What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Brett Kimmorely

Eddie.

Bench
Messages
4,188
Apparently he is NSW best halfback option, but I struggle to see that he is up to First Grade standard any more. He seems a nice enough bloke and there has been alot of talk about how he is enjoying his footy this season and playing really well.

However every time I watch the Sharks play the guy is awful. There is no ned product. He is busy and so on but thats about it. Sure, he has a decent long kicking game. That is nullified by his predictable before the line passing, poor short kicking game and general lack of ability to lay on a try. Today he had a 4 man overlap and indtead decided to put a kick straight to Merritt. I watched him at CTown earlier this season and I thought he was the worst player on the field. In numerous games since the Sharks has looked completely lost inside the opposition 20 and this has to come down to both Super coach Ricky Staurt and the lack of creativity and ability of his halback.

The Sharks always look better with Dykes at halfback and generally win when Kimmorley is out of the side. However Dykes is shocking when playing at 6 with Kimmorley at 7. Watching these 2 play together is like a trian wreck.

Its a real worry that this guy is considered the best halfback in NSW, when he can't even help his club side across the line against mediocre oposition from week to week.
 

Fiddy

Juniors
Messages
669
Well i can't be really bothered reading your post - it's probably a long post about several different things with perhaps a cheapshot at souths. So please, let me be one of the first to say:


HAHA You lost, We won.




Or if your not a fan of the sharks then the alternative response is:


Cry more please.
 

Mr Saab

Referee
Messages
27,762
Warren Ryan said it best about Noddy.
All icing and no cake.
Watching him play today vs the Bunnies was painful.
 

Y2Eel

First Grade
Messages
8,176
50centforlife said:
Well i can't be really bothered reading your post - it's probably a long post about several different things with perhaps a cheapshot at souths. So please, let me be one of the first to say:


HAHA You lost, We won.




Or if your not a fan of the sharks then the alternative response is:


Cry more please.

That explains alot...:sarcasm:
 

ockham

Juniors
Messages
89
50centforlife said:
Well i can't be really bothered reading your post - it's probably a long post about several different things with perhaps a cheapshot at souths. So please, let me be one of the first to say:
HAHA You lost, We won.
Or if your not a fan of the sharks then the alternative response is:
Cry more please.

In your feeble and lame attempt to poke fun at the Brett Kimmorley Post you made yourself look like a moron.

The comments about the "invisible" mr kimmorley are well placed. If he is the best halfback in NSW, then NSW is in big trouble.
 

ockham

Juniors
Messages
89
Mr Saab said:
Warren Ryan said it best about Noddy.
All icing and no cake.
Watching him play today vs the Bunnies was painful.

That is so funny. WOK is an absolute legend. Never a truer statement. Kimmorley is fluff.
 

Stranger

Coach
Messages
18,682
He is the Alan Tongue of halfbacks at the moment.

Shows up, plays his heart out and is still just an average player.
 

mongoose

Coach
Messages
11,805
Stranger said:
He is the Alan Tongue of halfbacks at the moment.

Shows up, plays his heart out and is still just an average player.

stupid comment.

Both players have completely different roles in their teams. One of them well exceeds his job in the team while the other struggles to do his job.
 
Messages
922
50centforlife said:
HAHA You lost, We won.
Or if your not a fan of the sharks then the alternative response is:
Cry more please.

If only it took 50 cents to make you go away for life :(

Kimmorley is still the 2nd best halfback in the competition. With Thurston admittedly the best as he's the Australian and QLD half.
 

Mr Saab

Referee
Messages
27,762
Covellius Maximus said:
Kimmorley is still the 2nd best halfback in the competition. With Thurston admittedly the best as he's the Australian and QLD half.

Thurston
Prince
Cronk
Orford
Sherwin
Kimmoley
 

Mr Saab

Referee
Messages
27,762
Hey, i am not a huge fan of Orford or Sherwin, but they are better than Noddy.
He is a below avg halfback who couldnt organise a Ron Coote in a Brothel.
 

sherrinator

Juniors
Messages
271
Covellius Maximus said:
:lol:

Prince and Cronk are debatable but Orford the choker and Sherwin :?

Prince and Cronk debatable? Don't let your club loyalties cloud your vision. I think that Kimmorely is better than Orford only that he actually shows a bit of balls, and Sherwin, yes once upon a time, now - no.
 

Stonecutter

First Grade
Messages
5,447
Why the hell did we resign him for 2 years. He is an old dog that can't learn any new tricks to save hs career. But we just keep throwing him more bones to chew on. ](*,)
 

Latest posts

Top