What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Change to the kickoff rule 2026

T-Boon

Coach
Messages
19,197
we should rank the biggest changes to the "fabric of the game" of the last 30 years and see how many of them are due to head coaches having too much time on their hands. I would go:
1. wrestling / gang tackling (100% coaches).
2. scrums being a turnover.
 
Messages
18,411
Last 30 years?

Sorry but the two, in my opinion, would be:

- 40/20 kicks (started in 1997 wiuth the ARL competition and was in the NRL from its formartion in 1998; and
- 6 again rule.
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
48,843


Peter V’landys won’t back down from the NRL’s controversial kick-off rule change ahead of a showdown with the game’s 17 clubs in his bid to deliver the code a record multi-billion dollar broadcast bonanza.
NRL chief Andrew Abdo is expected to meet with clubs on Wednesday to discuss feedback on a number of proposed rule changes set to be implemented in the 2026 Premiership.

The clubs have unitedly rejected the NRL’s proposal to change the traditional restart of play, giving the team that concedes a try the option to either kick off or receive the ball.

While ARL Commission chairman V’landys has the backing of super coach Wayne Bennett, the clubs have broadly rejected the mooted change.

However V’landys isn’t about to back down without a fight, insisting the commission will do what it believes is in the best interests of the game on the back of a record-breaking season.

“We are in the consultation period so we’re listening to everybody’s views and once we consider it all we’ll make the decision,” he said.

“We review every season and get feedback from all different aspects – fans, players, and we also had a meeting with six coaches – Wayne Bennett (Rabbitohs), Ivan Cleary (Panthers), Craig Fitzgibbon (Sharks), Ricky Stuart (Raiders), Craig Bellamy (Storm) and Michael Maguire (Broncos).

“They came up with some ideas, we came up with some other ideas, and that’s how it was formulated.

“What people have to understand is that we have to make the game exciting for the fans.

“We had 137 million viewers (in 2019) before we changed the rules (six-again set restarts). Now we’ve got 224 million viewers.

“Our attendances and viewership have increased dramatically because the game is faster and more exciting.”

V’landys and Abdo are in the midst of critical negotiations over the game’s next broadcast deal.

The current agreement expires at the end of this year and V’landys is determined to deliver the NRL its biggest ever contract in excess of $5 billion.

To do that, he believes the NRL must continue to evolve and changing the traditional restart of play – where the team that concedes a try kicks off to the team that scored – will help make the game more exciting.

“If we didn’t make the rule changes we’ve made so far, we wouldn’t be where we are,” he said.

“Sometimes leadership means that you’ve got to make the tough decisions.
“You listen to people but at the end, as custodians, you make the decisions that you believe are in the best interest of the game as a whole.

“Who is to say we can’t increase it by another 30 or 40 million viewers? It might be at its peak, but there’s a lot of good minds that say it isn’t.

“You don’t rest on your laurels just because you’ve had success. That doesn’t mean you become complacent.
“Without the fans, you don’t get the broadcast (revenue). The more fans you have, the more money the game gets.
“You have to continue to look at the game, review the game and make sure that we’ve got it at its best.

“Any business that doesn’t do that has failed, or will fail. You’ve got to accommodate your audience.”


V’landys’ commission made huge changes to the game in 2020 after Covid forced the competition to be suspended, introducing the six-again rule for set restarts in a bid to speed up play.

The two-point field goal has been another successful change, but V’landys stressed he hadn’t already made his mind up with the kick-off shake-up.

“No, no, no,” he said.
“One thing you have to respect about consultation is that it gives someone an opportunity to make you change your mind. We’re giving them (clubs) the opportunity.

“We haven’t made a final decision. That’s what consultation is about. If we’ve already made a decision, why are we consulting?
“The purpose of consultation is to listen to people’s views and see if they have a strong enough argument not to do it.”
The NRL has some concerns about momentum being hard to turn in games, which has prompted the discussion around changing the restart of play after a try.
V’landys said it would bring a new dimension to the NRL.

“The fact that you can choose to kick off or receive is tactical, which makes it more interesting and brings un predictability to the game,” he said.

“We wanted to make sure that a team doesn’t get momentum and then you can’t reverse it. The other end of the argument is that anyone can make a comeback.
“That’s the sort of thing we’re weighing up at the moment.

