Best, Worst, Favourite and Most Under-Rated From Each Team

[thehattrickrabbit]

And your New Zealand team is crap too.

yeah i forgot benji
--

Toopi i dont think is too happy at the warriors, i dont think he is motivated at the club, he will be One Of the NZ Team's Star Player every test

He will carve up in England, but i think he will be back in the nrl, after a couple of years over there

But when Toopi is motivated, he would smoke mannering and martin put together...

Toopi is in the class off hodges,cooper, tahu and gasnier, when he isnt being lazy

Toopi at his best is better than gasnier at his best, the only reason gasnier is better, as because gaz is more consistent in showing some of his best footy

 

[CGD]

You understand that Toopi is no longer at the New Zealand Warriors, right?

 

[douglasallen91]

yeah i forgot benji
--

Toopi i dont think is too happy at the warriors, i dont think he is motivated at the club, he will be One Of the NZ Team's Star Player every test

He will carve up in England, but i think he will be back in the nrl, after a couple of years over there

But when Toopi is motivated, he would smoke mannering and martin put together...

Toopi is in the class off hodges,cooper, tahu and gasnier, when he isnt being lazy

Toopi at his best is better than gasnier at his best, the only reason gasnier is better, as because gaz is more consistent in showing some of his best footy

toopi can't defend to save himself.

and p.s. toopi is at leeds,

18 man squad vs hull two weekends ago
Leeds Rhinos: Smith, Donald, Toopi, Senior, Gibson, Sinfield, Burrow, Jones-Buchanan, Diskin, Bailey, Walker, Peacock, Ellis.
Replacements: Millard, Kirke, Thackray, Lauitiiti.

 

[Lowdown]

Thoughts and Opinions ???
Storm
Best: Cameron Smith
Worst: Jeremy Smith
Favourite: Cooper Cronk
Under-Rated: Ryan Hoffman
--------------------------

Jeremy Smith was playing reserve grade last year. Nows he's a regular first grader in arguably the toughest team in the comp to get game time. He is one, if not the most under-rated player in the roster. He is fast, skillful and his tackling (which resembles a judo player on acid) is ferocious.

Worst? Definately not. Who is? Can't pick anyone from the storm who is the weak link. Fair to say that Jamie Feeney struggled to get time on the paddock, but when he does play, he's always reliable.

Since this thread does not mention players:

Best: Craig Bellamy

 

[Ice777]

I have to agree with you there Lowdown, he's such a tough bastard who only knows how to play it one way and that's hard. For me when i see him run off the bench i know he's not going to give anyone an inch and he's more than capable of matching it with the best of them.

Having said that it's all opinion. But i think it's a great compliment to the Storm that many can't find a worst player for them in their selections. Walker has been mentioned a few times but he's not with us anymore anyway.

 

[veryhappyshark]

sharks:

best: covell
worst: beau scott
fav: simmo/thompson/gallen/hilder/kimmorley/dykes/douglas/williams/bird/kearney/pommeroy
under rated: gallen and pommeroy
over rated: kimmorley and vagana

 

[CC_Eagle]

Manly

Best: Kennedy
Worst : King
Favourite : Everyone - King,Dunley
Underrated : Williamson,Burns
Overrated : King

 

[Breadman]

Best - Gallen
Worst - Scott individually, Kimmorley in terms of effect on the team
Favourite - Gallen
Underated - Pommeroy / Covell

 

[Dutchy]

Broncos:
Best: Darren Lockyer
Worst: Scott Minto
Favourite: Corey Parker
Under-rated: Corey Parker


Bulldogs:
Best: Willie Mason
Worst: Ben Czislowski
Favourite: Mark Omeley
Under-rated: Luke Patten


Raiders:
Best: Clinton Shifcofske
Worst: Dont Know
Favourite: Alan Tongue
Under-rated: Dont Know


Sharks:
Best: Paul Gallen
Worst: Darren Albert
Favourite: Paul Gallen
OVER-rated: Kimmorley

Knights:
Best: Andrew Johns
Worst: The Fullback
Favourite: Kidley
Under-rated: Kidley


Cowboys:
Best: Johnathon Thurston
Worst: Josh Hannay
Favourite: Aaron Payne
Under-rated: Aaron Payne


Eels:
Best: Nathan Hindmarsh
Worst: Matt Peterson
Favourite: Hindmarsh
Under-rated: Luke Burt


