Brett Finch > John Morris

[Avenger]

Seriously how bad has Morris played in the last 2 games ? He is definitely not a big game player.

Finch, however has proven that he can do it in the games that matter. I think it was a masterstroke to sign him and punt Morris.

 

[PIG]

It aint even close. John Morris sucks!!! Typical Brian Smith choker....I mean player

 

[Avenger]

It aint even close. John Morris sucks!!! Typical Brian Smith choker....I mean player

Agree 100%. Finch may well be the best buy that we have made since Tahu.

 

[scottyeel]

Maybe, time will tell but it's not as if Finchy has never folded in the big games either.

 

[Ron Jeremy]

Morris is makeshift, a typical utility, who has been starting for to long.

Morris=John Plath

 

[Ron Jeremy]

Finch has grown on me, more so the comments of players who've played with him, thats a big compliment knowing that players around him wrap him heaps.

 

[lucablight]

I'll reserve my judgement for Finch but Morris was awful tonight.

 

[Avenger]

Finch has won a grandfinal, played with Fittler and has received 2 State of Origin "Man Of the match" awards (from memory).

Its a no brainer.

 

[scottyeel]

Don't think he has won a GF but he has lost 2.

 

[lucablight]

Finch has won a grandfinal, played with Fittler and has received 2 State of Origin "Man Of the match" awards (from memory).

Its a no brainer.

Finch has never won a grand final or won any man of the match awards in origin.

 

[Avenger]

Don't think he has won a GF but he has lost 2.

Wasn't he the halfback in 2002? or was that Wing?

 

[Avenger]

Finch has never won a grand final or won any man of the match awards in origin.

Wasn't he MOM when he kicked that field goal in origin this year? I also think he was MOM in his debut origin game.

 

[scottyeel]

Wing was the no.7 in '02, Finch didn't go there until '03, but yeah he did get MOM in SOO 1 this year.

 

[Avenger]

Wing was the no.7 in '02, Finch didn't go there until '03, but yeah he did get MOM in SOO 1 this year.

Actually he wasn't. Mason was.

 

[scottyeel]

Ok then, so he's no better in the big games than Morris.

 

[Avenger]

Ok then, so he's no better in the big games than Morris.

hahahahah.

Morris could never kick that miracle field goal. Morris will also never play origin.

 

[strider]

Ok then, so he's no better in the big games than Morris.

:lol: ... please rename this the "finich sucks thread"

i really don't know hw he'll go - he's a bit temperamental ..... he's one of those guys who could be great or really suck - lets hope its the first

 

[scottyeel]

Finch did well to kick that field goal, it was brilliant but the fact remains if all the other candidates didn't turn it down or get injured then Finch would never have got near an origin jersey either.

 

[fish eel]

Finch did well to kick that field goal, it was brilliant but the fact remains if all the other candidates didn't turn it down or get injured then Finch would never have got near an origin jersey either.

so?

He had a chance, stepped up and did well.

 

[scottyeel]

:lol: ... please rename this the "finich sucks thread"

i really don't know hw he'll go - he's a bit temperamental ..... he's one of those guys who could be great or really suck - lets hope its the first

I hope he goes great too and if you go back to the thread when he signed then I was 1 of the minority who welcomed here. I'm not trying to bag him but I just can't see how he is a better "big" game player than Morris.