What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Big crowd Wallabies v Samoa..why cant RL do that?

miketyson

Juniors
Messages
412
38,000 at the game.. Proabably around 100,000 watched it on TV.

FFS.. Friday night football will double the Onion audience..

Let alone Origin which will proably have more people watching it on TV then all the wallabies games combined this year.
 

JW

Coach
Messages
12,657
Graf Vynda-k said:
fairdinkum, you and razor need to stop pretending to be ostriches and get a dose of reality!!!

you can invent all the convoluted logic and mumbo jumbo you like to try and spin a fantasy cocoon around yourselves, but the reality is that the tahs get over 30,000 to each game, the brums get over 20,000 a match and wallaby test attract over 50,000 a pop.......year in year out.

in other words union is very popular......it's a great spectator sport.

You go on about comparing "apples with apples". There are 100+ NRL matches in Sydney each year. There are 6, yes 6, Super 12 matches.

Apples with apples my arse.

Cheers.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
101,139
Graf Vynda-k said:
fairdinkum, you and razor need to stop pretending to be ostriches and get a dose of reality!!!

you can invent all the convoluted logic and mumbo jumbo you like to try and spin a fantasy cocoon around yourselves, but the reality is that the tahs get over 30,000 to each game, the brums get over 20,000 a match and wallaby test attract over 50,000 a pop.......year in year out.

in other words union is very popular......it's a great spectator sport.

20 or 30k to 5 or home matches a year.

All NRL clubs average about 15k nowadays over a much longer period of time.

Not to mention S12 is a provincial showcase event - if it attracts 20 or 30k per game, and something like Origin (also a provincial showcase event) has a guarantee of 80k THREE MONTHS before the event (not to mention the 60k at Suncorp both times too) then that clearly says something about your "popular spectator sport". In terms of sustained crowds the NRL wins hands down.

Or do you want me to bring up Tooheys New Cup crowd figures, being the domestic comp for Rugby and pit it against the NRL, League's domestic comp.

Save your breath fool.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
101,139
Union isn't a great game. It's a disorganised and unformatted game which snobby and arrogant people watch. It claims to be a global sport but only has footholds in the UK, Australia/NZ and South Africa.

League never claims to be a world sport, it's merely developing it's international game at the moment.

Ever wondered why it's called Yawnion or Kick & Clap? :rolleyes:
 

tiburon

Juniors
Messages
731
I've never really thought about it before but I have been to around a dozen International Union games and half a dozen 'tahs games and never paid for one, all freebies.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
101,139
tiburon said:
I've never really thought about it before but I have been to around a dozen International Union games and half a dozen 'tahs games and never paid for one, all freebies.

And there's the clincher.
 

tye

Juniors
Messages
1,966
Small minds, get out and live a little.....there is a whole new world out there ......idiots
 

dubby

Bench
Messages
3,005
free tickets hey???

Lions still outdo broncos, is that why??

Most Union supporters i meet are rum drinking yobbos from club rugby who had a fight in league once....and lost.
Why cant RL give freebies away, it makes the stadium full...attracts sponsers...more money...more developement.

Whos smarter???
 

LeagueXIII

First Grade
Messages
5,969
Don't most commentators claim that union now is played more like league use to be? If league has nothing to offer why did England RU train with Leeds RLFC?
 

rugged

Juniors
Messages
2,415
Like rugby, like league.

One crowd that is never mentioned is school rugby which can get crowds of a few thousand.
 

Big Bunny

Juniors
Messages
1,801
I love rugby, but it's a pity that the union variant tends to be popular with those that can be best described as poorly informed and ill equipped to discuss their own code, let alone the more progressive one. Sure, there are intelligent folk among them, but they do often get drowned out by the elitist clods, the kind that have found their way to this thread and who concentrate on "body shapes" and "complexities" rather than the entertainiment factor and the enjoyment of playing the game.

Union is an ok game, I find it quaint because it's like looking through time and seeing rugby league in the 1950's. The only thing is that instead of a play-the-ball it has fat blokes writhing on the ground with even fatter guys standing on them and even by that stage we had gone 50 years without line-outs. In fact these days I refuse to consider union a separate football code at all and for those reasons. It's quite clearly just a slower, bastardized interpretation of rugby league in the 50's.

Union might be good for people as a social exercise, a bit of fun on sunday between mates, but by no means should it be presented as a professional game. I'd imagine that attending a Super 12 match or even a Wallaby game would be a bit like going along to a renaissance fair, where guys pretend to be knights but aren't really any more than dreamers. They might have the talent to be knights, but the middle ages have past. Just like the era of when union was a code unto itself.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
101,139
dubby said:
Why cant RL give freebies away

...more money...

Whos smarter???

Clearly not you.

Free

Money

Free

Money.


Sorry I'm not seeing the connection. If they're giving them away they aren't getting money!! I wouldn't be surprised if the ARU struggles to break even for all of their Telstra games...
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
101,139
Big Bunny said:
I love rugby, but it's a pity that the union variant tends to be popular with those that can be best described as poorly informed and ill equipped to discuss their own code, let alone the more progressive one. Sure, there are intelligent folk among them, but they do often get drowned out by the elitist clods, the kind that have found their way to this thread and who concentrate on "body shapes" and "complexities" rather than the entertainiment factor and the enjoyment of playing the game.

Union is an ok game, I find it quaint because it's like looking through time and seeing rugby league in the 1950's. The only thing is that instead of a play-the-ball it has fat blokes writhing on the ground with even fatter guys standing on them and even by that stage we had gone 50 years without line-outs. In fact these days I refuse to consider union a separate football code at all and for those reasons. It's quite clearly just a slower, bastardized interpretation of rugby league in the 50's.

Union might be good for people as a social exercise, a bit of fun on sunday between mates, but by no means should it be presented as a professional game. I'd imagine that attending a Super 12 match or even a Wallaby game would be a bit like going along to a renaissance fair, where guys pretend to be knights but aren't really any more than dreamers. They might have the talent to be knights, but the middle ages have past. Just like the era of when union was a code unto itself.

:clap: Brilliant.
 

ruggabugga

Juniors
Messages
88
What a shame the ARU put this game on at a time when the Sydney rugby community was occupied with it's regular competition. This denied the majority of rugby supporters a chance of attending the game. Many thousands more would have been there. Maybe 60-70,000.

Even the leagies know to put State of origin on at a time when it does not compete with itsef.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
101,139
ruggabugga said:
What a shame the ARU put this game on at a time when the Sydney rugby community was occupied with it's regular competition. This denied the majority of rugby supporters a chance of attending the game. Many thousands more would have been there. Maybe 60-70,000.

Even the leagies know to put State of origin on at a time when it does not compete with itsef.

Another 30k would go if the Sydney RU comp wasn't running?

:lol:

Riiight.
 

LeagueXIII

First Grade
Messages
5,969
Union the only sport where the school you went to is of some importance. By the way South Africa just scrapped home 134-3.
 
Top