What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Brothers in arms: how Bulldogs helped hunted Bunnies bounce back from the brink of extinction

___

Juniors
Messages
861
This article is a good few years old, however I think it's worth posting here as many people would not be aware of the significant information it holds.

https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/br...m-the-brink-of-extinction-20120921-26c5z.html

When Souths took on News Ltd and the NRL, one club stood up for them, writes Brad Walter.

IF South Sydney had not won their battle to be reinstated to the NRL a decade ago, they may have been based on the Gold Coast under a little-known plan devised by Canterbury to keep the Rabbitohs alive.

Despite being on opposite sides of the Super League war, the Bulldogs played a significant role in Souths' fight for re-admission and refused to co-operate with News Ltd and the NRL in the court case against the Rabbitohs.
Canterbury also assisted financially, by attending a number of fund-raising events to pay for Souths' court costs, and were the first NRL club to speak publicly against the Rabbitohs expulsion at the end of the 1999 season.

''They were a brother club and they were a great club,'' said long serving Canterbury director Arthur Coorey, whose cousins Jim and Peter Lahood were on the Souths board. ''We weren't going to let them die, we fought with them all along.''

Coorey revealed in Wednesday's Herald how the Bulldogs were the main rival to Russell Crowe's $42,000 bid for the bell used in the first league game in 1908 at an auction to raise funds for Souths' legal bills.

Former Canterbury Leagues Club boss Gary McIntyre was also sitting at the table of Bulldogs officials at the function, held at Sydney Convention Centre on November 9, 1999.

''I made quite clear to the compere, Ray Martin, and I am sure he announced it to the function that we never intended to keep the bell,'' McIntyre said. ''It was a very important symbol of rugby league and it was also a treasured item of the South Sydney club, so we were going to donate it back to them. Canterbury went to the function specifically to support Souths, financially and morally, during their darkest hour.

''When I was phoned by the media about why our club was attending when no other club was attending I responded that Canterbury will be attending, Souths is a great club and it will be a shame if Canterbury did not attend. We admired their fighting spirit and we supported their endeavours to get back in the comp. We thought they were unfairly excluded and supported them entirely.''

The black-tie event was the first of many Souths fund-raisers Bulldogs officials or supporters attended, including one at Bankstown in 2001 at which Hazem El Masri made a surprise appearance.


To gain reinstatement, Souths had to fund three costly court cases, losing the first two but winning the third, and News Ltd and the NRL expected the other clubs to help them.

''Don't forget that we had been on the Super League side but we were the only club to my knowledge that refused to put in an affidavit and we said we were not prepared to give any evidence whatsoever against Souths because we supported Souths' inclusion,'' McIntyre said.

Coorey said the Bulldogs had only agreed to join News Ltd's breakaway Super League competition to ensure their own future. ''We saw the plans for Super League and we weren't in it. They were going to scrub us, too, so it was about our survival,'' he said. ''We made sure we survived and then we tried to help Souths.''

Among the plans devised by the Canterbury board to ensure Souths' survival was a development proposal on the Gold Coast that they considered offering to the Rabbitohs as a new home.

''I don't know if even George [Piggins] knows this but Canterbury looked at a site opposite Coolangatta beach as a potential second club on the Gold Coast,'' McIntyre said. ''We had discussions amongst our directors about helping Souths to have an eventual club on the Gold Coast with an objective of one day being re-admitted to the competition from the Gold Coast. They could have been a feeder club to us in the meantime.''


Souths and Canterbury have long had a close association and after the Rabbitohs were expelled Piggins helped direct his nephew Braith Anasta to Belmore.

After Souths won the third court case and were granted readmission to the NRL, the Bulldogs invited Piggins, his wife, Noelene, and other members of the Rabbitohs board to ANZ Stadium for their next home match on July 8, 2001, and a tribute to them was played on the big screen.

The two clubs are also closely connected through their ties with the Lebanese community. The Lahood brothers and Coorey's families came from the village of Kfarsghab as part of the first wave of Lebanese migration to Australia in the 1890s and settled in Redfern.

''We have been with Souths since day one,'' Jim Lahood said. ''The next generation moved out in the 1920s and were instrumental in the start up of Canterbury.

''Through mine and Peter's urging of not only Arthur but also others at Canterbury, they came to the conclusion that there was something terribly wrong with what was happening to Souths and their supporters.


''Even though legally they couldn't break away from the other clubs, morally they felt that they wanted Souths back in the comp and their contribution was quite significant.

''There was the financial support … but even more important was the fact one of the most popular and powerful clubs … had broken ranks and said: 'We are changing our stance, we don't want Souths out of the comp, we think it's better if Souths are back in'.''


Share on Facebook
 

ThingFish

Juniors
Messages
1,665
Great reminder. I remember the Lebanese community support at the Souths v USA Tomahawks game was immense. So much so they had a Lebanon v Souths game soon after.