Sea Eagles:
Best: Ben Kennedy
Worst: Mark Bryant
Favourite: Anthony Watmough/Steve Menzies
Under-rated: Travis Burns


Storm:
Best: Cameron Smith
Worst: Jeremy Smith
Favourite: Cameron Smith
Under-rated: Steve Turner


Panthers:
Best: Luke Priddis
Worst: Lee Hookey
Favourite: Luke Priddis
Under-rated: Michael Gordon


Rabbitohs:
Best: David Peachey
Worst: Ben Walker
Favourite: Joe Gulavou
Under-rated: Peter Cusack


Dragons:
Best: Mark Gasnier
Worst: Jason Ryles
Favourite: Mark Gasnier
Under-rated: Ben Hornby


Roosters:
Best: Anthony Minichello
Worst: Braith Analstar
Favourite: Brett Finch
Under-rated: Shaun Foley


Warriors:
Best: Steve Price
Worst: Jerome Ropati
Favourite: Ruben Wiki
Under-rated: Brent Webb


Tigers:
Best: Scott Prince
Worst: Daniel Fitzhenry
Favourite: Benji Marshall
Under-rated: Shannon McDonnell

 

[Pure_Knight]

how the hell can he be favourite hes only played 5 games. Also Brett Seymour is a worst player.

Um becus hes played numerous games for thre knights and the dragons, and became one of my favourite players. He is now at the broncos, and is my favourite player in the broncos squad. Simple as that champ.
And ah no i believe seymour has far more potential and is a better player currently then minto who is poo to be honest.

 

[Pure_Knight]

Jeremy Smith was playing reserve grade last year. Nows he's a regular first grader in arguably the toughest team in the comp to get game time. He is one, if not the most under-rated player in the roster. He is fast, skillful and his tackling (which resembles a judo player on acid) is ferocious.

Worst? Definately not. Who is? Can't pick anyone from the storm who is the weak link. Fair to say that Jamie Feeney struggled to get time on the paddock, but when he does play, he's always reliable.

Since this thread does not mention players:

Best: Craig Bellamy

Yea mate i dont think he is all that bad. But when i look at the storm 17, he doesnt stand out as much as the others, bcus frankly its a great squad. In any other side he certainly wudnt be my worst. However at the strom i think he is.

 

[Dr Crane]

Warriors
Best: Steve Price
Worst: Jerome Ropati (although he is going well at the moment)
Favourite: Steve Price/Ruben Wiki/Grant Rovelli/Tony Martin
Underrated: Micheal Luck and Paddy Ah Van

 

[Hutty1986]

Saints:

Best: Ben Hornby/Mark Gasnier
Worst: Colin Best
Favourite: Matty Head/Matt Cooper
Underrated: Den Young

 

[Nutzcraw]

Manly:
Best: Ben Kennedy
Worst: Jason King
Favourite: Steve Menzies
Under-Rated: Brett Stewart

 

[Rod]

Broncos
Best: Darren Lockyer
Worst: Scott Minto
Favourite: Shane Webcke
Under-rated: Sam Thaiday

Bulldogs
Best: Sonny Bill Williams
Worst: Corey Hughes
Favourite: Sonny Bill Williams
Under-rates: Luke Patten

Canberra
Best: Clinton Schifoske
Worst: Adrian Purtell
Favourite: Jason Croker
Under-rated: Lincoln Withers

Cowboys
Best: Johnathan Thurston
Worst: Steve Southern
Favourite: Matt Bowen
Under-rates: Aaron Payne

Manly
Best: Ben Kennedy
Worst: George Rose
Favourite: Steve Menzies
Under-rated: Steve Matai

Newcastle
Best: Andrew Johns
Worst: Reegan Tanner
Favourite: Milton Thaiday
Under-rated: Adam Woolnough

Melbourne
Best: Cameron Smith
Worst: Brett White
Favourite: Jake Webster
Under-rated: Nathan Friend

Parramatta
Best: Nathan Hindmarsh
Worst: Luke O'Dwyer
Favourite: Timana Tahu
Under-rated: Wade McKinnon

Panthers
Best: Luke Priddis
Worst: Lee Hookey
Favourite: Frank Pritchard
Under-rated: Frank Pritchard

Sharks
Best: Paul Gallen
Worst: Beau Scott
Favourite: Nigel Vagana
Under-rated: Kevin Kingston

