What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Big News @ St Kilda

CyberKev

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
2,323
Fresh off the presses.

Armen Tanzarian's reign of tyrrany is over...

St Kilda has "boned" Grant Thomas and will enter 2007 with a new man at the helm.

My guess is that either Mark Harvey, Daryn Cresswell or John Longmire will get the gig.

Given Thomas' numerous roles at Moorabbin, I'd imagine there'd be a few gigs on offer down there.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,785
can you guys please provide a link for any breaking news

unsubstantiated allegations get deleted in the NRL forums



Saints sack Thomas


September 12, 2006

ST Kilda this afternoon sacked Grant Thomas as coach, just days after the Saints were eliminated from the 2006 AFL finals.
Saints president Rod Butterss, Thomas and some of the club's directors fronted a packed media conference where Butterss said the board had accepted the coach's resignation.

But Thomas countered, saying he hadn't quit, instead coming to a "mutual agreement" with his board that his six-season tenure was over.

"The guys firmly believe the club needs to move in a new direction, I don't have to believe in that, but I am going to have to live with it," Thomas said.

Thomas later said he did not agree with the board's decision, that he did not see his axing coming and that he was "gutted" to be leaving.

"It came from left-field, I wasn't expecting it - maybe I am a bit dumb - but I was not expecting it," he said.

"But I'm not the first to go through this situation."

Thomas, 48, replaced Malcolm Blight as interim coach when Blight was sacked in 2001.

Thomas was appointed permanent coach in 2002.

He coached the Saints in 123 games, including the past three finals series, for 63 wins, 59 losses and one draw.

Thomas, who came from a football management background and had only coached at country level before leading the Saints, conceded he would never coach an AFL club again.

St Kilda's decision came just four days after the Saints' season ended with last Friday night's elimination final loss to Melbourne at the MCG.

The Saints reached preliminary finals in 2004-05.

Butterss said St Kilda would take its time searching for a replacement, and the names at the top of the list are likely to be current assistant coaches John Longmire (Sydney) and Mark Harvey (Fremantle), and Matt Rendell, an assistant coach under Thomas.

Butterss said the club would seek the "best available" candidate, and was unfazed by any time restrictions.

"If it takes twice as long as we'd hoped, it takes twice as long," he said.

Thomas' left-field approach to coaching has had both its critics and fans, but he will depart the job having never been able to guide his talent-laden playing list into a grand final.

That said, he endured more than his share of injuries to key players over the years - including during last Friday night's loss to the Demons - and rarely had his best available team together because of injury.

But he departs as the club's second-longest-serving coach, behind only the legendary Allan Jeans.

Thomas, who played 83 VFL games (72 for St Kilda) from 1978-85, said he would "re-introduce" himself to his family and then consider what to do with the next chapter of his life.

But he said he would remain a St Kilda fan, and hoped the club could soon end its long premiership drought, which stretches back to 1966.



AAP

http://www.foxsports.com.au/story/0,8659,20398863-23211,00.html
 

meltiger

First Grade
Messages
6,268
Twizzle said:
can you guys please provide a link for any breaking news

unsubstantiated allegations get deleted in the NRL forums

What unfounded allegation?!


Thomas himself admitted he wasn't happy with the decision.
 

CyberKev

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
2,323
meltiger said:
What unfounded allegation?!


Thomas himself admitted he wasn't happy with the decision.

I think he was referring to tool-timers that post rumours as if they're hard fact.

Normally I would post the link, but I was in a rush to get out of here last night and just gave the quick rundown.

In my own defence, I wouldn't present it as fact unless it had been reported that way in a viable news forum.

Had it been at the unfounded allegation (with strong mail) stage, I would have presented it as such (i.e "the word's pretty strong on the grapevine that Thomas will get 'boned' by St Kilda").
 

CyberKev

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
2,323
meltiger said:
LOL

f**k. If it's not Frawley, St Kilda might actually win a premiership now :(

Assuming they can also:

a) tighten up their rucks;
b) get more speed and flair into their outside midfield; and
c) replace the likes of Harvey, Gehrig & Hamill when they retire at the end of next year.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,785
meltiger said:
What unfounded allegation?!


Thomas himself admitted he wasn't happy with the decision.


it has nothing to do with Thomas, moreso the forum rules

it took me about 5 seconds to find a news article on it
 

CyberKev

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
2,323
On Thomas.

He's a controversial character, seemingly unpopular with almost everyone outside of the St Kilda football club, and there are clear reasons for this lack of popularity.

That said, he deserves plenty of credit for his conduct yesterday.

I think its dodgy that sacked coaches should have to sit through a press conference with their executioner at their side, and it was clearly difficult for Thomas yesterday.

He handled himself very well under the circumstances and at all times spoke passionately about the club and warmly about the players.

By contrast, a huge cloud now hangs over Butterss (you get the feeling that his South Park namesake would have more nous and credibility) and his fellow Board Members.

The Watson debacle, then the Blight disaster, followed by the Thomas years leading to a very amateurish sacking yesterday...

Over the past decade the Saints board has now sacked two coaches in the midst of multiple finals seasons; taken on one with zero experience; and in-between hired and just as quickly fired a tired guru who never at any stage had his head or heart set for the role.

Let's hope they follow a process this time, at least.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,785
I thought he was hard done by when you compare his record to that of the likes of Pagen.
 

meltiger

First Grade
Messages
6,268
Twizzle said:
it has nothing to do with Thomas, moreso the forum rules

it took me about 5 seconds to find a news article on it

Ahh ok. Sorry mate. It (The press converence) had been all over the standard news down here by the time it was posted. That's why I assumed we hadn't broken the rules.
 

meltiger

First Grade
Messages
6,268
CyberKev said:
The Watson debacle, then the Blight disaster, followed by the Thomas years leading to a very amateurish sacking yesterday...


Was he president when Watson was pushed out? I thought his predecessor was still there?


Maybe I am thinking of the Alves sacking? (This was the stupidest thing they ever did, as silly as St George pushing out Waite)
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,785
meltiger said:
Ahh ok. Sorry mate. It (The press converence) had been all over the standard news down here by the time it was posted. That's why I assumed we hadn't broken the rules.

no probs
 

CyberKev

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
2,323
meltiger said:
Was he president when Watson was pushed out? I thought his predecessor was still there?

Yeah, he was there for the Watson demise.

meltiger said:
Maybe I am thinking of the Alves sacking? (This was the stupidest thing they ever did, as silly as St George pushing out Waite)

Agreed on the Alves nonsense.

Agree in principle with the Waite view too, but in fairness, I believe he had stated a desire to move on.
 

meltiger

First Grade
Messages
6,268
CyberKev said:
Agree in principle with the Waite view too, but in fairness, I believe he had stated a desire to move on.

After the way he was treated for supporting Mundine ... I'd want to move too.
 

meltiger

First Grade
Messages
6,268
Have you seen the thread on BigFooty with Skunk fans posting their 'Wants' with regards to a Tarrant trade?


LMFAO Still vastly over rating their players
 

Latest posts

Top