“Every single one of the coaches wanted to make (the game) more attractive. They understand the economics of the game.

“If you have a game that nobody watches then you’re not going to get the revenue. The reason we’re going to get record broadcast revenue is because the game is so much more popular now than it was three or four years ago.

“We’re prepared to make changes to satisfy the fans and attract more fans.
“The proof’s in the pudding. The game has never been more popular, ever. We’ve broken all records in the last two years.”

Pretty sure it was also Wayne Bennett who supported the idea of six again after it was trailed in an all stars game
 
Last edited:
Messages
18,411
Honestly that was a good rule change. For the 1 in 10 times it looked great, it was the other 9 times that it was just ugly and you saw why it wasn't attempted that much.

It wasn't removed due to the "ugly" look. It was removed due to the difficulty in the referees had in policing it.
 

PARRA_FAN

Coach
Messages
19,091
I think the last time I saw someone attempt to strike was Steve Walters, I believe Benny Elias was faking a play the ball and Walters kicked him haha.
 

King-Gutho94

Referee
Messages
20,243


Peter V’landys won’t back down from the NRL’s controversial kick-off rule change ahead of a showdown with the game’s 17 clubs in his bid to deliver the code a record multi-billion dollar broadcast bonanza.
NRL chief Andrew Abdo is expected to meet with clubs on Wednesday to discuss feedback on a number of proposed rule changes set to be implemented in the 2026 Premiership.

The clubs have unitedly rejected the NRL’s proposal to change the traditional restart of play, giving the team that concedes a try the option to either kick off or receive the ball.

While ARL Commission chairman V’landys has the backing of super coach Wayne Bennett, the clubs have broadly rejected the mooted change.

However V’landys isn’t about to back down without a fight, insisting the commission will do what it believes is in the best interests of the game on the back of a record-breaking season.

“We are in the consultation period so we’re listening to everybody’s views and once we consider it all we’ll make the decision,” he said.

“We review every season and get feedback from all different aspects – fans, players, and we also had a meeting with six coaches – Wayne Bennett (Rabbitohs), Ivan Cleary (Panthers), Craig Fitzgibbon (Sharks), Ricky Stuart (Raiders), Craig Bellamy (Storm) and Michael Maguire (Broncos).

“They came up with some ideas, we came up with some other ideas, and that’s how it was formulated.

“What people have to understand is that we have to make the game exciting for the fans.

“We had 137 million viewers (in 2019) before we changed the rules (six-again set restarts). Now we’ve got 224 million viewers.

“Our attendances and viewership have increased dramatically because the game is faster and more exciting.”

V’landys and Abdo are in the midst of critical negotiations over the game’s next broadcast deal.

The current agreement expires at the end of this year and V’landys is determined to deliver the NRL its biggest ever contract in excess of $5 billion.

To do that, he believes the NRL must continue to evolve and changing the traditional restart of play – where the team that concedes a try kicks off to the team that scored – will help make the game more exciting.

“If we didn’t make the rule changes we’ve made so far, we wouldn’t be where we are,” he said.

“Sometimes leadership means that you’ve got to make the tough decisions.
“You listen to people but at the end, as custodians, you make the decisions that you believe are in the best interest of the game as a whole.

“Who is to say we can’t increase it by another 30 or 40 million viewers? It might be at its peak, but there’s a lot of good minds that say it isn’t.

“You don’t rest on your laurels just because you’ve had success. That doesn’t mean you become complacent.
“Without the fans, you don’t get the broadcast (revenue). The more fans you have, the more money the game gets.
“You have to continue to look at the game, review the game and make sure that we’ve got it at its best.

“Any business that doesn’t do that has failed, or will fail. You’ve got to accommodate your audience.”


V’landys’ commission made huge changes to the game in 2020 after Covid forced the competition to be suspended, introducing the six-again rule for set restarts in a bid to speed up play.

The two-point field goal has been another successful change, but V’landys stressed he hadn’t already made his mind up with the kick-off shake-up.

“No, no, no,” he said.
“One thing you have to respect about consultation is that it gives someone an opportunity to make you change your mind. We’re giving them (clubs) the opportunity.

