$BW to Roosters in 2013

[adamkungl]

LOL, so in summary no you can't provide 9 players your club produced into first grade only to be bought by other clubs (3 of which your club possible 4)

LOL CLASSIC.

We've been through this before champ, Roosters don't lose players they want to keep.

But this being your criteria:

You can list 9 players that the roosters have lost that have all represented their country that were THEIR product and were bought to play elsewhere?

Piece of piss. You're going all the way back to 04, and including players that weren't necessarily poached (SBW wasn't poached, nor Maitua. Actually, most of those players left your club because it's a shit club...)

Shannon Hegarty
Brian Fletcher
Sia Soliola
Setiamata Sa
Anthony Tupou
Micheal Crocker
Ben Hannant
David Shillington


Australian/NZ reps before leaving Easts

edit: I had Wingy in there, forgot he played for lol@souffs before they got booted :lol: I'm sure I'll think of someone. Nevertheless, 8 is still the same amount that DoggiesBro posted, because Isaac Luke sure as shit doesnt count.

 

[DoggiesBro]

4. Shannon Hegarty
6. Setaimata Sa
8. David Shillington
10. Ben Hannant
11. Sia Soliola
12. Anthony Tupou
13. Michael Crocker
14. Lopini Paea
15. Mickey Paea

Not including hooker since Issac Luke never played first grade for the bulldogs

BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.

Paeas played for their country? No halfback?

So hrmm

Idris, Anasta, Thurston, Asotasi, Luke, Price, Myles, SBW, Mataiu, Mason

VS

Hegarty LOL, Sa, NOONE, Shillington, NOONE, Hannant, Tupou, Crocker, Solila BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHHAH

You can't do it for any club. Your club offers nothing. Notice that half of those players aren't even in the NRL and are SHIT.... While all the players listed for the dogs bar one who has retired, and two who are yet to sign with a club are in the nrl.

 

[sputneek]

As I said before, your club cheated the cap, so I did it with a club that also cheated the cap, the Storm. And I did it for the Roosters, our players obviously won't be as good. Most people reading this forum would see what a one-eyed idiot you are, so it doesn't bother me. Now show me evidence of Issac Luke playing first grade for the Dogs, since he is such a vital part of your 9 player argument.

And no halfback cause Thurston played 75% of matches for you from the bench, the rest mainly at 5/8. So how does he classify as a halfback for you?

 

[Easts R #1]

Soward [better than any dogs half] rep
ben Hannatt [ better then any dogs prop] rep
george rose [also better than any dogs prop] rep
mark mini [better than any dogs back rower] rep
Ashley harrison [ better than any dogslock] rep
Mickey paea [bought by dogs ] rep
sisa waqa current storm winger
Anthony toupou [better than any dogs backrower] rep
mick croker [ better than any dogs back rower] rep
david shillington [ better than any dogs prop] rep
Richard faaoso knights
shane shackelton [ better than any dogs props hahahaha ]
sandor earl [panthers wnger better than any dogs wingers]
John williams cowboys 2008 highest points scorer[ thurston was in that team LOL]

ALL DEBUT IN 1ST GRADE FOR ROOSTERS AND STILL PLAYING NRL! [ better than any dogs you mentioned]....sorry i forgot; LOL@ BRO!

Does this only include players currently playing nrl?? if not i could add a heap more...

 

[sputneek]

Does this only include players currently playing nrl?? if not i could add a heap more...

He said they have to have debuted for us, and played for their country, and moved on.

 

[adamkungl]

BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.

Paeas played for their country? No halfback?

So hrmm

Idris, Anasta, Thurston, Asotasi, Luke, Price, Myles, SBW, Mataiu, Mason

VS

Hegarty LOL, Sa, NOONE, Shillington, NOONE, Hannant, Tupou, Crocker, Solila BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHHAH

You can't do it for any club. Your club offers nothing. Notice that half of those players aren't even in the NRL and are SHIT.... While all the players listed for the dogs bar one who has retired, and two who are yet to sign with a club are in the nrl.

Your criteria never included
a) specific positions
b) opinions on whether they are shit or not
c) whether they have retired or are still in the NRL

Stop moving the goalposts f**kwit.

 

[sputneek]

Your criteria never included
a) specific positions
b) opinions on whether they are shit or not
c) whether they have retired or are still in the NRL

Stop moving the goalposts f**kwit.

I hate playing his games but he's basically begging to be proven wrong. Notice how he completely avoids the fact that Luke never played firsts with the dogs despite that being a significant part of his argument.

 

[adamkungl]

I hate playing his games but he's basically begging to be proven wrong. Notice how he completely avoids the fact that Luke never played firsts with the dogs despite that being a significant part of his argument.

Too stupid for words.

Bet it burns that the Roosters currently, and for the last few years, have had far more debutants in the top side than the mercenary Boughtdogs have.

 

[DoggiesBro]

Your criteria never included
a) specific positions
b) opinions on whether they are shit or not
c) whether they have retired or are still in the NRL

Stop moving the goalposts f**kwit.

Did you miss the part where i put the numbers of the positions down?

LOL IDIOT.

 

[DoggiesBro]

Too stupid for words.

Bet it burns that the Roosters currently, and for the last few years, have had far more debutants in the top side than the mercenary Boughtdogs have.

