support Play - 10
Playmaking - 7
Total = 51.5

Matt Bowen

Attacking - 9.5
Tackling - 7
Positional Play - 7
Catching - 8
Support Play - 8.5
Playmaking - 8.5
Total = 48.5

Billy Slater

Attacking - 10
Tackling - 7
Positional Play - 7
Catching - 8
Support Play - 9.5
Playmaking - 7
Total = 48.5

Wade McKinnon (brilliant this year)

Attacking - 9
Tackling - 7.5
Positional Play - 9
Catching - 8
Support Play - 9
Playmaking - 7
Total = 48.5

David Peachey

Attacking - 8
Tackling - 7
Positional Play - 8
Catching - 8
Support Play - 8
Playmaking - 9
Total = 48

Rhys Wesser

Attacking - 10
Tackling - 6.5
Positional Play - 7.5
Catching - 7.5
Support Play - 9.5
Playmaking - 7
Total = 48

Brett Stewart

Attacking - 10
Tackling - 7
Positional Play - 8
Catching - 7
Support Play - 9
Playmaking - 7
Total = 48

Karmichael Hunt

Attacking - 8.5
Tackling - 5.5
Positional Play - 8.5
Catching - 8
Support Play - 9
Playmaking - 8.5
Total = 48
 
D

Deleted member 10972

Guest
Btw can i get some old school fullbacks? Mullins? Belcher? Jack? Potter? Eadie?
 
Raider_69

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
Schifcofske:
Attacking - 8.5
Tackling - 9
Positional Play - 10 (sorry but there i no better positional fullback then schif atm)
Catching - 9
Support Play - 8
Playmaking - 8 (he trys but more often then not stagnates a play rather then makes it)
Total = 52.5
 
R

Red Bear

Referee
Messages
20,882
Tim Brasher

Attacking - 10
Tackling - 8
Positional Play - 10
Catching - 10
Support Play - 9.5
Playmaking - 7
Total = 44.5

And he was better than Lockyer, even if he lacks a bit on the playmaking.

And i'll agree on the positional play League Fan :)
 
D

Deleted member 10972

Guest
8.5, 8, 10, 9, 9, 8 is what i finally went with for Schif, as i just couldn't put his tackling on the same level as Phillips (Phillips was the most underrated fullback from 2000-2002, & he was flawless in positional play & defense).
 
D

Deleted member 10972

Guest
GoTheBears? No offense...but you can't add LOL. It equals 54, but i'd have his positional play at 10.
 
R

Red Bear

Referee
Messages
20,882
LeagueFanNumeroUno said:
GoTheBears? No offense...but you can't add LOL. It equals 54, but i'd have his positional play at 10.
Click to expand...
yeah typo, i meant 54.
And im at a selective school so i got some adding ability :)
 
Ghoulies

Ghoulies

Bench
Messages
3,948
Brett Mullins
Attacking - 10
Tackling - 7
Positional Play - 9
Catching - 9
Support Play - 9
Playmaking - 6.5

Gary Belcher
Attacking - 8
Tackling - 9
Positional Play - 9
Catching - 9
Support Play - 9
Playmaking - 8.5

Tim Brasher
Attacking - 8.5
Tackling - 7
Positional Play - 10
Catching - 9
Support Play - 10
Playmaking - 6.5

Darren Lockyer
Attacking - 9.5
Tackling - 7
Positional Play - 9.5
Catching - 9
Support Play - 8
Playmaking - 10
 
D

Deleted member 10972

Guest
GoTheBears i go to a selective school to! and so does TheEelsFanatic, we're friends!
 
Azkatro

Azkatro

First Grade
Messages
6,905
I think you're all getting a bit excited here... it'- okay to give a player an attribute less than 9 you know! For example, if Darren Lockyer's playmaking rating is say 9 (which in terms of all time players I think is pretty generous), how can someone like Minichiello's be higher than 2 or 3? Different fullbacks have different styles and strengths. Players like Mullins or Slater would have very high attacking or support attributes, but don't rate a mention on the playmaking scales. If say Jack or Belcher rate highly on the defensive attribute, obviously say Bowen or Slater have to be rated far, far less.
 
D

Deleted member 10972

Guest
GTB i go to Baulkham Hills, and Azkatro, we're doing it in a way so that we can rate the best fullbacks, and so far, if you look at the totals, the scale seems to be working fine. Actually, i'll give it a few tweaks just to please you,

I'm still waiting on Mick Potter, Graham Eadie, Greg Brentnall, Robbie O'Davis, Robie Ross, Ian Schubert, Russ Fairfax, Rod Silva, Paul Taylor, Ivan Cleary, Julian O'Neill, Steve McCoy, Paul Hauff, & Kris Radlinski.
 