“We haven’t made a final decision. That’s what consultation is about. If we’ve already made a decision, why are we consulting?
“The purpose of consultation is to listen to people’s views and see if they have a strong enough argument not to do it.”
The NRL has some concerns about momentum being hard to turn in games, which has prompted the discussion around changing the restart of play after a try.
V’landys said it would bring a new dimension to the NRL.

“The fact that you can choose to kick off or receive is tactical, which makes it more interesting and brings un predictability to the game,” he said.

“We wanted to make sure that a team doesn’t get momentum and then you can’t reverse it. The other end of the argument is that anyone can make a comeback.
“That’s the sort of thing we’re weighing up at the moment.

“Every single one of the coaches wanted to make (the game) more attractive. They understand the economics of the game.

“If you have a game that nobody watches then you’re not going to get the revenue. The reason we’re going to get record broadcast revenue is because the game is so much more popular now than it was three or four years ago.

“We’re prepared to make changes to satisfy the fans and attract more fans.
“The proof’s in the pudding. The game has never been more popular, ever. We’ve broken all records in the last two years.”

Pretty sure it was also Wayne Bennett who supported the idea of six again after it was trailed in an all stars game
Yet that's the Poll from the article is it really what the fans want PVL

1768347067606.png
 

T-Boon

Coach
Messages
19,197
What does "why change what works mean?" ?
I say it is meaningless statement like: "somebody think of the children".

PVL explains it perfectly in the article.

“The fact that you can choose to kick off or receive is tactical, which makes it more interesting and brings un predictability to the game,” he said.

“We wanted to make sure that a team doesn’t get momentum and then you can’t reverse it. The other end of the argument is that anyone can make a comeback".


Perfect explanation for the idea.
 

T-Boon

Coach
Messages
19,197
I rely think some the coaches don't like it because it is another thing they will get judged on at press conferences when they get beat when they are trying to deflect blame to the refs.
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
48,843
I rely think some the coaches don't like it because it is another thing they will get judged on at press conferences when they get beat when they are trying to deflect blame to the refs.
Exactly

Weak teams and coaches hate change as they are already struggling to keep up as it is
 

Vic Mackey

Referee
Messages
27,477


Peter V’landys won’t back down from the NRL’s controversial kick-off rule change ahead of a showdown with the game’s 17 clubs in his bid to deliver the code a record multi-billion dollar broadcast bonanza.
NRL chief Andrew Abdo is expected to meet with clubs on Wednesday to discuss feedback on a number of proposed rule changes set to be implemented in the 2026 Premiership.

The clubs have unitedly rejected the NRL’s proposal to change the traditional restart of play, giving the team that concedes a try the option to either kick off or receive the ball.

While ARL Commission chairman V’landys has the backing of super coach Wayne Bennett, the clubs have broadly rejected the mooted change.

However V’landys isn’t about to back down without a fight, insisting the commission will do what it believes is in the best interests of the game on the back of a record-breaking season.

“We are in the consultation period so we’re listening to everybody’s views and once we consider it all we’ll make the decision,” he said.

“We review every season and get feedback from all different aspects – fans, players, and we also had a meeting with six coaches – Wayne Bennett (Rabbitohs), Ivan Cleary (Panthers), Craig Fitzgibbon (Sharks), Ricky Stuart (Raiders), Craig Bellamy (Storm) and Michael Maguire (Broncos).

“They came up with some ideas, we came up with some other ideas, and that’s how it was formulated.

“What people have to understand is that we have to make the game exciting for the fans.

“We had 137 million viewers (in 2019) before we changed the rules (six-again set restarts). Now we’ve got 224 million viewers.

“Our attendances and viewership have increased dramatically because the game is faster and more exciting.”

V’landys and Abdo are in the midst of critical negotiations over the game’s next broadcast deal.

The current agreement expires at the end of this year and V’landys is determined to deliver the NRL its biggest ever contract in excess of $5 billion.

To do that, he believes the NRL must continue to evolve and changing the traditional restart of play – where the team that concedes a try kicks off to the team that scored – will help make the game more exciting.

“If we didn’t make the rule changes we’ve made so far, we wouldn’t be where we are,” he said.

