What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Cap Transparency

unforgiven

Bench
Messages
3,138
This is why they should bring in a points system. So it's not what they are actually being paid that is capped (although you could cap that as well just as now) but each individual player in each 30 man squad is assessed from 1 to 100 and the total is capped. This would also solve the TPA issue.
Solves nothing, who would rate the players?
 

KeepingTheFaith

Referee
Messages
25,235
No thanks to a points system. Would be a disaster.

I don't see any reason why having players cap included amount shouldn't be public knowledge.

It wouldn't stop anyone if they desperately wanted to cheat, but it might help keep some clubs/managers a little more honest.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,888
No thanks to a points system. Would be a disaster.

I don't see any reason why having players cap included amount shouldn't be public knowledge.

It wouldn't stop anyone if they desperately wanted to cheat, but it might help keep some clubs/managers a little more honest.

it would also make the players accountable. If they took more money than they know is on the playlist then they know they are cheating and should face penalties alongside the club.
 

Knight76

Juniors
Messages
2,045
it would also make the players accountable. If they took more money than they know is on the playlist then they know they are cheating and should face penalties alongside the club.

The players know they are cheating now. But the NRL is weak and does not want to blow up the league by enforcing the salary cap on players.

Players have said they knowingly sign contracts that give them X amount of dollars and with X additional in TPA. Maloney on TV really forked up when he said in an interview he was waiting on some TPA's to be sorted for his contract before he signed.

Enforcing this is easy, the NRL just does not want to out of fear of losing their stars to Union. So they let players be signed for less, with cap free TPA being used and look the other way.

Enforcing this is as simple as making players, and player agents sign a stat dec declaring every penny the player is paid to play for the club each time a contract is signed. Then, down the track if a player is found out to have lied, the club has rorted the cap, the player gets deregistered.

And, the next argument is players don't know what the club is declaring to the NRL. Sure, fair enough, but the player can insist all his money be on the cap, or can work with the club to ensure all his payments declared in his stat dec are all he is being paid by the club, and declared to the NRL.

But, I don't believe for a second, when a player signs a contact, that he is not aware of every dollar he is earning. If the player declares all of that money as his payment to play for club it all counts under the cap.
 

jack coburn

Juniors
Messages
475
For mine it’s pretty simple. Make each player sign a stat dec stating that the money registered with the NRL is all they or family members are receiving from the game. Anyone caught lying immediate 2 year ban and the club loses 2 mill off the salary cap for 2 years.
 

forby

Juniors
Messages
2,137
Club administrators don’t want salaries published. It would reveal the mistakes they make in paying overs to some players.
Players don’t want to other players to know how much they are getting paid. It could cause disruptions and jealousies in clubs.
NRL don’t want it because it would show who the ‘favoured’ and ‘cheating’ clubs are!
Fans want it, but unless TPAs and other perks such as free use of cars etc are included it doesn’t mean a whole lot.
 

Latest posts

Top