Best player to never win a premiership?

[KiamaSaint]

I agree, it definitely counts.

 

[user_nat]

Thurston. Yes i'm aware he won one from the bench in 04, doesnt really count.

So only the 13 starters count?

 

[851]

Arthur Summons

True,throw in Noel Kelly,Peter Diamond,Kel O'Shea and Tommy Raudonikis,but Steve Rogers would be right up there.

 

[Parra Pride]

Wally
Smith
Slater
inglis

4 immortals/in waiting that haven't won a premiership in the NSWR/NRL comp. well two of them will resolve this tomorrow.

Slater an Immortal? :lol::lol::lol:

 

[Special K]

Matthew Wright

 

[jonno_knights]

Daniel Tolar

 

[some11]

Thurston. Yes i'm aware he won one from the bench in 04, doesnt really count.

This is such a stupid thing to say, would you discount someone as esteemed as Menzies in 08?

 

[typicalfan]

Paul Gallen best player to have never played in a grand final?

 

[DC_fan]

Mario Fenech

 

[Danny-Boy]

Well he is not that great of a player but Krisnan Inu. Lost 3 grand finals in 4 years with 3 different clubs. Quite an achievement.

Courtesy of Grays Sports Almanac.

 

[mongoose]

So only the 13 starters count?

It counts but are people going to call him a premiership winning half based on that?

Technically he has a premiership.

 

[El Diablo]

Well he is not that great of a player but Krisnan Inu. Lost 3 grand finals in 4 years with 3 different clubs. Quite an achievement.

Courtesy of Grays Sports Almanac.

he's lost two with two

 

[Rhino_NQ]

ill chuck stacey jones into the hat as well

 

[Eels Dude]

Wayne Pearce, Steve Roach, Paul Sironen, Hindy, Cayless, ET, Mundine (just ask him).
Gavin Miller the list goes on.

If you asked Mundine he'd say he didn't count because he'd say he did win a premiership.

In my time, Smith, Slater, Hindy, Inglis, ET

 

[_Johnsy]

Easy Slater

 

[webbland]

There is more than one player...

Ainscough
McGregor
Timmins
Blacklock
Mundine
Barrett
Smith
Brown
Leikvoll
Thompson
Treacy
Bartrim
Wishart
Mackay
Ward
Coyne

mate, read the thread title again...it says BEST player,not court jesters

 

[cv8z]

he's lost two with two

It'll be 3 tomorrow

 

[Fire]

Mario Fenech

pmsl.

p.s. Thanks Webb. Spurs. Thanks. Spurs. Yep. Spurs.

 

[webbland]

pmsl.

p.s. Thanks Webb. Spurs. Thanks. Spurs. Yep. Spurs.

wecome

 

[Fire]

wecome

Spurs