Rabbitohs
Best: David Fa'alogo
Worst: Ben Walker
Favourite: David Fa'alogo
Under-rated: Mark Minichiello

Dragons
Best: Mark Gasnier
Worst: Reece Simmonds
Favourite: Matt Cooper
Under-rated: Clint Greenshields

Roosters
Best: Anthony Minichiello
Worst: Charlie Tonga
Favourite: Iosia Soliola
Under-rated: Seitemata Sa

Warriors
Best: Ruben Wiki
Worst: Manu Vatuvei
Favourite: Ruben Wiki
Under-rated: Simon Mannering

Tigers
Best: Benji Marshall
Worst: Daniel Fitzhenry
Favourite: Benji Marshall
Under-rated: Dene Halatau

 

[Jono078]

Canberra
Best: Jason Smith
Worst: Adrian Purtell
Favourite: Thom Learoyd-Lahrs
Under-Rated: Josh Miller

Broncos
Best: Darren Lockyer
Worst: Scott Minto
Favourite: Justin Hodges
Under-Rated: Sam Thaiday

Knights
Best: Andrew Johns
Worst: Michael Hagan
Favourite: Andrew Johns
Under-Rated: Dan Tolar

Tigers
Best: Benji Marshall
Worst: Ben Reynolds
Favourite: Benji Marshall
Under-Rated: Paul Whatuira

Storm
Best: Cameron Smith
Worst: Chris Walker
Favourite: Greg Inglis
Under-Rated: Ryan Hoffman

Bulldogs:
Best: Sonny Bill Williams
Worst: Ben Czislowski
Favourite: Sonny Bill Williams
Under-Rated: Tony Grimaldi

Rabbitohs:
Best: David Peachey
Worst: Joe Galuvao
Favourite: Joe Williams
Under-Rated: Shane Rigon or Scott Geddes

Cowboys:
Best: Johnathon Thurston
Worst: Neil Sweeney
Favourite: Brenton Bowen
Under-Rated: Brenton Bowen

Roosters:
Best: Anthony Minichiello
Worst: Sam Perrett
Favourite: Anthony Minichiello
Under-Rated: David Shillington

Dragons:
Best: Mark Gasnier
Worst: Chris Sheppard
Favourite: Matt Cooper
Under-Rated: Corey Payne

Warriors:
Best: Steve Price
Worst: Todd Byrne
Favourite: Rubin Wiki or Manu Vatuvei
Under-Rated: Simon Mannering

Panthers:
Best: Luke Priddis
Worst: Lee Hookey
Favourite: Luke Priddis
Under-Rated: Michael Gordon

Manly:
Best: Ben Kennedy
Worst: Michael Witt
Favourite: BK
Under-Rated: Chris Hicks

Parra:
Best: Nathan Hindmarsh
Worst: Matt Petersen
Favourite: Eric Grothe
Under-Rated: Wade McKinnon

Sharks:
Best: Lance Thompson
Worst: Beau Scott
Favourite: Darren Albert
Under-Rated: Kevin Kingston

 

[Sea Eagle Scuba]

Michael Witt :lol: nuff said. He'd take the cake for worst player in the NRL by a mile!!

 

[MSIH]

Manly

Worst: George Rose

Seriously, why do people with nfi post? You obviously haven't seen much of Manly over the last 12 weeks, as Rose has been great.

Please stop commenting on things you've got absolutely no knowledge of.

 

[Sea Eagle Scuba]

Seriously, why do people with nfi post? You obviously haven't seen much of Manly over the last 12 weeks, as Rose has been great.

Please stop commenting on things you've got absolutely no knowledge of.

Agreed with everything MSIH said. Over the last 2-3 months Rose has been Manly's most consistent prop.

 

[Rod]

Seriously, why do people with nfi post? You obviously haven't seen much of Manly over the last 12 weeks, as Rose has been great.

Please stop commenting on things you've got absolutely no knowledge of.

I'm sorry if that offends you, but when making my worst player selections I did them by taking out the player I'd least like to have in my 17, and I picked from the usual 17-19 players that regularly take the field for first grade. I didn't consider fringe/PL players such as Michael Witt as he spends most of his time in premier league. And looking at your bench, if I had to kick out one, it'd be Rose. If you really must know I tossed up between him and Kyle Leuleuai but in the end someone had to get the chop.