“Sometimes leadership means that you’ve got to make the tough decisions.
“You listen to people but at the end, as custodians, you make the decisions that you believe are in the best interest of the game as a whole.

“Who is to say we can’t increase it by another 30 or 40 million viewers? It might be at its peak, but there’s a lot of good minds that say it isn’t.

“You don’t rest on your laurels just because you’ve had success. That doesn’t mean you become complacent.
“Without the fans, you don’t get the broadcast (revenue). The more fans you have, the more money the game gets.
“You have to continue to look at the game, review the game and make sure that we’ve got it at its best.

“Any business that doesn’t do that has failed, or will fail. You’ve got to accommodate your audience.”


V’landys’ commission made huge changes to the game in 2020 after Covid forced the competition to be suspended, introducing the six-again rule for set restarts in a bid to speed up play.

The two-point field goal has been another successful change, but V’landys stressed he hadn’t already made his mind up with the kick-off shake-up.

“No, no, no,” he said.
“One thing you have to respect about consultation is that it gives someone an opportunity to make you change your mind. We’re giving them (clubs) the opportunity.

“We haven’t made a final decision. That’s what consultation is about. If we’ve already made a decision, why are we consulting?
“The purpose of consultation is to listen to people’s views and see if they have a strong enough argument not to do it.”
The NRL has some concerns about momentum being hard to turn in games, which has prompted the discussion around changing the restart of play after a try.
V’landys said it would bring a new dimension to the NRL.

“The fact that you can choose to kick off or receive is tactical, which makes it more interesting and brings un predictability to the game,” he said.

“We wanted to make sure that a team doesn’t get momentum and then you can’t reverse it. The other end of the argument is that anyone can make a comeback.
“That’s the sort of thing we’re weighing up at the moment.

“Every single one of the coaches wanted to make (the game) more attractive. They understand the economics of the game.

“If you have a game that nobody watches then you’re not going to get the revenue. The reason we’re going to get record broadcast revenue is because the game is so much more popular now than it was three or four years ago.

“We’re prepared to make changes to satisfy the fans and attract more fans.
“The proof’s in the pudding. The game has never been more popular, ever. We’ve broken all records in the last two years.”

Pretty sure it was also Wayne Bennett who supported the idea of six again after it was trailed in an all stars game

PVL basically admitting that the stupid kick off rule is being driven by 9/Fox. They don't want blow outs as viewers switch off if its 30-0 at halftime.
 

Chins

First Grade
Messages
5,069
He mentions the unpredictability but do we honestly believe that the team conceding a try, leading by 6 points with 2 minutes to go, will decide to kick off?
Well Penrith's only real weakness is defending short kickoffs and drop-outs so maybe we would.
 

T-Boon

Coach
Messages
19,197
He mentions the unpredictability but do we honestly believe that the team conceding a try, leading by 6 points with 2 minutes to go, will decide to kick off?
Maybe. They would have to consider it. Especially if the coming back team has spent a lot of time working on short kick offs and does them well.
 

Dogs Of War

Coach
Messages
13,822
Maybe. They would have to consider it. Especially if the coming back team has spent a lot of time working on short kick offs and does them well.

So not South's then. Which is surprising that Bennett is so for it the rule change. South's have the worst short drop outs by far.
 

T-Boon

Coach
Messages
19,197
PVL basically admitting that the stupid kick off rule is being driven by 9/Fox. They don't want blow outs as viewers switch off if its 30-0 at halftime.
I think PVL is saying it is a slightly better rule than the existing one and potentially a lot more entertaining to the fans and thus could/will help ratings.

I think we should go back to 6 again if you cross the opponents try line but are held up. That should be rewarded with 6 again.
 

Dogs Of War

Coach
Messages
13,822
I think we should go back to 6 again if you cross the opponents try line but are held up. That should be rewarded with 6 again.
Then teams would just try a lot more one out barging plays with multiple runners. No one wants to watch that.

And the reward for the defence currently is that they attacking team gets moved back to the 10m line. It's a fine balance between attack and defence, and no one wants to see touch footy. We all know that for the better teams, a few sets on an oppositions goal line tends to result in a try. Lets not make it worse.

Also please stop spamming PVL with your ideas. Seems his spam filter is letting a few through.
 
Last edited:
Top