It’s a shame my nieces are still too scared to go to Bulldogs games because of a bad experience with their fans when they were young. It has turned me off their club now as well. Different generation back then.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ___

Souths Till I Die

First Grade
Messages
5,957
I think a former member was talking about this when he was still around on the forums. Never knew about it until then. That article was a great read and even though I’m a Souths supporter I’ll be cheering for the Bulldogs whenever they’re not playing Souths.
 

Go Bunnies

Juniors
Messages
279
I don’t see it this way. Bulldogs were one of the first Sydney teams to join the Broncos and jump to Super League under Peter Moore. If they had stayed loyal to the ARL along with Cronulla etc, the Super League war may never have happened and Souths might never have been kicked out in the first place.
I won’t support any teams who went to Super League
 

___

Juniors
Messages
861
I don’t see it this way. Bulldogs were one of the first Sydney teams to join the Broncos and jump to Super League under Peter Moore. If they had stayed loyal to the ARL along with Cronulla etc, the Super League war may never have happened and Souths might never have been kicked out in the first place.
I won’t support any teams who went to Super League
This happened after the SP war in a united competition. I hated SL, pretty much every fan did. In fact perhaps the only fans that look at SL as being an official competition are Broncos fans because they won.

Also, Bulfrog was not the Bulldogs CEO at the time so I think it's very unfair that you blame him.
 

sensesmaybenumbed

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,930
I don’t see it this way. Bulldogs were one of the first Sydney teams to join the Broncos and jump to Super League under Peter Moore. If they had stayed loyal to the ARL along with Cronulla etc, the Super League war may never have happened and Souths might never have been kicked out in the first place.
I won’t support any teams who went to Super League
Exactly. They only had the luxury of cheap lip service after doing the entire game a disservice by supporting bronco league.
 

Go Bunnies

Juniors
Messages
279
This happened after the SP war in a united competition. I hated SL, pretty much every fan did. In fact perhaps the only fans that look at SL as being an official competition are Broncos fans because they won.

Also, Bulfrog was not the Bulldogs CEO at the time so I think it's very unfair that you blame him.
Oh sorry - I thought he was CEO. Who was the CEO at the time?
I know it was after the Super League war but SL would never have happened if the Sydney clubs had stood firm with the ARL.
 

___

Juniors
Messages
861
Oh sorry - I thought he was CEO. Who was the CEO at the time?
I know it was after the Super League war but SL would never have happened if the Sydney clubs had stood firm with the ARL.
I think at the time the CEO was Bob Hagen. I know he was CEO until 2002 but not sure when he started. @Timmah?
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,897
Moore was CEO til 1995, retired after our premiership win and died in 2000.

Hagan took over as CEO from 1996, moving on due to the cap scandal in 2002. From there - Mortimer, Noad, Greenberg, Castle and now Hill.

Moore was certainly a vital cog in the SL war's early days but had long since retired by the time it became a reality in 1997.

Either way I think the old "Super League good, ARL bad" attitude is fraught with simplicity, it was a far more complex issue than that.
 

Go Bunnies

Juniors
Messages
279
I think at the time the CEO was Bob Hagen. I know he was CEO until 2002 but not sure when he started. @Timmah?
Actually I just looked it up.Bullfrog was director and chief executive of Canterbury Bankstown at the time plus also a director of the ARL
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,897
Actually I just looked it up.Bullfrog was director and chief executive of Canterbury Bankstown at the time plus also a director of the ARL
Retired in 1995 so didn't really see it through per se, and had passed by the time Souths were on the outer.
 

___

Juniors
Messages
861
If you look at the way the NRL now, it's a joke really. A dogs breakfast. Now I'm certainly not saying we need another breakaway comp, but if one were to occur these days, it would be completely different from SL, and perhaps in a way be the kick the NRL to get into gear.
 
Messages
15,545
If you look at the way the NRL now, it's a joke really. A dogs breakfast. Now I'm certainly not saying we need another breakaway comp, but if one were to occur these days, it would be completely different from SL, and perhaps in a way be the kick the NRL to get into gear.

Super League ruined any chance of a breakaway competition fixing Rugby League. I don't think you will ever see that sort of situation again.

I'm 100% certain that the NRL know that the competition is not set up in an ideal way but I think you'll find that they play the long game in order to fix it.

They would have an ideal model in mind and they'll sit back and wait until teams go broke in order to then shuffle things around to a more ideal set up.

If, for example, a team like the Sharks were to succumb to the current issues plaguing the club, you won't see an NRL bail out to keep them as they are. The NRL would probably offer them an incentive to move to a more ideal location.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ___

Mr Spock!

Referee
Messages
22,502
Oh sorry - I thought he was CEO. Who was the CEO at the time?
I know it was after the Super League war but SL would never have happened if the Sydney clubs had stood firm with the ARL.

Yeah but the ARL clubs were ALL against us in the court case.
 

Mr Spock!

Referee
Messages
22,502
Bulldogs were the only team who didn't support kicking us out (all the other clubs provided lawyers against us in our court case), were the only club to sign our petition for re-instatement.
Bulldogs participated in our fundraising auctions, and after purchasing items from Souths history then donated them back to the club.
 

Latest posts

Top