By buying them from other clubs before they debut and paying overs like Tasi? :lol::lol::lol:

 

[DoggiesBro]

Claiming earl and john williams :lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

 

[sputneek]

By buying them from other clubs before they debut and paying overs like Tasi? :lol::lol::lol:

4. Idris - Newcastle
6. Anasta - Souths
7. Thurston - Queensland
8. Asotai - Auckland
9. Luke - NZ
10. Price - Queensland
11. SBW - NZ
12. Myles - Queensland
13. Mataiu - Souths

14. Mason - Newcastle

 

[Easts R #1]

He said they have to have debuted for us, and played for their country, and moved on.

change the goal posts again LOL! the dumb f**k is claiming;
LUKE;debut rnd 12 2007 v storm @ olympic park for SOUTHS
THURSTON; played rep when he left and went to COWBOYS
MYLES; played rep when he left and went to ROOSTERS
I new he was geniused but now he's proving to be; Drug f**ked..

 

[Easts R #1]

BRO'S favourite song; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zzrh5GftgzM
make sure you view this..describes him well!

 

[adamkungl]

Did you miss the part where i put the numbers of the positions down?

LOL IDIOT.

Wasn't relevant. Afterwards you repeatedly asked for 9 players, International reps, that had left the club, with no stipulation on position. But hey, throw in origin reps too and we can include players like Soward. I'm sure there are more.

By buying them from other clubs before they debut and paying overs like Tasi? :lol::lol::lol:

1 example... vs Mini, SKD, Pearce, Perrett, Kennedy, Cordner, Cherrington, Symonds, Friend...at least (off the top of my head), just from our 2011-12 sides. No poaching for overs there.

4. Idris - Newcastle
6. Anasta - Souths
7. Thurston - Queensland
8. Asotai - Auckland
9. Luke - NZ
10. Price - Queensland
11. SBW - NZ
12. Myles - Queensland
13. Mataiu - Souths

14. Mason - Newcastle

:lol: faaail

 

[Ram Man]

change the goal posts again LOL! the dumb f**k is claiming;
LUKE;debut rnd 12 2007 v storm @ olympic park for SOUTHS
THURSTON; played rep when he left and went to COWBOYS
MYLES; played rep when he left and went to ROOSTERS
I new he was geniused but now he's proving to be; Drug f**ked..

He also claimed it was the roosters fault that SBW left the dogs

 

[RWB]

Claiming earl and john williams :lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

What's wrong with claiming Sandor Earl?

 

[RWB]

Off the top of my head... who played first grade this year and spent some part of their career before their first grade debut at our club.

1.
2. John Williams
3. Blake Ayshford
4. Iosia Soliola
5. Sandor Earl
6. Jamie Soward
7. Ben Jones
8. Ben Hannant
9. Heath Le'strange
10. David Shillington
11. Anthony Tupou
12. Lewis Brown
13. Michael Crocker

14. Rusell Packer
15. George Rose
16. James Tamou
17. Chris Flannery

Mickey Paea
Lopini Paea
Shane Shackleton
Nigel Plum

Pretty strong in the forwards... not so much the backs :lol:

Most clubs could put something similar like this together though, it's nothing unusual or special. Unlike Doggiesbro though we haven't used this continual loss of players an excuse to not continue developing talent (of our starting 13 only 1 or 2 will have debuted at a club other than the Roosters).

 

[DoggiesBro]

Off the top of my head... who played first grade this year and spent some part of their career before their first grade debut at our club.

1.
2. John Williams
3. Blake Ayshford
4. Iosia Soliola
5. Sandor Earl
6. Jamie Soward
7. Ben Jones
8. Ben Hannant
9. Heath Le'strange
10. David Shillington
11. Anthony Tupou
12. Lewis Brown
13. Michael Crocker

14. Rusell Packer
15. George Rose
16. James Tamou
17. Chris Flannery

Mickey Paea
Lopini Paea
Shane Shackleton
Nigel Plum

Pretty strong in the forwards... not so much the backs :lol:

Most clubs could put something similar like this together though, it's nothing unusual or special. Unlike Doggiesbro though we haven't used this continual loss of players an excuse to not continue developing talent (of our starting 13 only 1 or 2 will have debuted at a club other than the Roosters).

What a bunch of talentless hacks, noone except the broncos and storm could list the talent that the dogs have produced to be playing at the highest level of the game including the best halfback in the world, along with some of the best forwards.

The roosters have the same amount of developed talent in their squad as the dogs do right now and that says something because as we have seen the dogs have had several high profile players purchased and the roosters biggest names are from OTHER clubs.

 

[Ladmate]

Off the top of my head... who played first grade this year and spent some part of their career before their first grade debut at our club.

1.
2. John Williams
3. Blake Ayshford
4. Iosia Soliola
5. Sandor Earl
6. Jamie Soward
7. Ben Jones
8. Ben Hannant
9. Heath Le'strange
10. David Shillington
11. Anthony Tupou
12. Lewis Brown
13. Michael Crocker

14. Rusell Packer
15. George Rose
16. James Tamou
17. Chris Flannery

Mickey Paea
Lopini Paea
Shane Shackleton
Nigel Plum

Pretty strong in the forwards... not so much the backs :lol:

Most clubs could put something similar like this together though, it's nothing unusual or special. Unlike Doggiesbro though we haven't used this continual loss of players an excuse to not continue developing talent (of our starting 13 only 1 or 2 will have debuted at a club other than the Roosters).

Blake Ayshford debuted for the Tigers, not for the Roosters. Same with James Tamou with the Cowboys off the top of my head. Unless I am completely misunderstanding the bolded part.