Best Wingers In Tigers History

[dribble73]

Who do you consider to be the best wingers in Wests Tigers history? Can't go past Richards myself, but there are some strange selections in the list.

 

[Tigers Tale]

Yeah, they got it right with Richards and TNT...

 

[Matchball]

K Mcguiness.

 

[Shanghai Charlie]

Fullback: Hodgson
Wingers: TT and Richards

Centres will be interesting. Not much quality. Whatuira and McGuiness?

5/8 Benji
1/2 Prince

 

[gronkathon]

That centre selection seems about what I would pick

 

[TYGA]

Moody& fitzhenry for me fullback McDonnell.

 

[dribble73]

Hodgo would have to be fullback!

 

[madunit]

my best tigers team:

Hodgo fullback, Tuiaki & Richards on the wing, McGuinness & Either Lawrence or Whatiura at centre. Benji & Prince in the halves, Skando & Woods at prop, Farah at hooker, Galea, Fulton & Ellis as back rowers.

Gibbs, O'Neill, Senter & Galloway on the bench.

 

[Shanghai Charlie]

Fullback: Hodgson
Wingers: TT and Richards

Centres will be interesting. Not much quality. Whatuira and McGuiness?

5/8 Benji
1/2 Prince

Plus

Galea
Fulton
Ellis
Skando
Farah
Gibbs

Res:
Lafranchii
Woods
Galloway
O'Neill

 

[macnaz]

What about Terry Hill as a centre ?

 

[madunit]

what about him?

lol

 

[Matchball]

What about Terry Hill as a centre ?

We got him at the end of his glory days.
Mild flashes of brilliance and great competitor but hardly our best.

 

[magpie guy]

We got him at the end of his glory days.
Mild flashes of brilliance and great competitor but hardly our best.

Mild flashes mixed with continuous attempts to milk a penalty.

 

[Tigers Tale]

Plus

Galea
Fulton
Ellis
Skando
Farah
Gibbs

Res:
Lafranchii
Woods
Galloway
O'Neill

I'm not disagreeing Charlie but more making an observation. Your selection shows how the game and more so the WT have changed. Many of these forwards made up our 2005 pack (excluding Payten). They were good enough to win a comp but I think our current pack would absolutely monster them.

Different times I guess but I know one thing Ellis would fit in any pack at any time....he was a standout.

 

[macnaz]

Mild flashes mixed with continuous attempts to milk a penalty.

Why is milking a penalty considered when judging a players ability ?? We have Farah who is the master milkman.

 

[macnaz]

what about him?

lol

Guess your showing your younger age MU .. he carried our side for a couple of years , dont let that Tery Lamb era jrule your judgement ... Terry gave shitloads to this club , he did f**king everything he could for WT.

 

[gronkathon]

When he could actually get onto the field

 

[Shanghai Charlie]

I'm not disagreeing Charlie but more making an observation. Your selection shows how the game and more so the WT have changed. Many of these forwards made up our 2005 pack (excluding Payten). They were good enough to win a comp but I think our current pack would absolutely monster them.

Different times I guess but I know one thing Ellis would fit in any pack at any time....he was a standout.

Totally agree. Young guys just dont have he runs on the board yet to make our greatest side.

 

[macnaz]

f**k thats got nothing to do with it ! Terry Hill returned to the magpies/tigers and gave his all. Every big win in our early years as minnows were on the back of his performance or inspiration , anyone that disagrees wasnt watching or alive to see . So please look up the the history books .

 

[macnaz]

what about him?

lol

Always rated your opinion MU , but to laugh at my opinion of Terry Hill shows your knowledge of our club and the game in general is no where near where I thought it was . Guess u will say Hopiate added nothing as well ?