R

Raiders Plight

Juniors
Messages
962
I think some people forget how awesome Lockyer was circa 1998-2002 at fullback. At 5/8 he hasn't been quite the success everyone predicted but at fullback he could tear up any team of any era.
 
Panthers_God

Panthers_God

Juniors
Messages
1,753
Rhys Wesser
Attacking 9.5
Tackling 8.5
Positional Play 7
Catching 7
Support Play 8.5
Play-making 8
Total=48.5

Billy Slater
Attacking 9.5
Tackling 7
Positional Play 8
Catching 8
Support Play 8.5
Play-making 7.5
Total=48.5

Matt Bowen
Attacking 9
Tackling 7
Positional Play 8
Catching 8
Support Play 8.5
Play-making 8.5
Total=49

Karmichael Hunt
Attacking 7
Tackling 8
Positional Play 8
Catching 8
Support Play 8
Play-making 8.5
Total=47.5

Clinton Schifcofske
Attacking 7.5
Tackling 9
Positional Play 8
Catching 8
Support Play 7
Play-making 8.5
Total=48

Brent Webb
Attacking 6.5
Tackling 7
Positional Play 8
Catching 8
Support Play 8
Play-making 7
Total=44.5

No wonder Queensland Origin selectors have such massive headaches when deciding on the team.
 
C

Cockadoodledoo

First Grade
Messages
5,045
Karmichael Hunt is a brilliant player and at 18 will only improve but his defence should be no more than 5.. It is horrible..
 
Azkatro

Azkatro

First Grade
Messages
6,905
Went through, this is what I came up with.

Darren Lockyer

Attacking - 8
Tackling - 6
Positional Play - 8
Catching - 7
Support Play - 5
Playmaking - 8
Total = 42

Gary Belcher

Attacking - 8
Tackling - 8
Positional Play - 7
Catching - 9
Support Play - 6
Playmaking - 3
Total = 41

Anthony Minichiello

Attacking - 7
Tackling - 7
Positional Play - 9
Catching - 6
Support Play - 8
Playmaking - 3
Total = 40

Tim Brasher

Attacking - 8
Tackling - 7
Positional Play - 8
Catching - 7
Support Play - 6
Playmaking - 3
Total = 39

David Peachey

Attacking - 7
Tackling - 7
Positional Play - 7
Catching - 9
Support Play - 4
Playmaking - 5
Total = 39

Brett Mullins

Attacking - 10
Tackling - 5
Positional Play - 6
Catching - 8
Support Play - 6
Playmaking - 3
Total = 38

Ben Hornby

Attacking - 5
Tackling - 8
Positional Play - 6
Catching - 7
Support Play - 6
Playmaking - 6
Total = 38

Brett Hodgson

Attacking - 7
Tackling - 5
Positional Play - 7
Catching - 8
Support Play - 7
Playmaking - 4
Total = 38

Clinton Schifcofske

Attacking - 8
Tackling - 7
Positional Play - 7
Catching - 7
Support Play - 6
Playmaking - 3
Total = 38

Matt Bowen

Attacking - 9
Tackling - 4
Positional Play - 5
Catching - 6
Support Play - 7
Playmaking - 7
Total = 38

Matthew Ridge

Attacking - 5
Tackling - 8
Positional Play - 7
Catching - 8
Support Play - 6
Playmaking - 3
Total = 37

Luke Phillips

Attacking - 6
Tackling - 8
Positional Play - 7
Catching - 7
Support Play - 5
Playmaking - 4
Total = 37

Billy Slater

Attacking - 9
Tackling - 4
Positional Play - 6
Catching - 7
Support Play - 8
Playmaking - 3
Total = 37

Rhys Wesser

Attacking - 8
Tackling - 6
Positional Play - 6
Catching - 7
Support Play - 7
Playmaking - 3
Total = 37

Wade McKinnon

Attacking - 5
Tackling - 7
Positional Play - 6
Catching - 7
Support Play - 8
Playmaking - 2
Total = 35

Karmichael Hunt

Attacking - 7
Tackling - 4
Positional Play - 6
Catching - 7
Support Play - 5
Playmaking - 5
Total = 34

Brett Stewart

Attacking - 7
Tackling - 4
Positional Play - 5
Catching - 6
Support Play - 7
Playmaking - 3
Total = 32
 
D

Deleted member 10972

Guest
Mini's attack would be 8 or 9...not 7...and Phillips was a sharp playmaker, he had a brilliant passing game, & his kicking game was very handy as well.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Top